Legal Bill Leads To Heated Discussion


MILLERTON — How and why did the village rack up attorney’s fees for more than $4,000 with a lawyer originally hired to specifically help the Planning Board get through the SEQRA (State Environmental Quality Review Act) process? That was the question being asked by the Village Board at its meeting Tuesday night.

The question arose after charges were reviewed from a bill submitted by Planning Board counsel Jennifer Van Tuyl, of Cuddy & Feder LLP. Van Tuyl was hired to help with the environmental review process for the proposed Millerton Overlook project, a 20-unit affordable housing complex that, if approved, will be at the intersection of routes 22 and 44.

"The village has its own attorney," Trustee Anne Veteran said. "The Village Board did not agree to hire this woman. Four-thousand dollars is a huge amount of our budget."

"This is the first we’ve seen of the bill," added Deputy Mayor John Scutieri, who was as surprised as the other trustees to find out that the Village Board was being billed for Van Tuyl’s services.

"This bill says it was about how to replace our chairman [of the Planning Board]," Veteran said, directing her complaint toward Mayor Michael Cawley, who spent time discussing village business with Van Tuyl, on the village’s dime. "She was hired to help the Planning Board do SEQRA. I want to know how we, though it wasn’t even the board, Mike, how you, drove up this bill?"

"I believe what happened with me, is that we have a legal budget, some goes to Kevin [Thiemann, attorney to the village] and some does not. The lady pointed out a problem. She asked if I wanted to check it out," Cawley said.

"You did that without coming to the board," Veteran said. "What do we do with this bill now?"

"Pay it," was Cawley’s reply.

"I’m not going to pay it," Veteran said. "I’m not going to spend taxpayers’ money — $4,000 out of our little budget is a lot of money."

According to Thiemann, municipalities have the ability to set financial caps on what their leaders, for example a mayor, are authorized to spend. The board members discussed what Cawley’s cap was, and while some said they thought it was $5,000, Thiemann said he would look into it to be sure.

Meanwhile, former Planning Board Chairwoman Cathy Fenn, who was in the audience at the Village Board meeting, asked why the money was spent at all on outside advice.

"Regardless of what the mayor is allowed to spend, for years I’ve said the zoning law is antiquated, so why ask Jennifer Van Tuyl?" Fenn asked.

"I did not ask her, she asked me," Cawley replied. "She pointed out to me [the weak points in our procedures].

"We were facing a very large project and a very involved project and we had her work," the mayor said, referring to the Millerton Overlook project. "It’s a cumulative effort."

"It’s irresponsible for people to think they can hop on the phone and the other side is not going ching, ching, ching," Veteran said.

Scutieri suggested the mayor review the bill and talk to Van Tuyl about the charges. Veteran agreed that something needs to be done.

"The village is facing a $4,200 bill from an attorney that the board did not approve," she said. "To rack up a $4,200 bill is inexcusable and insane with our little budget."

"Why don’t we turn this around," Dave Shufelt, a local resident, said. "She initiated it, but she should never have looked into it for $4,200. If she was going to spend that money she should have said so. Find out the facts of what happened."

The board agreed and chose not to pay the bill until the matter was clarified.

Latest News

Kent girls score late win against Millbrook
Pip Davies controls the puck for Kent School.
Photo by Lans Christensen

KENT Kent School's girls hockey team defeated Millbrook School 4-3 in a Valentine's Day showdown on the ice Saturday, Feb. 14.

There was no love lost between these Founders League schools situated on opposite sides of the Connecticut/New York border. Both teams had similar win-loss records, and both were eager to add to the "win" column.

Keep ReadingShow less
In remembrance:
Tim Prentice and the art of making the wind visible
In remembrance: Tim Prentice and the art of making the wind visible
In remembrance: Tim Prentice and the art of making the wind visible

There are artists who make objects, and then there are artists who alter the way we move through the world. Tim Prentice belonged to the latter. The kinetic sculptor, architect and longtime Cornwall resident died in November 2025 at age 95, leaving a legacy of what he called “toys for the wind,” work that did not simply occupy space but activated it, inviting viewers to slow down, look longer and feel more deeply the invisible forces that shape daily life.

Prentice received a master’s degree from the Yale School of Art and Architecture in 1960, where he studied with German-born American artist and educator Josef Albers, taking his course once as an undergraduate and again in graduate school.In “The Air Made Visible,” a 2024 short film by the Vision & Art Project produced by the American Macular Degeneration Fund, a nonprofit organization that documents artists working with vision loss, Prentice spoke of his admiration for Albers’ discipline and his ability to strip away everything but color. He recalled thinking, “If I could do that same thing with motion, I’d have a chance of finding a new form.”

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Laurie Fendrich and Peter Plagens:
A shared 
life in art 
and love

Laurie Fendrich and Peter Plagens at home in front of one of Plagens’s paintings.

Natalia Zukerman
He taught me jazz, I taught him Mozart.
Laurie Fendrich

For more than four decades, artists Laurie Fendrich and Peter Plagens have built a life together sustained by a shared devotion to painting, writing, teaching, looking, and endless talking about art, about culture, about the world. Their story began in a critique room.

“I came to the Art Institute of Chicago as a visiting instructor doing critiques when Laurie was an MFA candidate,” Plagens recalled.

Keep ReadingShow less
Strategic partnership unites design, architecture and construction

Hyalite Builders is leading the structural rehabilitation of The Stissing Center in Pine Plains.

Provided

For homeowners overwhelmed by juggling designers, architects and contractors, a new Salisbury-based collaboration is offering a one-team approach from concept to construction. Casa Marcelo Interior Design Studio, based in Salisbury, has joined forces with Charles Matz Architect, led by Charles Matz, AIA RIBA, and Hyalite Builders, led by Matt Soleau. The alliance introduces an integrated design-build model that aims to streamline the sometimes-fragmented process of home renovation and new construction.

“The whole thing is based on integrated services,” said Marcelo, founder of Casa Marcelo. “Normally when clients come to us, they are coming to us for design. But there’s also some architecture and construction that needs to happen eventually. So, I thought, why don’t we just partner with people that we know we can work well with together?”

Keep ReadingShow less
‘The Dark’ turns midwinter into a weeklong arts celebration

Autumn Knight will perform as part of PS21’s “The Dark.”

Provided

This February, PS21: Center for Contemporary Performance in Chatham, New York, will transform the depths of midwinter into a radiant week of cutting-edge art, music, dance, theater and performance with its inaugural winter festival, The Dark. Running Feb. 16–22, the ambitious festival features more than 60 international artists and over 80 performances, making it one of the most expansive cultural events in the region.

Curated to explore winter as a season of extremes — community and solitude, fire and ice, darkness and light — The Dark will take place not only at PS21’s sprawling campus in Chatham, but in theaters, restaurants, libraries, saunas and outdoor spaces across Columbia County. Attendees can warm up between performances with complimentary sauna sessions, glide across a seasonal ice-skating rink or gather around nightly bonfires, making the festival as much a social winter experience as an artistic one.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.