Debate grows over who should evaluate teachers


 

FALLS VILLAGE - A group of department chairs at Housatonic Valley Regional High School has publicly rebuked Region One Board of Education Chairman Judge Manning and called on him to retract statements he made late last year about the teacher evaluation process at the school.

At a Jan. 7 board meeting, Manning read portions of a letter he received from seven department chairs calling on him to withdraw comments he made at a special board meeting Nov. 20 about the practice at the school of having department heads evaluate teachers.

The department heads pointed to a Nov. 29, 2007, Lakeville Journal article that characterized Manning's thoughts on the issue. According to the article, Manning "noted that all teachers at Housatonic are members of the same labor union and such a common bond could pose a conflict, even if the law permits it."


Teachers object to implications


In a Dec. 4 letter to Manning, the department heads (Scott Fellows, Paul Padua, Peter Vermilyea, Marjorie Becker, Damon Osora, Nur Abdulhayoglu and Ronnie Santorelli) bristled at Manning's suggestion about the possible conflict. They insisted that they take their supervisory responsibilities, for which they receive a stipend, "very seriously" and that belonging "to the same bargaining unit" does not affect their professional judgment.

"To suggest otherwise is to unfairly impugn our integrity," the educators wrote.

The meeting in which Manning made the controversial comments had been called to discuss the release last fall of a report by the New England Association of Schools and Colleges, a regional accrediting organization that put Housatonic on warning for the curriculum and instruction components of its program. Among other things, the report was critical of the teacher evaluation process.


Chairman disagrees


In his verbal response at the Jan. 7 board meeting, Manning said he "has respect for the signers of the letter," but disagreed with them on some key points.

"To say that my questioning the way we choose evaluators is to impugn their integrity... that was not my intention," Manning said. "In fact, I don't think that's the case at all. I still think it could pose a conflict."

Manning quoted from page 25 of the NEASC report, citing complaints by some department chairs that "the process for determining evaluators is counterproductive" and mostly "inconsistent." The report further states that "there is much evidence to suggest that there is an inherent conflict of interest between the improvement of instructional practices and the perception that serving as an evaluator is a perk."

"That information comes from the [school's own] self-study," Manning continued. "And the Board of Education has adopted the NEASC conclusions."

But the department heads stated in their letter that the visiting NEASC committee did not see a conflict in having teachers' union members evaluating each other, as Manning himself suggested in his previous comments.

In their letter, the teachers also noted that the policy of having department heads evaluate teachers was approved by the Board of Education "at the urging of the previous high school principal."

Still, Manning insisted his "comments were not about past practice, but about going forward, looking forward and improving and we need to do that constantly."

Asked if he wished to elaborate on his response to the department heads, Manning declined. So did Fellows, one of the letter writers and the head of the math department.

In an e-mail, Fellows, who is also the faculty representative to the Housatonic Valley Regional Faculty Association, did note that "Housatonic is not unique among schools in Connecticut in having department chairs evaluate teachers. I believe it is a relatively common structure."


How other schools do it


A brief informal survey of some area schools shows them split between department heads and other administrators in performing evaluation duties. At the Litchfield Schools District, which includes Litchfield High School, Director of Curriculum and Instruction Don Johnson said only he and the principals and assistant principals evaluate the district's three schools. And at the Webutuck School District in Millerton and Amenia, N.Y., Superintendent Richard "Nick" Johns reports that the principals evaluate teachers at the district's four schools.

At Region 7 in Winsted, which includes Northwestern Regional High School, Superintendent Clint Montgomery said, "It is our practice to have department chairpersons evaluate staff in their department."

A spokesperson at Wamogo Regional High School, which serves Warren, Morris and Goshen, said district policy permits department heads to evaluate teachers, but few of them do so because they do not yet have the proper certification (known as 092). So the responsibility typically falls to the principal's office.

Region One Assistant Superintendent Tom Gaisford recently conducted an informal survey of 15 school districts in Connecticut - some large, some small.

