Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

Repercussions of our policies on terrorists

Jose Padilla is an American citizen who claims he was frequently tortured while he was held in solitary confinement for 3 ½ years without being charged with a crime after his arrest as a suspected terrorist.  Now, a federal judge has decided Padilla can sue the lawyer whose rulings resulted in his physical, emotional and constitutional abuse.  

Padilla is currently serving a 17-year sentence in a federal prison for supporting terrorism and taking part in a conspiracy to provide money and supplies to Islamic extremist groups.  Originally, he was accused, but not charged, with plotting with al Qaeda to detonate a radioactive “dirty bomb.†   

Padilla’s ultimate conviction and sentence aren’t at issue; the denial of his rights as a citizen is and in that respect, things are looking up for this citizen.  A federal judge has ruled he and his mother can sue John Yoo, a lawyer for President Bush, whose advice to the Bush administration legalized the physical and mental abuse Padilla allegedly suffered.  If they prevail, Padilla and his mother will be awarded $1 in damages along with a declaration by the court that his treatment was unconstitutional.  

This is a very important case and, it is equally important to note, it was decided by a U.S. District Court judge in San Francisco who was appointed by President George W. Bush.

According to filings in his lawsuit, Padilla “suffered gross physical and psychological abuse at the hands of federal officials as part of a systematic program of abusive interrogation intended to break down Mr. Padilla’s humanity and will to live.† This interrogation was presumably designed to get him to provide information about the alleged plot to detonate the radioactive bomb, an accusation the feds couldn’t make stick, despite the heretofore forbidden interrogation methods.    

    u    u    u

Yoo wrote many memoranda authorizing harsh treatment of “enemy combatants†as a deputy attorney general in the Office of Legal Counsel and a member of a group called the War Council, which shaped several controversial Bush policies in his “war on terror.â€

“In 2002, Yoo delighted the president’s legal counsel Alberto Gonzales by writing a memorandum that proclaimed Geneva Conventions’ torture agreements were obsolete and saying it wasn’t torture until and if the victim suffered damage to the extent of major organ failure,†I wrote in this column four years ago.

“Yoo had a hand in virtually every major legal decision involving the U.S. response to the attacks of Sept. 11,†wrote Georgetown law professor David Cole in The New York Review of Books, “and at every point, so far as we know, his advice was virtually the same—the president can do whatever he wants.â€

President Obama prohibited most of the torture methods approved by Yoo shortly after becoming president, but the new administration has been obliged to represent Yoo, who is challenging Padilla’s right to sue him for his performance as a government official.  This places the current Obama administration in the awkward position of representing a lawyer whose excesses candidate Obama condemned during the campaign.  

 â€œWe’re not saying we condone torture,†a Justice Department attorney told U.S. District Judge Jeffrey White at a hearing in March on the government’s request to dismiss Padilla’s lawsuit.  But, she maintained, action against a government lawyer “is for the executive to decide,†not the courts.

This argument seemed to trouble Judge White, who wondered if the government lawyer was saying, “If high public officials commit clearly illegal acts, a citizen has no remedy in this court.â€

The judge confirmed his doubts in mid-June when he issued a 42-page ruling allowing the lawsuit to proceed, characterizing it as a conflict “between the requirements of war and the defense of the very freedoms that war seeks to protect.† 

He found that “Yoo set in motion a series of events that resulted in the deprivation of Padilla’s constitutional rights.† In other words, Yoo fixed it so that this particular American citizen was held for years without being charged with a crime and deprived of other rights available to other American citizens.  And while he was waiting, Yoo saw to it that he could be tortured.  After all, we were at war.

It will be interesting to see if the Justice Department, which has said it is considering an appeal of Judge White’s decision, will continue a vigorous defense of Yoo or determine it has done its duty.  

At any rate, the determination by a federal  court that the torture victim can sue is, as one of Padilla’s lawyers said, “a significant victory for American values, government accountability and our system of checks and balances.â€

And since the judge in the case was a Bush appointee, the decision might prompt those on both sides of the ideological divide in this country to recognize the fact that you can’t always judge a judge by the president who appoints him.  It can even make a person believe that the country’s working right again.

