Kent Hollow Mine sues the town of Amenia for ZBA ruling

AMENIA — Residents of the town of Amenia may have believed that ever since the Amenia Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) unanimously denied the Kent Hollow Mine zoning appeal on June 17 of this year, the matter had been laid to rest. That assumption would be in error.

The mine, located on South Amenia Road, wanted to expand its operations to develop a new 33-acre sand and gravel mine on its already existing 82.6-acre parcel, according to documents from the state Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC). That, despite being informed by Amenia Code Enforcement Officer (CEO) Michael Segelken that the town classifies the mine as a nonconforming use, which was originally declared back in 1978, when Kent Hollow first applied for its permit.

Some history: Kent Hollow Mine has operated a mine on a small scale during the past few decades, but its original permit expired in 1989. It then submitted an application to the town of Amenia to increase operations in 2016, but withdrew that application shortly afterward. It resubmitted the application in February, 2017. 

Ultimately it was unable to win the appeal based on Segelken’s decision, despite submitted mounds of paperwork trying to establish the mine’s working history. The mine’s timeline of activity — including when activity discontinued -— whether the mine provided the town with the proper documents for materials extracted from the site, the mine’s classification as a nonconforming use and the mine’s intentions for extracting materials in the future were all considered by the ZBA.

All the while, the public spoke of the mine’s pastoral location and quality of life issues for nearby residents. Countless residents attended the public meetings and hearings dealing with the appeal. And, after years of consideration, the ZBA made its final decision.

Michael Chamberlin, a ZBA member who was named in the recent lawsuit, defended the board’s decision.

“There was a lengthy public hearing and the whole process was really guided by the ZBA’s lawyer, George Lithco,” said Chamberlin. “I think the ZBA did its job, I just don’t think that Kent Hollow made its case.”

Calls to Kent Hollow Mine President Richard Steiner for comment were not returned by press time. But public records  reflect that on Tuesday, Sept. 17, Kent Hollow Mine served the town.

Legal details

The lawsuit, filed by Allan Rappleyea of Corbally, Gartland and Rappleyea, LLP, is against the Amenia Zoning Board of Appeals, CEO Segelken, town Councilwoman Vicky Doyle, ZBA member Chamberlin, ZBA alternate Leo Blackman, former ZBA Chairman Jeff Barnett-Winsby and ZBA member James Wright.

The suit claims that Kent Hollow Mine has operated a gravel mine since on or about June 1971, when it acquired the property. In the fall of 2012, it states, the DEC issued a notice of a complete application and negative declaration in the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) process, when Kent Hollow sought a mining permit.

Doyle, Chamberlin, Barnett-Winsby, Blackman and Wright all own or owned properties near the mine, and, according to Kent Hollow, “had a personal interest in closing the mine” even though they held official positions in town.

Doyle, for her part, recused herself from any discussion or action taken regarding the mine. 

Chamberlin, an attorney by trade, did not recuse himself, but submitted a lengthy explanation of why he felt he could objectively rule on the matter. He explained that more than a decade ago he led the Oblong Valley Association (OVA), which objected to the mine. 

“I guess my main reason for doing that was my daughter, who was 7 or 8 years old at the time, would ride her pony around 50 yards from the mine, and ponies don’t like loud noises and gravel trucks. That was the main thing that motivated me,” he said. “There are lots of arguments against the mine: bog  turtles, rattlesnakes, etc., they were not as important to me. What was more important was the safety of my daughter on her pony. My daughter is 18 now, and doesn’t ride a pony anymore. My main reason for having a problem with the mine went away, because of a change of circumstances.”

Therefore, argued Chamberlin, he held no animus against the mine and could fairly rule on the appeal with the rest of the ZBA. OVA, meanwhile, is rarely active these days, and Chamberlin has not been much involved with the organization, he said.

Alternative use

He, and others, said when Kent Hollow purchased the mine years ago, mining wasn’t its main objective. Developing residential apartments was, they say, adding one such apartment building exists today. 

“That was back in the ‘70s,” Chamberlin said. “We’d call that affordable housing now. One of those buildings was actually built, and it’s still there. They were interested in seven, eight, even 10 buildings that they were proposing at the time. That’s the best we could tell from the ZBA, from the evidence they submitted… Then, a little mining [would occur] to get some gravel out for building foundations and driveways. That was their plan.”

