Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

Forty years later, and still no closure

On Sept. 28, 1973, Barbara Gibbons was murdered in her home in Falls Village. Her 18-year-old son, Peter Reilly, confessed to the crime during an eight-hour interrogation by Connecticut State Police. Over the next three years, Reilly was found guilty in court of the murder, then, with the help of friends and supporters from neighbors to journalists to celebrities, was able to appeal the conviction and was finally exonerated. But before that could happen, a one-man special grand jury lambasted the State Police investigation and a report by the State Police, ordered by the governor, Ella Grasso, insisted on Reilly’s guilt. Grasso and the state’s attorney stepped in and that State Police report was withdrawn. Reilly’s exoneration stood.In 2013, when DNA evidence, cell phone tracking and other sophisticated investigation tools are taken for granted, it’s hard to imagine that a confession wrenched out of a confused 18-year-old that went against physical evidence at the scene would have been enough to assign guilt. It was only through concentrated activism on the part of Reilly’s ardent defenders as well as the ethical analysis of some within the justice system that he was released from jail and absolved of any responsibility for his mother’s death.This newspaper’s editor and publisher at the time of the murder and trial, Robert H. Estabrook, used his strong editorial voice to write about the faults of the State Police investigation and to defend Reilly’s innocence. His award-winning editorials, combined with the ongoing reporting of Joseph O’Brien (who in retirement became a columnist for The Winsted Journal) in The Hartford Courant, playwright Arthur Miller’s substantive financial and moral support, and the actions of many others, brought to light the flaws in the case against Reilly. Kent’s Donald S. Connery wrote a book about the case while it was happening, “Guilty Until Proven Innocent,” published first in 1977 and again in 2010. Connery has become a widely recognized expert in police interrogation techniques and abuse as a result of his profound knowledge of and research into Reilly’s case. As an investigator into miscarriages of justice, he has continued to advocate for responsible and accountable questioning and handling of suspects in police custody. Connery wrote an excellent synopsis of the Reilly case and its ramifications on police practices for Sunday’s Hartford Courant opinion page. Read it at www.courant.com. Connery acknowledges that current police methods of investigation are more advanced and responsible than in 1973. He still, however, sees intransigence from the chief state’s attorney’s office relating to admitting shortcomings in any case built by law enforcement. The example he uses is that of Richard Lapointe of Manchester, who was convicted of murdering his wife’s grandmother in 1987 on evidence that has since been widely questioned. (See Chris Powell’s column this week.) Both Connery and Reilly been among those who have worked for a new trial in Lapointe’s case, so far unsuccessfully.Four arrests relating to the 2012 murder of Sharon’s Luke Vitalis happened this September and more information about that case is being released as those charged come up for trial (see story, Page A1). While those accused are, of course, innocent until proven guilty in a court of law, justice for Vitalis seems possible, even imminent, when one reads through the description of the careful investigation of the State Police over the past year. This will not bring Vitalis back, but should help his friends and family cope with the loss and fear associated with one’s loved one being murdered.But there remain two unsolved murders in the Northwest Corner, both cold cases but one very cold: The 2004 murder of Sharon’s Floyd Ellis, and the 1973 murder of Barbara Gibbons.

Latest News

Slow fashion takes the runway at Stone Ridge Orchard

The organic runway at HVSFW puts sustainable style among the apple trees at Stone Ridge Orchard.

Jay Ballesteros

Fast fashion has made it possible to buy the latest trend almost as quickly as it appears on social media. The environmental cost, however, is anything but fleeting. Fashion production accounts for about 10% of global carbon emissions, consumes enormous quantities of water and energy, and an estimated 85% of textiles end up in landfills each year. Synthetic fabrics also shed microplastics when washed.

So what would happen if we slowed things down?

Keep ReadingShow less
Susan Schneider and the magic of marbling
Susan Schneider, owner of Shandell’s in Ashley Falls, in her studio.
Susan Schneider, owner of Shandell’s in Ashley Falls, in her studio.
It’s a joyful process. —Susan Schneider

A beautiful September morning found Susan Schneider of Shandell’s working in her Ashley Falls home studio, while linen cocktail napkins she had marbled the day before hung on a line outside her back door. Her helpers, dogs Daisy and Stubbs, are never far from her.

“Marbling,” Schneider explained, “the art of floating paint on a liquid and printing it on a medium, has been around for hundreds of years.”

Keep ReadingShow less

Through the lens of war

Through the lens of war

“Omaha Beach Rescue, D-Day +1, Normandy, June 7, 1944.” one of the best-known photographs of D-Day.

Walter Rosenblum

Longtime Norfolk resident Nina Rosenblum will present her award-winning documentary, “They Fight With Cameras,” on Saturday, Sept. 26, at 6:30 p.m. at the Norfolk Library.

The film tells the story of her father, decorated U.S. Army Signal Corps combat cameraman Walter Rosenblum.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Brian Gersten finds the story in the overlooked

Filmmaker Brian Gersten

D.H. Callahan

At 6 p.m. on Saturday, Sept. 26, award-winning filmmaker Brian Gersten will screen four short documentaries at the David M. Hunt Library in Falls Village, exploring obscure topics such as a lingering territorial dispute between the United States and Canada, a nationwide toilet paper panic sparked by a late-night joke, the infamous “Balloon Boy” saga and the history of bowling in America.

The Chicago-raised, Millerton-based filmmaker has worked as an editor on feature-length documentaries like the cycling film “Enter the Slipstream” and Netflix’s profile on author Tom Wolfe, “Radical Wolfe.” In 2025, “Why We Dream,” a film he edited about bringing D-Day veterans back to the beaches of Normandy, premiered aboard the U.S.S. Intrepid in New York City. When it comes to directing, Gersten’s own interests focus more on the underappreciated and unremembered, as the four short films he directed will demonstrate.

Keep ReadingShow less
Sharon artist takes top prize at Lime Rock art show
Muriel Stockdale, left, and judge Roger McKee during the awards announcement at the juried art show at Trinity Episcopal Church. Stockdale\u2019s \u201cKevin\u201d was the second place winner.
Patrick L. Sullivan

The annual juried art show at Trinity Episcopal Church in Lime Rock was won by Mi-Kyung Hwang of Sharon for “Wild Hazelnut from Eggleston.”

The winners were announced at the show’s opening reception at the church Friday evening, Sept. 18.

Keep ReadingShow less
From Woodstock to the Warner, Graham Nash is still singing for peace

Graham Nash brings a career-spanning retrospective to the Warner Theatre in Torrington on Sept. 30, joined by Todd Caldwell, Adam Minkoff and Zack Djanikian.

Misti Layne

Imagine stepping out onto a stage in front of hundreds of thousands of tired, wet and weary strangers with a lineup of songs they’ve never heard before. If you’re Graham Nash, who will perform with his current band at the Warner Theatre in Torrington on Sept. 30, you don’t have to imagine. You only have to remember.

The legendary Woodstock music festival was only the second concert Nash played with Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. David Crosby, Stephen Stills and Nash had already formed Crosby, Stills & Nash, releasing their debut album earlier that year. Theirs was a sound both new and nostalgic when it hit the scene in the late 1960s, and, thanks in part to the success all three members had had with previous bands, they instantly found a wide and willing audience.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.