Retired journalist Dick Ahles of Simsbury may be reached by e-mail at dahles@hotmail.com.

Latest News

Fallen tree downs power lines, blocks Route 112

Eversource crews work to repair damaged power lines after a tree fell near onto Route 112 just north of the Interlaken Inn on Monday, June 22.

Photo by Nathan Miller

LAKEVILLE — A tree fell on Route 112 Monday, June 22, downing power lines and blocking traffic north of Route 41 near the Hotchkiss Four Corners.

Eversource crews on scene at 4:45 p.m. said power lines were being repaired and utility service had been restored to customers in the area.

Keep ReadingShow less

Francis Lynehan

Francis Lynehan

DOVER PLAINS — Francis “Butch” Lynehan, 75, a twenty-year resident of Dover Plains, New York, formerly of Sharon, passed away unexpectedly on Thursday, May 7, 2026 at Vassar Bros. Medical Center in Poughkeepsie, New York.

Born Aug. 29, 1950, in Sharon, he was the son of the late William W. and Nellie (Kluun) Lynehan.

Keep ReadingShow less

Richard McGriff

Richard McGriff

TACONIC — Richard McGriff died unexpectedly on May 16, 2026. This is a collection of loving reminiscences.

With a smile like that and a laugh like that and a soul like that, how could you not love him? Macey Levin and Gloria Miller

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Juneteenth graduation celebrates Berkshire’s next generation of leaders

Cohort 2026 members Abigail Horace, Adam Liccardi, Adrian Lynch, Cameo Brown, Chauncey Dozier, Claudette Grant, Erline Saintilet, Harmony Edwards, Kamayue Gomes, Mackenzie Colvin, Otis West, Shadre Domingo, TJ West and Tyeesha Keele-Kedroe and Blackshires’ leadership team John Lewis, Patrick Danahey, Dubois Thomas and Julie Haagenson gather at the Blackshires City Hall Fishbowl alongside Mayor Peter Marchetti and city officials Michael Obasohan, Brandon Gill, Katherine VanBramer, Heather Brazeau, Justine Dodds and Jesse Tobin McCauley.

Provided

When designer Abigail Horace joined the Blackshires Leadership Accelerator, she was looking for support for her business, Casa Marcelo, which was founded in Salisbury in 2019. Through the Accelerator, she created the Black Berkshires Social Club, which creates culturally grounded social spaces for Black and BIPOC residents in the region. Throughout her experience, Horace found a community of peers invested in one another’s success.

“Finding Blackshires has been transformative,” Horace said. “Being a BIPOC founder in this region can feel isolating, and this community has changed that. They see my work, champion my business and have opened doors I couldn’t have opened alone.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Forged by curiosity: Art, craftsmanship and big fun with Izzy Fitch

Izzy Fitch at Battle Hill Forge in Wassaic.

Madi Long
I’m not really inventing anything new. I just tweak it a little bit.— Izzy Fitch

A steel praying mantis stands among garden accents at Battle Hill Forge in Wassaic, its folded forelegs ready for prayer and mischief in equal measure.

“She’s very nice,” said blacksmith, sculptor and Battle Hill Forge owner Izzy Fitch, patting the giant insect affectionately. Then he added, “Just don’t go out to dinner with her.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Unexpected subjects, familiar beauty in new Kent exhibits
Millerton-based artist Alexis England with her flamingo and mandrill portraits at Peggy Mercury in Kent.
D.H. Callahan

Kent Barns was alive with art on Saturday, June 13, as three new shows opened at Peggy Mercury and Kenise Barnes Fine Art, featuring a variety of fascinating paintings and drawings from four local artists.

Peggy Mercury, which in just two years has earned a reputation for curating remarkable collections of fine beauty products and accessories, continues to find exciting art to complement its offerings. The new show, “Portraits,” features four pairs of paintings by Millerton-based artist Alexis England. The “portraits” she paints, however, feature some pretty unexpected sitters.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.