“It’s pretty clear that they never established that quarry primarily to mine,” said adjacent property owner Phil Sicker. “All the evidence pointed to the fact that he wanted to build a series of apartment complexes. They only built one. 

“The questions of grandfathering it in were moot because of their original intent,” he added, noting Kent Hollow’s claim that it was entitled to renew mining activities because it had extracted small legal amounts of gravel during the past 30 years was untrue, “because many years they took nothing at all.”

The ZBA had asked Kent Hollow to document the gravel it extracted over the years, but the paperwork it submitted was unconvincing. 

“You could see in the questions the ZBA was asking they were not buying it,” said Sicker. “And the binder of receipts Kent Hollow presented were indications [that] extracted small amounts of soil or gravel over many years appeared to be a series of documents indicating one part of the company took dirt to another part of the company and some years, nothing at all.”

Sicker said Kent Hollow’s case was ineffective and that when the ZBA denied the appeal, he wasn’t surprised.

Fallout

Now, with the latest lawsuit, nearby resident Laurence Levin said the town needs to support the ZBA and its decision.

“I think people should understand that if this [lawsuit] goes against the town and the ZBA decision… it goes against the master plan and the zoning ordinances. And this can happen anywhere in the town, it’s not just a very localized issue over in the Oblong Valley and Rattlesnake Mountain,” she said. “[We] all live on that eastern edge of Amenia,  but it could happen anywhere: Smithfield, along 22 — anywhere, because the whole valley is basically glacial remains and there’s gravel everywhere.”

Levin added that the town took years to develop its master plan (now known as a comprehensive plan), and defined where the mining industry is appropriate, and where it is not.

“There are zoning maps based on this,” she said, noting the Segalla gravel mine operates just “up the road from Kent Hollow.

“They have a right to mine there, and that was granted,” she said. 

She also mentioned that the lawsuit claims there was bias against the mine when the ZBA ruled. Levin credited ZBA attorney Lithco for maintaining an aura of appropriateness and said because of his actions, she’s “very confident that the decision will stand.”

Complaints against Amenia town Supervisor Victoria Perotti’s unwillingness to discuss the lawsuit at Town Board meetings, meanwhile, were addressed by both Doyle and Perotti. 

“We are unable to talk because of comments on issues that are in litigation,” said Doyle, who expressed disappointment about having to be so coy.

Perotti also expressed frustration at having to deal with yet another legal proceeding filed by the mine. But, she said philosophically, it’s all in a day’s work at Town Hall.

“This isn’t our first go around with them,” she said. “It’s probably our third. They just keep coming back every so many years. OK, here they are again.”

The town supervisor said the town will answer the lawsuit in defense of the ZBA.

“Kent Hollow Mine is not in our soil mining [district] overlay in our zoning,” she said. “It’s a very complicated issue. But it’s totally inappropriate for us to be discussing litigation at this point, because there aren’t really any answers.”

Latest News

Robin Wall Kimmerer urges gratitude, reciprocity in talk at Cary Institute

Robin Wall Kimmerer inspired the audience with her grassroots initiative “Plant, Baby, Plant,” encouraging restoration, native planting and care for ecosystems.

Aly Morrissey

Robin Wall Kimmerer, the bestselling author of “Braiding Sweetgrass” and a member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation, urged a sold-out audience at the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies on Friday, March 13, to rethink humanity’s relationship with the natural world through gratitude, reciprocity and responsibility.

Introduced by Cary Institute President Joshua Ginsberg, Kimmerer opened the evening by greeting the audience in Potawatomi, the native language of her ancestors, and grounding the talk in a practice of gratitude.

Keep ReadingShow less

Melissa Gamwell’s handmade touch

Melissa Gamwell’s handmade touch
Melissa Gamwell, hand lettering with precision and care.
Kevin Greenberg
"There is no better feeling than working through something with your own brain and your own hands." —Melissa Gamwell

In an age of automation, Melissa Gamwell is keeping the human hand alive.