He found they were almost evenly split between those that allow department chairs to evaluate teachers and those that either did not permit the practice or had not even established the position of department head or its equivalent. When Gaisford was principal of North Canaan Elementary School, he alone evaluated teachers.


Evaluating can taint relationship


Johns, the Webutuck superintendent, said in an e-mail exchange that he is opposed to the practice of having department chairs evaluate teachers, in part because it compromises the mentoring relationship between the two.

"We want the department head to have a relationship with the teachers in the department that is formative in nature - that is, the department head is a coach who is on the same side as the teacher, constantly looking for more effective ways to deliver the curriculum," said Johns.

"Many think the more the merrier when it comes to evaluating teachers," he added. "I do not share this opinion."


Principal is stepping in


Since the NEASC report came out last fall, Housatonic Principal Gretchen Foster has become more active in evaluating and supervising faculty.

"We ask that you retract your comments, as reported in The Lakeville Journal, at the next public meeting of the the Region One Board of Education," the department heads concluded in their letter. Manning declined to do so.

Latest News

To save birds, plant for caterpillars

Fireweed attracts the fabulous hummingbird sphinx moth.

Photo provided by Wild Seed Project

You must figure that, as rough as the cold weather has been for us, it’s worse for wildlife. Here, by the banks of the Housatonic, flocks of dark-eyed juncos, song sparrows, tufted titmice and black-capped chickadees have taken up residence in the boxwood — presumably because of its proximity to the breakfast bar. I no longer have a bird feeder after bears destroyed two versions and simply throw chili-flavored birdseed onto the snow twice a day. The tiny creatures from the boxwood are joined by blue jays, cardinals and a solitary flicker.

These birds will soon enough be nesting, and their babies will require a nonstop diet of caterpillars. This source of soft-bodied protein makes up more than 90 percent of native bird chicks’ diets, with each clutch consuming between 6,000 and 9,000 caterpillars before they fledge. That means we need a lot of caterpillars if we want our bird population to survive.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Stephanie Haboush Plunkett and the home for American illustration

Stephanie Haboush Plunkett

L. Tomaino
"The field of illustration is very close to my heart"
— Stephanie Plunkett

For more than three decades, Stephanie Haboush Plunkett has worked to elevate illustration as a serious art form. As chief curator and Rockwell Center director at the Norman Rockwell Museum in Stockbridge, Massachusetts, she has helped bring national and international attention to an art form long dismissed as merely commercial.

Her commitment to illustration is deeply personal. Plunkett grew up watching her father, Joseph Haboush, an illustrator and graphic designer, work late into the night in his home studio creating art and hand-lettered logos for package designs, toys and licensed-character products for the Walt Disney Co. and other clients.

Keep ReadingShow less
Free film screening and talk on end-of-life care
‘Come See Me in the Good Light’ is nominated for best documentary at this year’s Academy Awards.
Provided

Craig Davis, co-founder and board chair of East Mountain House, an end-of-life care facility in Lakeville, will sponsor a March 5 screening of the documentary “Come See Me in the Good Light” at The Moviehouse in Millerton, followed by a discussion with attendees.

The film, which is nominated for best documentary at this year’s Academy Awards, follows the poet Andrea Gibson and their partner Megan Falley as they are suddenly and unimaginably forced to navigate a terminal illness. The free screening invites audiences to gather not just for a film but for reflection on mortality, healing, connection and the ways communities support one another through difficult life transitions.

Keep ReadingShow less

The power of one tray

The power of one tray

A tray can help group items in a way that looks and feels thoughtful and intentional.

Kerri-Lee Mayland

Winter is a season that invites us to notice our surroundings more closely and crave small, comforting changes rather than big projects.

That’s often when clients ask what they can do to make their homes feel finished or fresh again — without redecorating, renovating or shopping endlessly. My answer: start with one tray.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.