The First Amendment in an era of social media

The First Amendment, which guarantees free speech, has long been the lifeblood of our democracy. Yet free speech is based on two expectations: that, even when people are biased, their facts are generally truthful; and that the opinions and ideas that circulate, however disturbing or discriminatory, are attributable to identifiable individuals.

During the past three years, President Trump’s use of Twitter to attack the news media for “fake news” has occurred alongside an exponential growth in social media, which has enabled the spread of partisan information and disinformation whose sources are often not clear. This new world of extremist views, often loosely tethered to facts, has raised the stakes for determining what news is protected by free speech, even if it appears biased, and what news is demonstrably false, but presented as factual with the intention of deceiving the public.

For most Americans, “fake news” debuted as a frightening part of the 2016 elections. Russian social media posts, disguised as American accounts, attempted not only to influence the election in favor of Donald Trump, but to heighten Americans’ distrust in our institutions, especially our elections, and to divide us by race, religion and political views. 

The use of social media to spread disinformation and extremist views is important because two out of three American adults have come to get some of their news on social media. According to a Pew survey released in September of 2018, 43% of Americans get at least some news from Facebook, which also owns Instagram; 21% get some news from YouTube, which is owned by Google; and 12% get some news from Twitter. Just as important, social media is able to target its “news” to those highly engaged partisans most likely to use social media for information and to believe what they read. 

Despite efforts by the technology companies to curtail fraudulent news, Russia and a growing number of other countries continued to influence the 2018 midterm elections by posting misinformation on social media aimed at attacking individual candidates, dampening turnout, stoking distrust in the voting process and amplifying distorted narratives about particular events. 

υ  υ  υ

What has changed over the past three years is the increasing use of disinformation by American political activists — about voting, political opponents and current events. This was most conspicuous during now- Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s confirmation hearings and in the 2018 coverage of Central American migrants coming toward our border. As a new report by PEN, “Truth on the Ballot: Fraudulent News, the Midterm Elections, and Prospects for 2020,” concludes, we are threatened by a new domestic “normal,” in which the end justifies the means and bogus news promulgated by American politicians, activists and reporters is considered “a distasteful but not disqualifying political tactic.”  

The number of misleading political news stories on social media has already surged in advance of the 2020 elections. Fake news stories that went against Democrats and liberals made up 62% of the fraudulent stories on Facebook so far in 2019 and drew 104 million viewers. Of the fraudulent stories on Facebook in 2019, 29% went against Republicans or conservatives and were seen 49 million times, according to Avaaz, a global advocacy group that tracks misinformation.  

Caught between the contradictory pressures to protect free speech, to remove misinformation and to avoid the accusation of being a global censor, Facebook has revised its algorithms for detecting fake news (a fraught project); partnered with third-party fact-checkers; and shut down accounts whose authors appeared fraudulent. Although taking down pages and ads posted by inauthentic sources supposedly avoids the problem of interfering with free speech, critics say that Facebook is not always clear as to why it is deleting a page. Moreover, determining whether the accounts are purchased by the persons or organizations they purport to be is not always easy. 

As our country prepares for an impeachment trial, three years of attacks on our fact-checked mainstream media, along with a steady stream of hyper-partisan social media output, is grievously apparent. Many Americans either do not believe or care about evidence that our president held back military equipment from Ukraine as a bribe to secure dirt on his presumed 2020 opponent, Joe Biden. It is this widespread lack of trust in both the news and our government that threatens our democracy and will have to be rebuilt by whoever becomes our next president. 

Carol Ascher, who lives in Sharon, has published seven books of fiction and nonfiction, as well as many essays and stories.

Latest News

Economic pressures jeopardize Connecticut's farming future

Marble Valley Farm in Kent leases land from the Kent Land Trust at below-market rates. The model enabled owner Megan Haney to grow her vegetable operation in an otherwise harsh economic climate for Connecticut farmers.

Photo by Sarah Lang

Last month, the USDA’s 2024 Land Values Summary reported that Connecticut has the third most expensive farm real estate in the country (tied with Massachusetts) at two times the northeast average for dollars per acre.

To Chelsea Gazillo, the senior New England policy manager for American Farmland Trust, these numbers reflect a “farmland access and succession crisis” that has impacted the state for “the last 15 years at least.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Amelia R. Wright

Falls Village – Amelia Rosalie (Betti) Wright, 91, of Falls Village died September 30, 2024 at her home surrounded by her loving family. She was the wife of the late Robert Kenneth Wright.

Amelia was born September 6, 1933 in Torrington, CT, daughter of the late Benjamin and Mary Eliza (Passini) Betti. Amelia worked at Camp Isabella Freedman as the Head Housekeeper. She was employed there for 35 years. She attended the Falls Village Congregational Church and had been very active at the Senior Center in Falls Village. She enjoyed collecting. She also enjoyed the craft classes offered by Adult Ed at the Housatonic Valley Regional High School. She enjoyed traveling, especially to the Cape, Vermont and New Hampshire. An avid flower person, Amelia had traveled to the major flower shows in both Boston and Philadelphia.

She is survived by her daughter, Susan Osborn and her husband David of Falls Village, her son, Robert H. Wright of Falls Village and her son, Donald Wright and his wife Kate of Millbrook, NY; her sister, MaryAnn Betti of Falls Village; her grandchildren, Benjamin and Katie Osborn and Jacob Wright. Amelia is also survived by her great grandson, Gunner Osborn. Amelia was predeceased by her brother, Donald Betti.

Funeral services will be held at 11:00 a.m. on Saturday, October 5, 2024 in the Mountain View Cemetery, Sand Road, North Canaan, CT. Calling hours will be held at the Newkirk-Palmer Funeral Home, 118 Main Street, North Canaan, CT 06018 on Friday, October 4, 2024 from 6:00 – 8:00 p.m.

Memorial donations may be sent to the Falls Village Volunteer Ambulance Association, 188 US-7 South, Falls Village, CT. 06031

Fashion and fun mark a century of service

Tom Barret shows off some Rummage Sale finds.

Natalia Zukerman

On Saturday, Sept. 28, the Cornwall Woman’s Society hosted its 100th anniversary celebration at Mohawk Mountain ski lodge.

“This celebration is to thank the people of Cornwall for their support and to celebrate the 100 years that the Woman’s Society has contributed to Cornwall and to needs near and far,” said Nancy Barr, co-chair of the Cornwall Woman’s Society (CWS).

Keep ReadingShow less
Haystack Festival returns to Norfolk

Now in its sixth year, the Haystack Book Festival brings together writers and thinkers in unmoderated conversation. Produced in conjunction with the Norfolk Foundation, whose mission is “to contribute to the vitality and sustainability of Norfolk, particularly in relation to the town’s natural setting and multiple artistic and cultural attractions,” the Haystack Book Festival takes place at the Norfolk Library. On Sunday, Oct. 6 at 1:30 p.m. the festival will have an event for middle grade readers at The HUB featuring Sarah Maslin Nir.

“We’re excited to be celebrating the sixth year of the festival. This year we have a great program discussing topics as wide ranging as ballet, interpreting the landscape, and looking at the horse as a treasured companion throughout history, along with other ideas that will be discussed on our stage,” says Michael Selleck co-director of the Haystack Book Festival.

Keep ReadingShow less