A different take on the oil spill

Corporate risk management in America changed from the need to protect the company to the need to protect the executives and Wall Street. The problem with this change, which took place during the 1980s, is that in the end everyone loses, especially the nation. BP may be a British company, but it has many subsidiaries here and is quoted on the U.S. stock exchange. It is an oil company, one of the Big 5, and anything they do reflects well or badly on the other companies: especially poorly when there is a disaster.

When PanAm went bust, it was not the Lockerbie disaster that caused their demise. It was corporate mismanagement of a situation caused by terrorists, poor PR and, above all, a seeming disdain for the passengers and those killed on the ground over the interests of the company.

PanAm’s top executives all had golden parachutes. The head of PR took his $8 million ’chute in 1987 and swanned off to retirement in Bermuda. What did he care if management left the sinking ship (which they had piloted onto the rocks)? What did any of the directors care if the pension fund of employees was raided to fill the financial void for the Wall Street honchos?

BP is going bust. The management there is to blame. They may not go bust today or tomorrow, and they certainly have plenty of assets (in banks and underground oil), but they also have huge liabilities brought about by the incompetency of the upper management. Seeing the three oilmen testifying before Congress reminded me of the Three Stooges — it was his fault, no it was his, no it was the first guy’s fault — slap, smack, bop, yada yada yada. They have no clue.

It doesn’t matter if, by the time this makes it to print, they have capped the leaking oil (let’s hope). What matters is that upper management is so out of touch with reality, they are so cushioned, so coddled, they have no perspective left for the little things that can bring down a company, no exposure to the minutiae that needs to be cared for to preserve the company, jobs and profits. In short, they are outsiders in their own company.

Let’s take just one person there, CEO Tony Hayward. He’s a nice man, honest but made myopic by his lifestyle and money. Announced in March this year, his BP payment is considered small, just over $6 million, up 41percent from the year before.

OK, let’s make believe this sounds pretty good to you and you’d like to be a CEO. Now what you should remember is that this is a 12-hour-a-day job, six days a week. In return, you get stock options (discounted shares, sometimes 20 percent of real cost), 24-hour-a-day servants at your beck and call, drivers, secretaries, assistants, private planes, limos, food, unlimited restaurant expenses, never having to stand in line anywhere (including the DMV — think of it!), no public transportation ever and full living accommodation expenses (apartments, housing allowances, moving fees, red carpet service). In short, you are the company’s baby and they breastfeed you anything you need to keep you working and happy.

So, what do you do with that money anyway? Assuming 40 percent tax (well, we know that’s not true, but let’s assume), you still have $720 to spend for every waking hour of every day, 52 weeks a year. That’s $70,000 a week. Gee, you have to wait three weeks to buy a Bentley. But why buy a Bentley when you have a BP limo anyway? And a private plane? Nope, don’t need one of those, either. How about a house? But why, when you have company accommodation?

And what about the stock options? Given to you on Jan. 31, you could cash them in the next day and make another couple of tens of millions. So what if you have to pay the government capital gains taxes? It’s all profit, not really salary, the way we consider payday.

So, how does Hayward ever get to know about, care about, his company drilling the ocean floor, 5,000 feet down with blow-out equipment only rated (certified) to 1,500 feet? How does he get to care or know about the drilling company, Transocean, a company they hired to drill a BP well, flying a BP flag with no BP employees to report to him? Why would he instruct BP to care about an oil spill except to somehow recover the oil wellhead, recapture the oil, maximize profits?

If it all goes sour, he’ll have his money, he’ll have a golden parachute and he can retire. There is no incentive, there is no reality check to manage the risk of such disasters until after they happen. Then their answer is to guess, unplanned errors piling on top of one another, while they continue their lifestyle. They are totally insulated, unprepared, totally immune to any consequence except, perhaps, a stoppage of salary if they are fired.

The problem with the Gulf oil spill, perhaps the worst ever anywhere, is that it was preventable, yes, but not preventable at all with no real risk management in place in American business any more — none in place that is beyond risk managing the safety of the executives.

Peter Riva, formerly of Amenia Union, lives in New Mexico.

Latest News

Living History comes alive in Millbrook talk

Bill Jeffway tells an anecdote to a capacity crowd at the Millbrok Library.

Submitted

MILLBROOK — Last Thursday April 18, Bill Jeffway, Executive Director of the Dutchess County Historical Society, delivered a lecture titled “Town of Washington: Antebellum Free Black Community” to a capacity crowd at the Millbrook Library.

A graduate of Wesleyan College, he is the author of “This Place Called Milan and Invisible People, Untold Stories: Voices of Rhinebeck’s Historic Black Community.” He writes regularly for the Northern Dutchess News.

Keep ReadingShow less
Ecology Success Stories:
A Cary Fellow’s optimism

With the ban of DDT, the bald eagle has come back from 417 nesting pairs in 1963 to 71,400 nesting pairs and was removed from the Endangered Species List in 2007.

Seaq68 via Pixabay

MILLBROOK — In today’s world of climate change worry, Peter Groffman, research fellow at the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies in Millbrook, gave a lecture of hope for the future of the environment.

Groffman “studies urban ecology and how climate change alters microbial processes that support plant growth and air and water quality.” He is the president-elect of the Ecological Society of America and teaches at the City University of New York and Brooklyn College.

Keep ReadingShow less
Affordable housing hearing in Salisbury

SALISBURY — The Planning and Zoning Commission (P&Z) will hold a public hearing Monday, May 20, 6:45 on Zoom on the Salisbury Housing Trust’s (SHT) application to build two affordable housing houses on town-owned property on Undermountain Road and Grove Street.

The commission received the application at its April 15 meeting.

Keep ReadingShow less
Hotchkiss hosts interstate Ultimate Frisbee tourney

Luke Warner soared over the Amherst offense to swat down a pass during the Ultimate Mini-Tourney at The Hotchkiss School Saturday, April 20.

Patrick L. Sullivan

LAKEVILLE — On a soggy Saturday, April 20, eight teams competed in an Ultimate Frisbee mini tournament hosted by The Hotchkiss School.

There were teams from New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts and Connecticut. Two middle schools competed against high school junior varsity squads.

Keep ReadingShow less