Execution of American-born cleric raises questions

The assassination by drone of American-born Muslim cleric Anwar al-Awlaki in Yemen raises questions that should disturb anyone who holds the rule of law as essential to protecting individual rights and limiting the arbitrary power of government. The Obama administration alleges that al-Awlaki committed a variety of bad acts, but the key word is “alleges.” We are taught that no one may be jailed, much less executed, on the basis of mere allegations. This goes back at least as far as the Magna Carta in 1215 and is echoed in the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution: “No person shall be … deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.”

Yet al-Awlaki was targeted for assassination by the executive branch of the U.S. government without indictment, trial, or showing of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. President Obama acted as cop, judge, jury and executioner all in one.

One should note that the Fifth Amendment is not restricted to citizens. Over the last decade, the U.S. government has killed many foreigners with missiles fired from aerial drones on the basis of unproven assertions and hearsay, but it took the assassination of an American citizen to get the public’s attention. (A second American, editor Samir Khan, was also killed in the strike on al-Awlaki’s convoy.)

The allegations against al-Awlaki are vague. Until recently he was said to have “inspired” people who went on to commit or attempt acts of violence. These people include Faisal Shahzad, the would-be Times Square car bomber; Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, the failed “underwear bomber” on a plane over Detroit; and Major Nidal Malik Hasan, the mass shooter at Fort Hood. But as Glenn Greenwald points out, the U.S. Supreme Court on two occasions (Brandenburg v. Ohio and NAACP v. Claiborne) ruled that speech advocating or “inspiring” violence is constitutionally protected.

It is only recently that the Obama administration has alluded to al-Awlaki’s connection to the al-Qaeda attacks on Sept. 11, 2001. But this is suspect because, as Greenwald notes, right after 9/11 al-Awlaki was seen as a moderate (still in the United States) and was asked to participate in government-sponsored meetings.

The Obama administration insists that al-Awlaki was, not merely an inspirational cleric, but a figure with operational authority in al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula. Yet, again, this is merely an allegation never proven in a court of law, where evidence can be scrutinized independently and witnesses cross-examined. As the Associated Press reported, “The White House refused to offer evidence of al-Awlaki’s role in terrorism.”

Was al-Awlaki the mastermind the administration suggests he was? Middle East scholar Gregory Johnsen wrote before the assassination, “Contrary to what the Obama administration would have you believe, he has always been a minor figure in Al Qaeda.”

But, some will say, holding the Obama administration to the standards of criminal justice is incorrect, because terrorism is not a crime. It’s an of act war. Even if we accept that dubious claim for the sake of argument, many problems arise. There is no congressional declaration of war, which the Constitution requires. (Past violations cannot justify new violations.) Some advocates of unilateral executive action find authority in Congress’s post-9/11 Authorization for the Use of Military Force, but that doesn’t get them where they want to go. The AUMF states,

“That the President is authorized to use all necessary and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on Sept. 11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons.”

Al-Awlaki does not fall into this category. Moreover, his killing did not occur on a “hot” battlefield. He was in Yemen, whose president is an ally of the U.S. government. Why didn’t Obama ask that he be turned over or send in a force to arrest him? (Hundreds of terrorist suspects have been tried in American courts, and a good percentage have been convicted.)

Oddly, Obama refuses to tell the American people by what authority he ordered the execution, just as he refuses to release any evidence. Apparently, in the administration’s view, that’s none of the public’s business.

Is this any way to run a republic?

 Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation (www.fff.org).

Latest News

Father Joseph Kurnath

LAKEVILLE — Father Joseph G. M. Kurnath, retired priest of the Archdiocese of Hartford, passed away peacefully, at the age of 71, on Sunday, June 29, 2025.

Father Joe was born on May 21, 1954, in Waterbury, Connecticut. He attended kindergarten through high school in Bristol.

Keep ReadingShow less
Club baseball at Fuessenich Park

Travel league baseball came to Torrington Thursday, June 26, when the Berkshire Bears Select Team played the Connecticut Moose 18U squad. The Moose won 6-4 in a back-and-forth game. Two players on the Bears play varsity ball at Housatonic Valley Regional High School: shortstop Anthony Foley and first baseman Wes Allyn. Foley went 1-for-3 at bat with an RBI in the game at Fuessenich Park.

 

  Anthony Foley, rising senior at Housatonic Valley Regional High School, went 1-for-3 at bat for the Bears June 26.Photo by Riley Klein 

 
Siglio Press: Uncommon books at the intersection of art and literature

Uncommon books at the intersection of art and literature.

Richard Kraft

Siglio Press is a small, independent publishing house based in Egremont, Massachusetts, known for producing “uncommon books at the intersection of art and literature.” Founded and run by editor and publisher Lisa Pearson, Siglio has, since 2008, designed books that challenge conventions of both form and content.

A visit to Pearson’s airy studio suggests uncommon work, to be sure. Each of four very large tables were covered with what looked to be thousands of miniature squares of inkjet-printed, kaleidoscopically colored pieces of paper. Another table was covered with dozens of book/illustration-size, abstracted images of deer, made up of colored dots. For the enchanted and the mystified, Pearson kindly explained that these pieces were to be collaged together as artworks by the artist Richard Kraft (a frequent contributor to the Siglio Press and Pearson’s husband). The works would be accompanied by writings by two poets, Elizabeth Zuba and Monica Torre, in an as-yet-to-be-named book, inspired by a found copy of a worn French children’s book from the 1930s called “Robin de Bois” (Robin Hood).

Keep ReadingShow less
Cycling season: A roundup of our region’s rentals and where to ride them

Cyclists head south on the rail trail from Copake Falls.

Alec Linden

After a shaky start, summer has well and truly descended upon the Litchfield, Berkshire and Taconic hills, and there is no better way to get out and enjoy long-awaited good weather than on two wheels. Below, find a brief guide for those who feel the pull of the rail trail, but have yet to purchase their own ten-speed. Temporary rides are available in the tri-corner region, and their purveyors are eager to get residents of all ages, abilities and inclinations out into the open road (or bike path).

For those lucky enough to already possess their own bike, perhaps the routes described will inspire a new way to spend a Sunday afternoon. For more, visit lakevillejournal.com/tag/bike-route to check out two ride-guides from local cyclists that will appeal to enthusiasts of many levels looking for a varied trip through the region’s stunning summer scenery.

Keep ReadingShow less