Kelsey defense leads to more questions

The criminal case against Dutchess County Legislator Michael Kelsey (R-25) has been troubling from the start. Accused of one count of first-degree sexual abuse and two misdemeanor counts of endangering the welfare of a child, Kelsey’s attorney, Gary Greenwald, has recently filed a notice of intent stating his client has diminished mental capacity and is therefore not responsible for any possible crimes. (For full story turn to Page A1.)

When asked directly if the filing should be seen as an indication of guilt, Kelsey said, “Not at all.”

OK. But certainly the notice of intent raises more questions than it answers.

According to the filing, Kelsey has multiple mental disorders, including: childhood neglect and extended maternal separation, dysthymic disorder, cyclothymic disorder and anxious distress, obsessive compulsive disorder and depressive personality disorder.

Dysthymia reportedly results in trouble concentrating and making decisions.

Cyclothymia can reportedly lead to poor judgment that can result in risky behavior or unwise choices.

The claim is that because of these mental health issues, Kelsey “lacks criminal responsibility” and that his mental disorders “will show lack of specific intent  to commit the crimes of sexual abuse in the first degree, attempted sexual abuse in the first degree, forcible touching and endangering the welfare of a child.”

That’s saying a lot.

It’s not taking into account, however, the reported victims in the case. Would the conditions stated in Kelsey’s notice of intent morally excuse him from any wrongdoing? Since Kelsey denied it is an admission of guilt does that mean we’re misunderstanding its purpose as a defense in the case? Hopefully clarification will be forthcoming. 

A Salt Point resident and attorney, Kelsey was also a professor of philosophy at Marist College before the charges against him were made public. Marist promptly cut ties with Kelsey following his December 2014 arrest.

He has, however, maintained his seat with the Dutchess County Legislature. Though his colleagues have repeatedly called for Kelsey to step down, he has refused to do so. In fact, he’s even running for re-election this November and will face off against Republican Committee-backed Sandra Washburn in the September primary.

Dutchess County Republican leaders tried to keep Kelsey off the GOP primary ballot, but he prevailed in a court and will indeed be on the Republican primary ballot.

Nevertheless, relying on a defense of diminished mental capacity due to mental illness leads one to question whether Kelsey is capable of serving competently in office. Certainly if he’s lacking proper judgment it should concern his constituents.

The reality is, though, that Kelsey has been doing a pretty good job in office. He attends local town board meetings regularly and frequently attends various regional events. He continues to fight for his constituents’ needs, most recently undertaking a campaign to make crossings along the Harlem Valley Rail Trail safer for pedestrians and cyclists. And he is optimistically running for re-election.

These are all things that point to Kelsey as a productive and valuable member of society. But if he’s not capable of discerning between right and wrong, how can we trust him to serve in office? It’s not to say that he shouldn’t serve, and we must strive to respect the innocent-until-proven-guilty mantra, but it does raise important questions about the wisdom of Kelsey’s efforts to remain in office.

It’s a sad realization, but it seems that Kelsey’s recent court filing has revealed some important issues. Always an advocate for those in need of mental health care, it now is apparent that Kelsey is in need of such care himself. And, it must be stressed, seeking mental health care is nothing to be ashamed of. We hope that Kelsey gets the care he needs and is treated fairly in the interim, and that justice — whatever that amounts to — is ultimately served.

Latest News

Jacob assumes leadership role at William Pitt Sotheby’s Litchfield Hills offices

Eddie Jacob was recently promoted to Assistant Brokerage Manager for four Litchfield Hills offices of William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty.

Photo provided

William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty has appointed Eddie Jacob as Assistant Brokerage Manager for its four Litchfield Hills offices, the company announced on Nov. 19.

In his new role, Jacob will support agents and help oversee operations in the firm’s Kent, Litchfield, Salisbury and Washington Depot brokerages.

Keep ReadingShow less
Winter sports season approaches at HVRHS

Mohawk Mountain was making snow the first week of December. The slopes host practices and meets for the HVRHS ski team.

By Riley Klein

FALLS VILLAGE — After concluding a successful autumn of athletics, Housatonic Valley Regional High School is set to field teams in five sports this winter.

Basketball

Keep ReadingShow less
Bears headline DEEP forum in Sharon; attendees call for coexistence, not hunting

A mother bear and her cubs move through a backyard in northwest Connecticut, where residents told DEEP that bear litters are now appearing more frequently.

By James H. Clark

SHARON — About 40 people filled the Sharon Audubon Center on Wednesday, Dec. 3, to discuss black bears — and most attendees made clear that they welcome the animals’ presence. Even as they traded practical advice on how to keep bears out of garages, porches and trash cans, residents repeatedly emphasized that they want the bears to stay and that the real problem lies with people, not wildlife.

The Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP) convened the meeting as the first in a series of regional Bear Management Listening Sessions, held at a time when Connecticut is increasingly divided over whether the state should authorize a limited bear hunt. Anticipating the potential for heated exchanges, DEEP opened the evening with strict ground rules designed to prevent confrontations: speakers were limited to three minutes, directed to address only the panel of DEEP officials, and warned that interruptions or personal attacks would not be tolerated.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kent unveils two new 'smart bins' to boost composting efforts

Rick Osborne, manager of the Kent Transfer Station, deposits the first bag of food scraps into a new organics “smart bin.” HRRA Executive Director Jennifer Heaton-Jones stands at right, with Transfer Station staff member Rob Hayes at left.

By Ruth Epstein

KENT — Residents now have access to around-the-clock food-scrap composting thanks to two newly installed organics “smart bins,” unveiled during a ribbon-cutting ceremony Monday morning, Dec. 1.

Rick Osborne, manager of the Kent Transfer Station, placed the first bag of food scraps into the smart bin located at 3 Railroad St. A second bin has been installed outside the Transfer Station gate, allowing 24/7 public access even when the facility is closed.

Keep ReadingShow less