Rumsfeld can run, but he can't hide


Recently, when former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld was visiting Paris for a foreign policy talk, the U.S.-based Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) and several European counterparts filed a complaint with the Paris prosecutor, charging Rumsfeld with authorizing torture. (They had previously brought similar charges against Rumsfeld in Germany, and that situation is pending.)

The criminal complaint brings charges under the 1984 Convention Against Torture, ratified into law by both the United States and France. A U.N. report on Guantanamo found that interrogation techniques authorized by Rumsfeld constitute torture. The evidentiary paper trail is overwhelming, and the law is the law. (For a discussion of the law and its long-term implications, see "A Primer on the Law of Torture," in The Lakeville Journal, Nov. 8, 2007.)


u u u


Under the convention, French courts have an obligation to prosecute individuals for direct or command responsibility for torture, if such individuals are present on French territory. French jurisdiction is mandated by the very fact that the U.S. courts have failed to act, and even more explicitly, because President George W. Bush (himself a potential future defendant) has attempted to grant permanent immunity to all U.S. officials who have been engaged in torture in the past.

This adds France to Germany and a growing list of countries to which Rumsfeld can no longer safely travel. As a practical and diplomatic matter, foreign courts are unlikely to act while a U.S. official is still in office and visiting the country in line with official functions. After an official such as Rumsfeld is out of office, however, it's a different story, and there are no time limits on national or international prosecution for violation of the law against torture.

In Paris, Rumsfeld was forced to leave the foreign policy meeting by a side door connected to the U.S. Embassy in order to avoid journalists and human rights attorneys waiting outside. Said CCR President Michael Ratner: "Rumsfeld must understand that he has no place to hide."

The Rumsfeld case, of course, is just the beginning, the tip of a looming iceberg. There is going to be quite a list of out-of-office U.S. officials, at every level of responsibility, who are going to curtail their future travel plans abroad. And who knows, they might some day face U.S. justice at home.

 


Sharon resident Anthony Piel is a former director and legal counsel of the World Health Organization.

Latest News

Paul Winter to celebrate the winter solstice at Saint James Place

Seven-time Grammy winning saxophonist Paul Winter, with the Paul Winter Consort, will return to celebrate the Winter Solstice on Saturday, Dec. 21, with sold out shows at 3 p.m. and 7 p.m. at Saint James Place, 352 Main St., Great Barrington, Massachusetts.

A uniquely intimate solstice celebration, in contrast to the large-scale productions done for many years in the Cathedral of Saint John the Divine in New York, it promises to deliver everything audiences have come to love and expect.

Keep ReadingShow less
Developers withdraw application to expand Wake Robin Inn

Wake Robin Inn is located on Sharon Road in Lakeville.

Photo by John Coston

LAKEVILLE — Aradev LLC has withdrawn its application to the Planning and Zoning Commission for a special permit to redevelop the Wake Robin Inn.

In a letter submitted to P&Z Chair Michael Klemens on the afternoon of Tuesday, Dec. 17, law outfit Mackey, Butts & Whalen LLP announced its client’s withdrawal.

Keep ReadingShow less
North Canaan antique mall fills resale niche

The 403 Group is located at 403 Ashley Falls Road, where the old This N’ That for Habitat used to be.

Photo by Robin Roraback

NORTH CANAAN — The 403 Group Antique Market is “A hidden secret, a little off the beaten path, but worth the drive,” said Carey Field, who has a booth called “Wild Turkey” there.

“It’s a really fun group of dealers,” Field said. “A really eclectic group of antiques and the prices are reasonable.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Shooting the breeze with Christopher Little

Martin Tandler

Little with his dog, Ruby.

"What I really feel lucky about is having had the chance to meet and photograph so many people who had a real impact on our lives,” said Christopher Little whose new memoir, “Shooting the Breeze: Memories of a Photojournalist” was just released. The book is as eclectic and colorful as the man himself and offers an intimate look into Little’s globe-trotting career spent behind the lens, capturing some of the most iconic figures, events, and human stories of the past half-century.

In 2021, the Dolph Briscoe Center for American History at The University of Texas acquired Little’s photographic archive.

Keep ReadingShow less