Fight to win or get out of Afghanistan

With great fanfare, President Obama is looking for a strategy for U.S. military intervention in Afghanistan. The implication is that the United States doesn’t have a strategy now, or that, whatever the strategy is, it isn’t working.

Meanwhile, more aggressive U.S. military operations in Afghanistan have caused a sharp increase in casualties among American troops, and the top general on the scene is reported to have asked for tens of thousands more soldiers to be sent.

Pacifying Afghanistan would require those additional soldiers and many more, plus an oppressive occupation lasting generations to change the country’s backward culture, an occupation that would only intensify resistance.

So the strategic question about Afghanistan isn’t how many more soldiers to send but rather, simply: What’s the point?

u      u      u

Yes, some of the plotters of the 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States found refuge in Afghanistan, if Afghanistan can be considered a refuge. But those attacks were successful not because of any resources drawn from Afghanistan itself but because of the failure of U.S. border and airport security. Border security remains a failure and the country is still full of illegal aliens.

And yes, a native regime in Afghanistan, replacing the regime sustained by the United States, could destabilize its neighbors, including Pakistan, a nuclear power. But Pakistan is already unstable, and a native regime in Afghanistan just as likely might want to behave itself to prevent more foreign intervention.

In any case, the public does not support the war in Afghanistan because it does not see that the United States is much threatened from that country, and there is neither the public support nor the resources necessary for winning the war there. That makes the whole expedition a disgrace, the betrayal of the soldiers sent to fight what is not meant to be won or held.

u      u      u

In regard to Afghanistan, Obama may fear being perceived as weak — just as Lyndon Johnson feared being perceived as weak in regard to his own mistaken war, the war in Vietnam. So Johnson chose to act tough and escalated U.S. intervention and succeeded only in destroying a pitiful country, dividing and bankrupting his own, and ruining himself politically. That is what awaits Obama in Afghanistan, except that the United States is already bankrupt and living on the credit of increasingly testy foreigners.

If Obama wants a strategy, let the United States admit mistakes, not perpetuate them and make them self-justifying, and let it go to war only when it is ready to commit its every resource to a clearly defined victory, and only with a declaration of war that makes the whole of the people’s representatives accountable.

Since the United States is not prepared to win in Afghanistan and since winning is plainly not worth the cost, we should get out.

Chris Powell is managing editor of the Journal Inquirer in Manchester.

Latest News

Winter sports season approaches at HVRHS

Mohawk Mountain was making snow the first week of December. The slopes host practices and meets for the HVRHS ski team.

By Riley Klein

FALLS VILLAGE — After concluding a successful autumn of athletics, Housatonic Valley Regional High School is set to field teams in five sports this winter.

Basketball

Keep ReadingShow less
Bears headline DEEP forum in Sharon; attendees call for coexistence, not hunting

A mother bear and her cubs move through a backyard in northwest Connecticut, where residents told DEEP that bear litters are now appearing more frequently.

By James Clark

SHARON — About 40 people filled the Sharon Audubon Center on Wednesday, Dec. 3, to discuss black bears — and most attendees made clear that they welcome the animals’ presence. Even as they traded practical advice on how to keep bears out of garages, porches and trash cans, residents repeatedly emphasized that they want the bears to stay and that the real problem lies with people, not wildlife.

The Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP) convened the meeting as the first in a series of regional Bear Management Listening Sessions, held at a time when Connecticut is increasingly divided over whether the state should authorize a limited bear hunt. Anticipating the potential for heated exchanges, DEEP opened the evening with strict ground rules designed to prevent confrontations: speakers were limited to three minutes, directed to address only the panel of DEEP officials, and warned that interruptions or personal attacks would not be tolerated.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kent unveils two new 'smart bins' to boost composting efforts

Rick Osborne, manager of the Kent Transfer Station, deposits the first bag of food scraps into a new organics “smart bin.” HRRA Executive Director Jennifer Heaton-Jones stands at right, with Transfer Station staff member Rob Hayes at left.

By Ruth Epstein

KENT — Residents now have access to around-the-clock food-scrap composting thanks to two newly installed organics “smart bins,” unveiled during a ribbon-cutting ceremony Monday morning, Dec. 1.

Rick Osborne, manager of the Kent Transfer Station, placed the first bag of food scraps into the smart bin located at 3 Railroad St. A second bin has been installed outside the Transfer Station gate, allowing 24/7 public access even when the facility is closed.

Keep ReadingShow less
Cornwall selectmen prioritize housing, healthcare in new two-year goals

Cornwall First Selectman Gordon Ridgway

File photo

CORNWALL — Housing and healthcare topped the list of 15 goals the Board of Selectmen set for the next two years, reflecting the board’s view that both areas warrant continued attention.

First Selectman Gordon Ridgway and Selectmen Rocco Botto and John Brown outlined their priorities during the board’s regular meeting on Tuesday, Dec. 2. On housing, the board discussed supporting organizations working to create affordable options in town, and Botto said the town should also pursue additional land acquisitions for future housing.

Keep ReadingShow less