Pine Plains adopts tree law

PINE PLAINS — The Town Board at a special workshop on Thursday, June 24, discussed the proposed tree law, which it ultimately adopted with a vote of four to one (Councilwoman Sandra David was the lone dissenter).

The Conservation Advisory Council (CAC) in the town of Pine Plains proposed Local Law No. 2, in hopes of protecting the town’s street trees.

According to the local law, it sets out to: “Provide a mechanism for the removal, and pruning of trees on public and private lands which impact public highways and other public property in the town, which pose a hazard to the general public.�

But at what cost? Typically the tree work will be done at the town’s expense, but there has been some controversy regarding the issue.

“I think this could have been all done by simple policy change,� town Supervisor Gregg Pulver said. “We can hash this thing out until December and still not have a tree law.�

That “thing� is the only real sticking point in the law — the issue of whether residents should be charged when the town has to prune or cut down trees on private land. Attorney to the Town Warren Replansky said he wrote the law giving the town the discretion to either charge property owners or not, on a “case-by-case basis.�

“We’re still debating on why we need to charge back residents on pruning or removal,� said Pulver with disbelief, adding that it will likely never happen.

“You don’t need to,� stressed Replansky. “It’s up to the Town Board.

“My thing is if you give somebody 60 days notice and they do something to make it harder,� Pulver said. “Like you could remove a tree for peanuts, and then 60 days later it would cost $3,000 because [of something someone did and] you need a crane to come in, we should have the option to charge for that.�

David objected.

“I showed the law to some other lawyers and they [said it had problems],� she said, adding one attorney called it “arbitrary.�

“There are absolutely no legal problems with charging property owners back,� Replansky said.

“I know how to bring this to a head,� said Councilman Bob Couse. “I make a motion to pass this local law.�

“I second it,� said Councilwoman Rosemary Lyons-Chase.

Replansky interrupted the motion and said the board first had to complete the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) process. He proceeded to walk the board through the short form application, which, it was determined, would cause no negative impacts on the environment. It was also determined that a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) would not be necessary.

Couse then repeated his motion to adopt the local law, with Lyons-Chase seconding the move. Pulver and Councilman George Keeler both voted in favor of adopting the law. David voted against the adoption of Local Law No. 2. After the law passed, David requested to read a statement she had prepared.

“I was very pleased,� she said, that the law was proposed by the CAC. However, she said, the town has “never charged homeowners for pruning or taking down trees in the past.... I feel no law is better than bad law.�

The board acknowledged David’s statement and then moved on to its next matter of business.

Latest News

Classifieds - October 23, 2025

Help Wanted

Weatogue Stables has an opening: for a full time team member. Experienced and reliable please! Must be available weekends. Housing a possibility for the right candidate. Contact Bobbi at 860-307-8531.

Services Offered

Hector Pacay Service: House Remodeling, Landscaping, Lawn mowing, Garden mulch, Painting, Gutters, Pruning, Stump Grinding, Chipping, Tree work, Brush removal, Fence, Patio, Carpenter/decks, Masonry. Spring and Fall Cleanup. Commercial & Residential. Fully insured. 845-636-3212.

Keep ReadingShow less
School spirit on the rise at Housy

Students dressed in neon lined the soccer field for senior night under the lights on Thursday, Oct. 16. The game against Lakeview was the last in a series of competitions Thursday night in celebration of Homecoming 2025.

Hunter Conklin and Danny Lesch

As homecoming week reaches its end and fall sports finish out the season, an air of school spirit and student participation seems to be on the rise across Housatonic Valley Regional High School.

But what can be attributed to this sudden peak of student interest? That’s largely due to SGA. Also known as the Student Government Association, SGA has dedicated itself to creating events to bring the entire student body together. This year, they decided to change some traditions.

Keep ReadingShow less
Student initiatives shake up Homecoming
The poster promoting the Homecoming dance boasted the event would feature dancing, games and a bonfire. Reactions to the planned move outside were mixed, with some students excited about the changes and others expressing a desire for tradition.
Provided

The weekend of Homecoming at HVRHS was packed with events including rival games under the lights, senior night, and a new take on Homecoming that moves it outside — and it wouldn’t have been possible without the students of Housatonic.

Orchestrating was no easy feat, especially considering much of the work was left up to the students.

Keep ReadingShow less
Housy takes on Halloween
Housatonic Valley Regional High School
File photo

As the chilly breeze settles in, Halloween approaches and the community yearns for spooky festivities — HVRHS has answered that calling. An event held annually for the past eight years, the HVRHS haunted house has returned.

The event is organized by the current senior and junior year classes — 2026 and 2027 respectively — and held to raise money that goes toward the junior and senior class’s activities such as senior week, prom, the senior class trip, and more.

Keep ReadingShow less