Historic reversal keeps couple out of their lakeside home

SALISBURY — In a stunning reversal, a local zoning board has revoked the certificate of occupancy given to a lakeside property owner who constructed a large home that exceeded the parameters of its zoning permit.

At its Aug. 28 meeting, the Salisbury Zoning Board of Appeals voted unanimously to grant the appeal of Millerton Road resident Ann Marie Nonkin, who had taken the town and her neighbor to court over the building of a large house next door — one that Nonkin and her attorneys claimed was built without proper permits, is too tall and is in violation of the town’s own zoning code.

The board ruled that the construction project of Dean and Margaret Haubrich on the shores of Lake Wononscopomuc went beyond what was authorized by the zoning permit issued by town Zoning Administrator Nancy Brusie on Nov. 17, 2006. That permit allowed for “internal renovations,� but the scope of the project included the demolition of a small existing ranch home and the construction of a large multi-story dwelling with dramatic views of the lake.

“I am so proud of this board,� Nonkin said of the ZBA. “They did the right thing.�

She declined to comment further and referred additional inquiries to her attorney. Asked whether he felt vindicated, Nonkin lawyer William Conti replied, “I’m not sure that’s the right word. We think the second story was improper.�

Ruling follows hearing, court date

The ZBA’s ruling came on the heels of a lengthy public hearing on Aug. 12 that lasted almost three hours and featured four attorneys presenting exhibits and questioning those involved in the case.

Last year, Fred Laser, the Haubrichs’ general contractor, testified under oath in Litchfield Superior Court that the project amounted to more than “internal renovations,� Conti said. Laser, who is also the chairman of the Planning and Zoning Commission in Falls Village, did not return a call seeking comment.

Salisbury zoning requirements stipulate that lot sizes in the lake district must be at least 1 acre. The Haubrich’s lot is only 6/10 of an acre, but since their original home was built before zoning regulations were enacted in the town of Salisbury in the 1950s, the Haubrichs’ one-story ranch was considered nonconforming but legal. In common parlance, its right to exist was “grandfathered in,� but the ability to expand it was and is substantially limited.

Nonkin’s original petition to the Planning and Zoning Commission to rescind the Haubrichs’ permit was denied by the commission on June 12, 2007, because of a legal opinion from one of the town’s attorneys, Charles R. Andres, that the commission lacked the authority to revoke the permit. Rather, Andres said, the remedy for an incorrect permit issued by the zoning administrator is to appeal that decision to the Zoning Board of Appeals.

Regulation was unclear

Almost everyone now agrees that the real culprit is language in the town’s zoning code (in effect at the time the Haubrichs started construction), which was unclear on what constitutes the expansion of a non-conforming use — especially vertical expansion of a structure.

The code states, “No non-conforming building or structure shall be altered, enlarged or extended in any way that increases the area or space of that portion of the building or structure which is non-conforming.� That prohibition extends to adding a second story to “that portion of a building which is non-conforming.�

The policy to allow some vertical expansion was based on an opinion issued by Salisbury’s former town attorney, the late Ralph Elliott, on that portion of the code. Last year the P&Z changed the code to explicitly allow for a second-story addition under certain conditions. But the change was not retroactive, so the Haubrichs’ project is subject to the previous version of the code that was challenged by Nonkin and another of the Haubrichs’ neighbors, Anthony Bouscaren, who sued the town earlier this year.

In an interview, Bouscaren said he was withdrawing his lawsuit in light of the ZBA’s decision to grant Nonkin’s appeal.

“I brought the suit only to force the town to enforce their own zoning regulations,� said Bouscaren, an aviation attorney in Manhattan. “They seem to be getting on track.�

Of Elliot’s decades-old verbal opinion on the zoning code allowing for vertical expansion of non-conforming structures, Bouscaren characterized it as “rank hearsay� that “does not meet any legal standard.�

A first for the town’s ZBA

Jeff Lloyd is a Salisbury native and chairs the zoning appeals board. He said he has never heard of the ZBA declaring a zoning permit null and void. Indeed, the ZBA attorney, Peter Herbst, who was on vacation this week and unavailable for comment, told him the same thing.

“We came to the conclusion that the permit didn’t reflect what was built,� said Lloyd. “It’s as simple as that.�

As for what happens next, Lloyd said it is strictly “up to the parties involved� and that his board’s responsibilities have essentially ended with the granting of Nonkin’s appeal. He was reluctant to blame anyone, but guessed it would end up back in Litchfield Superior Court since the revocation of the certificate of occupancy prohibits anyone from living there or purchasing homeowners insurance, for example.

“It’ll end up going back to Litchfield because the house can’t just sit there,� Lloyd predicted.

Salisbury First Selectman Curtis Rand declined to comment since the matter could end up in court again. He did confirm that the town has spent about $40,000 in legal fees on the case, not including the lawyers’ billings for the month of August — which should be substantial.

The Haubrichs, who live in Princeton, N.J., are represented by North Canaan attorney Mark Capecelatro, who could not be reached by press time.

Asked whether his client would seek to have the top floor of the Haubrichs’ home removed, to conform with the zoning code in effect at the time it was constructed, Conti replied, “I will say this: We will ask the town to enforce its ruling. Where it goes from there I don’t know.�

Latest News

Robin Wall Kimmerer urges gratitude, reciprocity in talk at Cary Institute

Robin Wall Kimmerer inspired the audience with her grassroots initiative “Plant, Baby, Plant,” encouraging restoration, native planting and care for ecosystems.

