Opinions differ on completeness of Carvel study


PINE PLAINS — The Planning Board’s discussion of the Carvel development project April 11 focused on one issue — archaeology.

Carvel, if approved, could add 951 homes to Pine Plains. The applicant is retooling the project’s Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS), a document required under the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA).

The board last spring deemed Carvel’s DEIS incomplete. The project’s consultants have worked to revise the document. One of the few outstanding issues is the chapter regarding archaeology.

At the April 11 meeting, Matthew Kirk, an archaeologist with Hartgen Archaeological Associates, explained the applicant’s criteria for tests and why his firm, as well as the applicant, believes that sufficient archaeological study has taken place.

Nelson Johnson, the applicant’s legal representative, said a document dated April 2 addresses all of the board’s archaeological concerns.

"We’d like to get the DEIS finished so ... people can comment on it," the attorney said.

Warren Replansky, the town’s attorney, differered. "I thought it was kind of light ... and conclusory."

Kirk explained that in 2003, New York’s State Historic Preservation Office noted that the Carvel site "clearly had no archaeological concerns." Despite this, the applicant hired Hartgen to conduct tests on the site.

In 2004, a Phase 1A study, which is archaeological reconnaissance work, was conducted on the property. It was revised two years later.

"That’s the most important part of the archaeological process," Kirk said.

Shovel tests were conducted during the Phase 1B period, which was completed in 2005.

Additional investigation occurred in 2006.

"Even though we felt it was complete, we redoubled our efforts," Kirk continued.

There are two types of artifacts in the archaeological world — historic and precontact.

Historic artifacts are often found in the vicinity of a residence and could consist of a chicken bone or a piece chipped off of ceramic ware, left behind by the Native American tribes that used to call the Carvel site home.

After digging more than 1,500 test pits, the Hartgen team only found one precontact artifact — a flake from an arrowhead or spear tip.

Carvel devised a certain criteria for testing.

Areas within 100 meters of water were tested because the site’s early inhabitants "didn’t stray too far from water," as Kirk put it.

Parcels on certain elevations (more than 12 percent slope) weren’t tested because Native Americans most likely stayed closer to the ground.

Most of the existing golf course was ruled out because construction probably destroyed any artifacts that were in those parcels.

"That soil was turned over and over," Kirk said.

Standing water and pieces of land with bedrock were also excluded from testing. The topographical constraints were later mapped. Kirk said this allowed him and his associates to focus their efforts.

Since a meeting this past January, the Planning Board and the applicant have not seen eye-to-eye on when a Phase 2 (more shovel tests) should be conducted.

Carvel’s representatives have said that since a Phase 2 study is not a completeness issue, it can be deferred until after the DEIS is approved by the board.

"We’re committed to doing a Phase 2," Johnson said. "We’re looking to bring this to closure."

Members of the board have asked why the applicant wants to delay the start of the test if they acknowledge it has to be done at some point.

"If you’re going to do a Phase 2, you target it to the area you want to develop," Nelson said, adding that this would be accomplished by conducting the test after the DEIS is deemed complete.

Opinion differed on Carvel’s testing criteria, as well. Christopher Lindner, an archaeologist who is working with the board on the project, met with the applicant to discuss the criteria in May of last year. The criteria, which the archaeologist called "inadequate," was still put to use, Lindner said.

As the hour grew late, Replansky said he would seek the advice of the state’s preservation office on the Phase 2 issue.

Latest News

Chion Wolf brings ‘Audacious’ radio show to Winsted with show-and-tell event
Nils Johnson, co-founder and president of The Little Red Barn Brewers in Winsted, hosted Chion Wolf and her Connecticut Public show “Audacious LIVE: Show and Tell,” which was broadcast on April 8, drawing a sold-out crowd.
Jennifer Almquist

The parking lot of The Little Red Barn Brewers in Winsted was full on Wednesday, April 8, as more than 100 people from 43 Connecticut towns — including New Haven and Vernon — arrived carrying personal treasures for a live taping of “Audacious LIVE Show & Tell.”

