Rumsfeld can run, but he can't hide


Recently, when former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld was visiting Paris for a foreign policy talk, the U.S.-based Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) and several European counterparts filed a complaint with the Paris prosecutor, charging Rumsfeld with authorizing torture. (They had previously brought similar charges against Rumsfeld in Germany, and that situation is pending.)

The criminal complaint brings charges under the 1984 Convention Against Torture, ratified into law by both the United States and France. A U.N. report on Guantanamo found that interrogation techniques authorized by Rumsfeld constitute torture. The evidentiary paper trail is overwhelming, and the law is the law. (For a discussion of the law and its long-term implications, see "A Primer on the Law of Torture," in The Lakeville Journal, Nov. 8, 2007.)


u u u


Under the convention, French courts have an obligation to prosecute individuals for direct or command responsibility for torture, if such individuals are present on French territory. French jurisdiction is mandated by the very fact that the U.S. courts have failed to act, and even more explicitly, because President George W. Bush (himself a potential future defendant) has attempted to grant permanent immunity to all U.S. officials who have been engaged in torture in the past.

This adds France to Germany and a growing list of countries to which Rumsfeld can no longer safely travel. As a practical and diplomatic matter, foreign courts are unlikely to act while a U.S. official is still in office and visiting the country in line with official functions. After an official such as Rumsfeld is out of office, however, it's a different story, and there are no time limits on national or international prosecution for violation of the law against torture.

In Paris, Rumsfeld was forced to leave the foreign policy meeting by a side door connected to the U.S. Embassy in order to avoid journalists and human rights attorneys waiting outside. Said CCR President Michael Ratner: "Rumsfeld must understand that he has no place to hide."

The Rumsfeld case, of course, is just the beginning, the tip of a looming iceberg. There is going to be quite a list of out-of-office U.S. officials, at every level of responsibility, who are going to curtail their future travel plans abroad. And who knows, they might some day face U.S. justice at home.

 


Sharon resident Anthony Piel is a former director and legal counsel of the World Health Organization.

Latest News

HVRHS Varsity golf swings into action

Dan Moran, left, and Wiley Fails, right, walk down the fairway to the green with a competitor from Lakeview High School, center. Moran shot 52 on nine holes and Fails shot 57 during Housy's first preseason golf match.

Photo by Riley Klein

LITCHFIELD — Housatonic Valley Regional High School took on Lakeview High School for a Berkshire League preseason match Wednesday, Aug. 28.

Hosted at Lichfield Country Club, the two teams put forth six official golfers to pair up in three foursomes with the lowest four scores contributing to team totals. Additional players from each side matched against each other for practice play.

Keep ReadingShow less
Ann Marie Nonkin

LAKEVILLE — Ann Marie Nonkin, 80, of Millerton Road, passed away Aug. 25, 2024, at Connecticut Hospice in Branford. She was the loving wife of the late Dr. Paul Nonkin.

She was born April 12, 1944 in Queens, New York, the daughter of the late John and Ann Vallen.

Keep ReadingShow less
Cornwall considers taking tax collector off ballot

CORNWALL — Long standing tax collector Jean Bouteiller will step down at the end of her two-year term this November.

With no qualified residents stepping forward to run for the position, the Board of Selectmen discussed the prospect of making the role an appointed job at a meeting Aug. 20.

Keep ReadingShow less
Farmers air struggles at Dutchess County Fair’s annual Ag Forum

Hans Pedersen, age 7, of Sharon, showed his Guernsey, Paisley, at the Dutchess County Fair on Saturday, Aug. 24. The calf was born Dec. 12, 2023, and is from Coon Brothers Farm in Amenia.

Photo by Olivia Valentine

RHINEBECK, N.Y. — The Dutchess County 9th annual Agricultural Forum was held on Aug. 22 at the Dutchess County Fairgrounds.
Local farmers, elected officials, and representatives from conservancy organizations attended the forum to discuss agricultural history and how the industry is a critical component of the county’s economic success, generating over $45 million in sales.

A. Gregg Pulver, Dutchess County Comptroller and farmer, began the forum by introducing representatives of the agricultural community and elected officials who share the same vision: “the promotion of agriculture, horticulture, mechanical and domestic arts, fine arts, and allied sciences through education, instruction, display, and competition.”

Keep ReadingShow less