The Cornwall, Connecticut-based calligrapher is practicing an art form that’s been under attack by machines for nearly 400 years, and people are noticing. For proof, look no further than the line leading to her candle-lit table at the Stissing House Craft Feast each winter. In her first year there, she scribed around 1,200 gift tags, cards, and hand drawn ornaments.

Keep ReadingShow less
Regional 7 students bring ‘The Addams Family’ to the stage

The cast of “The Addams Family” from Northwest Regional School District No. 7 with Principal Kelly Carroll from Ann Antolini Elementary School in New Hartford.

Monique Jaramillo

Nearly 50 students from across the region are helping bring the delightfully macabre world of “The Addams Family” to life in Northwestern Regional School District No. 7’s upcoming production. The student cast and crew, representing the towns of Barkhamsted, Colebrook, New Hartford and Norfolk, will stage the musical March 27 and 28 at 7 p.m., with a 2 p.m. matinee on March 29 in the school’s auditorium in Winsted.

Based on the iconic characters created by Charles Addams, the musical follows Wednesday Addams, who shocks her famously eccentric family by falling in love with a perfectly “normal” young man. When his parents come to dinner at the Addams’ mansion, two very different families collide, leading to an evening of secrets, surprises and unexpected revelations about love and belonging.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

‘Quilts of Many Colors’ opens at Hunt Library

Garth Kobel, Art Wall Chair, Mary Randolph, Frank Halden, Ruth Giumarro, Project Chair, Maria Bulson, Barbara Lobdell, Sherry Newman, Elizabeth Frey-Thomas, Donna Heinz around “The Green Man.”

Robin Roraback

In honor of National Quilt Day, a tradition established in 1991, Hunt Library’s second annual quilt show, “Quilts of Many Colors,” will open Saturday, March 21, with a reception from 5 to 7 p.m. The quilts, made by members of the Hunt Library Quilters, will be displayed through April 17. All quilts will be for sale, and a portion of each sale goes to the library.

At the center of the exhibit is a quilt the Hunt Library Quilters collaborated on called the “Quilt of Many Colors,” inspired by Dolly Parton’s song”Coat of Many Colors.” Each member of the Hunt Library Quilters made two to four 10-inch squares for the twin-size quilt, with Gail Allyn embroidering “The Green Man” for the center square. The Green Man, a symbol of rebirth, is also a symbol of the library, seen carved in stone at the library’s entrance. One hundred percent of the sale of this quilt benefits the library.

Keep ReadingShow less

New in at Kenise Barnes Fine Art

New in at Kenise Barnes Fine Art

New works on display at Kenise Barnes Fine Art in Kent

D.H. Callahan

Since 2018, Kenise Barnes Fine Art in Kent has been displaying an impressive rotation of works across a range of artists and mediums. On Saturday, March 14, art enthusiasts arrived to see a new exhibition at the gallery featuring a wide variety of new pieces.

Large-scale paintings by David Collins and Melanie Parke alongside small 3-by-3 inch oil-on-panel works by Sally Maca.

Keep ReadingShow less
Trailblazing divorce attorney Harriet Newman Cohen to speak at Norfolk Library

Harriet Newman Cohen

Provided

Harriet Newman Cohen weathered many storms in her five-decade-long journey to become one of the nation’s most celebrated divorce attorneys. Voted one of the top 100 attorneys in New York for many years, Cohen served as president of the New York Women’s Bar Association and has been a champion of divorce reform. She and her co-author, journalist David Feinberg, will give a book talk about her memoir, “Passion and Power: A Life in Three Worlds,” at the Norfolk Library on Sunday, March 22 at 2 p.m.

What began as a personal record of her life, intended for her family, grew into a memoir that journalist Carl Bernstein describes in his endorsement as “wise and riveting.” Born in 1932 in Providence, Rhode Island, to parents who immigrated in 1920 from Ukraine and Poland, Cohen traces the arc of her life and the challenges she faced entering a legal profession that was overwhelmingly male at the time, leading to her success as a maverick divorce attorney fighting for women’s rights and equity in the law. She received her Juris Doctor, cum laude, from Brooklyn Law School in 1974, one year after Roe v. Wade was decided. She is a founding partner of Cohen Stine Kapoor LLP in New York City, a family and matrimonial law firm she formed in 2021, at age 88, with her daughter Martha Cohen Stine and Ankit Kapoor.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.