Chion Wolf, host and producer of Connecticut Public’s “Audacious,” and her crew, led by production manager Maegn Boone, brought the program to the packed brewery for an evening of story-driven conversation and shared keepsakes.

Keep ReadingShow less
Marge Parkhurst, the preservation detective

Marge Parkhurst with a collection of historic nails recovered from wall cavities during restoration work.

Photo courtesy of Marge Parkhurst/Cottage & Country Painting Company
Walls still surprise me. If you look hard enough, you can find buried treasure.
Marge Parkhurst

After nearly 50 years of painting some of Litchfield County’s oldest homes and landmark properties, Marge Parkhurst has developed an eye for the past—reading the clues left behind in stenciled vines, forgotten bottles and newspapers tucked into walls, each revealing a small but vivid piece of Connecticut history.

Parkhurst was stripping wallpaper in a farmhouse in Colebrook — the kind of historic home she has spent decades restoring — when she noticed something odd. Three layers of paper had already come off — each one a different era’s idea of decoration — and beneath them, just barely visible under dull, off-white plaster, a pattern emerged.

Keep ReadingShow less
Wings of Spring performance at the Mahaiwe Theater
Adam Golka
Provided

On Sunday, April 19, at 4 p.m., Close Encounters With Music (CEWM) presents On the Wings of Song at the Mahaiwe Performing Arts Center in Great Barrington.

The program focuses on Robert Schumann’s spellbinding song cycle Dichterliebe (“A Poet’s Love”), a setting of sixteen poems by Heinrich Heine that explores love, longing, and the redemptive power of beauty. Featured artists include John Moore, baritone; Adam Golka, pianist; Miranda Cuckson, viola; and Yehuda Hanani, cello.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

New climbing gym planned for Great Barrington

Photo by Alec Linden

A climber explores Great Barrington’s renowned bouldering areas, reflecting the growing local interest in the sport ahead of the planned opening of Berkshire Boulders.

Alec Linden

Berkshire Boulders, a rock climbing gym, is set to open in the Berkshires later this year, aiming to do more than fill a gap in indoor recreation — it could help bring climbing further into the region’s mainstream.

Its co-founders already have their sights set beyond the roughly 2,000 square feet of climbable wall planned for a site off Route 7, just north of downtown Great Barrington.

Keep ReadingShow less
Wind, tarps and trail wisdom: a day learning how to camp smarter

Mat Jobin teaches the group how to use a permanent platform to rig a tent. The privy and lean-to of the Appalachian Mountain Club’s Limestone Spring Shelter are visible in the background.

Alec Linden

A happy day on the trail all starts with a good night’s sleep the night before. That’s local trekking guide Mat Jobin’s mantra, and he affirms that a good night’s sleep is possible even if it has to be on the trail itself – with the right preparation, that is.

Jobin, of Simsbury, Connecticut, is a 16-year professional guide and the founder and owner of Reach Your Summit, an outdoor experiences company that promotes self-confidence and leadership skills through a variety of excursions and educational workshops in the forests of New England. On Saturday, April 11, Jobin hosted the inaugural Campsite Selection & Skills workshop just off the Falls Village section of the Appalachian Trail.

Keep ReadingShow less
Grandmother Moon: Wunneanatsu Lamb-Cason book talk in Torrington
Wunneanatsu Lamb-Cason (Schaghticoke/Ho-Chunk), an educator, traditional storyteller and author, will read from her new book Grandmother Moon, inspired by her grandmother, Indigenous educator Trudie Lamb Richmond, who lived on Schaghticoke land along the Housatonic River in Kent.
Provided

The story comes full circle when educator, traditional storyteller and author Wunneanatsu Lamb-Cason (Schaghticoke/Ho-Chunk) comes to Litchfield County to read from her new book, Grandmother Moon, inspired by her grandmother, Indigenous educator Trudie Lamb Richmond, who lived on Schaghticoke land along the Housatonic River in Kent.

On Saturday, April 18, from 2-4 p.m., the Torrington Historical Society at 192 Main St. will host the book talk and sharing of traditional stories.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.