Aly Morrissey

Robin Wall Kimmerer, the bestselling author of “Braiding Sweetgrass” and a member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation, urged a sold-out audience at the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies on Friday, March 13, to rethink humanity’s relationship with the natural world through gratitude, reciprocity and responsibility.

Introduced by Cary Institute President Joshua Ginsberg, Kimmerer opened the evening by greeting the audience in Potawatomi, the native language of her ancestors, and grounding the talk in a practice of gratitude.

Keep ReadingShow less

Melissa Gamwell’s handmade touch

Melissa Gamwell’s handmade touch
Melissa Gamwell, hand lettering with precision and care.
Kevin Greenberg
"There is no better feeling than working through something with your own brain and your own hands." —Melissa Gamwell

In an age of automation, Melissa Gamwell is keeping the human hand alive.

The Cornwall, Connecticut-based calligrapher is practicing an art form that’s been under attack by machines for nearly 400 years, and people are noticing. For proof, look no further than the line leading to her candle-lit table at the Stissing House Craft Feast each winter. In her first year there, she scribed around 1,200 gift tags, cards, and hand drawn ornaments.

Keep ReadingShow less
Regional 7 students bring ‘The Addams Family’ to the stage

The cast of “The Addams Family” from Northwest Regional School District No. 7 with Principal Kelly Carroll from Ann Antolini Elementary School in New Hartford.

Monique Jaramillo

Nearly 50 students from across the region are helping bring the delightfully macabre world of “The Addams Family” to life in Northwestern Regional School District No. 7’s upcoming production. The student cast and crew, representing the towns of Barkhamsted, Colebrook, New Hartford and Norfolk, will stage the musical March 27 and 28 at 7 p.m., with a 2 p.m. matinee on March 29 in the school’s auditorium in Winsted.

Based on the iconic characters created by Charles Addams, the musical follows Wednesday Addams, who shocks her famously eccentric family by falling in love with a perfectly “normal” young man. When his parents come to dinner at the Addams’ mansion, two very different families collide, leading to an evening of secrets, surprises and unexpected revelations about love and belonging.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

‘Quilts of Many Colors’ opens at Hunt Library

Garth Kobel, Art Wall Chair, Mary Randolph, Frank Halden, Ruth Giumarro, Project Chair, Maria Bulson, Barbara Lobdell, Sherry Newman, Elizabeth Frey-Thomas, Donna Heinz around “The Green Man.”

Robin Roraback

In honor of National Quilt Day, a tradition established in 1991, Hunt Library’s second annual quilt show, “Quilts of Many Colors,” will open Saturday, March 21, with a reception from 5 to 7 p.m. The quilts, made by members of the Hunt Library Quilters, will be displayed through April 17. All quilts will be for sale, and a portion of each sale goes to the library.

At the center of the exhibit is a quilt the Hunt Library Quilters collaborated on called the “Quilt of Many Colors,” inspired by Dolly Parton’s song”Coat of Many Colors.” Each member of the Hunt Library Quilters made two to four 10-inch squares for the twin-size quilt, with Gail Allyn embroidering “The Green Man” for the center square. The Green Man, a symbol of rebirth, is also a symbol of the library, seen carved in stone at the library’s entrance. One hundred percent of the sale of this quilt benefits the library.

Keep ReadingShow less

New in at Kenise Barnes Fine Art

New in at Kenise Barnes Fine Art

New works on display at Kenise Barnes Fine Art in Kent

D.H. Callahan

Since 2018, Kenise Barnes Fine Art in Kent has been displaying an impressive rotation of works across a range of artists and mediums. On Saturday, March 14, art enthusiasts arrived to see a new exhibition at the gallery featuring a wide variety of new pieces.

Large-scale paintings by David Collins and Melanie Parke alongside small 3-by-3 inch oil-on-panel works by Sally Maca.

Keep ReadingShow less
Trailblazing divorce attorney Harriet Newman Cohen to speak at Norfolk Library

Harriet Newman Cohen

Provided

Harriet Newman Cohen weathered many storms in her five-decade-long journey to become one of the nation’s most celebrated divorce attorneys. Voted one of the top 100 attorneys in New York for many years, Cohen served as president of the New York Women’s Bar Association and has been a champion of divorce reform. She and her co-author, journalist David Feinberg, will give a book talk about her memoir, “Passion and Power: A Life in Three Worlds,” at the Norfolk Library on Sunday, March 22 at 2 p.m.

What began as a personal record of her life, intended for her family, grew into a memoir that journalist Carl Bernstein describes in his endorsement as “wise and riveting.” Born in 1932 in Providence, Rhode Island, to parents who immigrated in 1920 from Ukraine and Poland, Cohen traces the arc of her life and the challenges she faced entering a legal profession that was overwhelmingly male at the time, leading to her success as a maverick divorce attorney fighting for women’s rights and equity in the law. She received her Juris Doctor, cum laude, from Brooklyn Law School in 1974, one year after Roe v. Wade was decided. She is a founding partner of Cohen Stine Kapoor LLP in New York City, a family and matrimonial law firm she formed in 2021, at age 88, with her daughter Martha Cohen Stine and Ankit Kapoor.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.