Second Arrest Made in Amenia Girls Case


AMENIA, N.Y. — A second man has been arrested in the case of the two girls who went missing in this community two and a half weeks ago. Joshua Bauer, 23, of Rhinebeck, was arrested last week and charged with criminal facilitation in the second degree, a class C felony.

The charge means it is believed that Bauer provided the means and opportunity for accused rapist Kevin Millsaps to carry out felonious acts, of which he is charged with three. According to Detective Kirk Imperati, public affairs officer for the Dutchess County Sheriff’s Office, Bauer was present when the crimes occurred in his Rhinebeck apartment.

Millsaps, 23, of Staatsburg, stands accused of predatory sexual assault against a child, a class A felony that could carry a life sentence, first-degree rape and first-degree criminal sexual activity, both class B felonies, each of which carries a maximum sentence of 25 years in state prison.

The accusations against the men are the result of a more than 24-hour nightmare in which the two girls, one 11 and one 12, went missing. They were last seen Jan. 7 at the Cumberland Farms in Amenia, where they reportedly got into a gold-colored car with a man later alleged to have been Millsaps.


Connecticut Proposes Internet Sex Protection Act


In the Connecticut Legislature, Senate Republicans announced on Jan. 24 that they will introduce legislation that would ensure tougher jail sentences for convicted child predators, including those who use the Internet to find and make contact with their victims.

One part of the proposal is modeled after Florida’s "Jessica’s Law." Under the Connecticut version proposed today, anyone convicted of sexually assaulting a child under the age of 13 would be sentenced to 25 years in prison for a first offense and life imprisonment for a subsequent offense. The law also applies to anyone convicted of promoting prostitution or using a child under 13 to make pornography.

Once released from prison, a convicted child predator would be place on special probation and have to wear a GPS-type tracking device for life.

The Connecticut GOP is also proposing an Internet Child Protection Act, which would apply the same sentencing structure to anyone convicted of using a computer to attempt to entice a child under 13 into having sex.

As it stands now, sexual assault of a child under 13 is a class A felony and receives a sentence of 10 to 25 years in prison.

For enticing a minor through the Internet, the first offense is a class D felony and brings a sentence of 1 to 5 years. The second offense is a class C felony with a sentence of 1 to 10 years. Subsequent offenses are class B felonies with a sentence of 1 to 20 years.

Currently 21 states have passed versions of Jessica’s Law. The Connecticut Senate passed a "compromise" version of the law durig the 2006 legislative session, according to state republican spokesman Brett Cody. The bill never came up for a vote in the House.

New York state does not yet have a version of Jessica’s Law. However, the state’s office of the attorney general has an Internet bureau that it touts as "one of the first of its kind in the nation." The bureau helps coordinate statewide investigations and prosecutions of illegal Internet activity, and reviews and prepares relevant state legislation.

State Sen. Andrew Roraback (R-30) said he doesn’t expect there to be much opposition to the bills, which are meant to "modernize Connecticut’s laws, which don’t keep up with technology."

There may be some discussion of the length of sentences, he said. "We are also talking about what to do in cases that involve children who are 13,14, 15 years old."

Internet sex crimes are increasing at an alarming rate, Roraback observed.

"Unfortunately, hardly a week goes by that we don’t learn of someone having been entrapped by the Internet. It’s a heinous, heinous business because people that are skilled in using this medium can misrepresent themselves, they can misrepresent their age, they can misrepresent their intentions. And they earn the confidence of, and prey on, young people."

With the proposed Internet Protection Act, Roraback said the senate is "trying to draw attention to a new type of crime that has to be dealt with seriously."


— Cynthia Hochswender

The following day, Monday, sheriff’s deputies found the two girls at Cousin’s Mini Market on Route 22 in Wassaic, after one girl phoned her father.

Within a short time, Millsaps was stopped on the highway, arrested without incident and taken into custody.

It is now believed that during their time with Millsaps, the girls were taken to Bauer’s apartment for a couple of hours, where the sexual assault of both girls took place. Authorities are not saying if both girls were raped.

Although the names of the girls appeared in the media during the 24 hours they were missing, it is the policy of this newspaper not to identify minor victims.

In addition to the second degree criminal facilitation felony charge, Bauer faces misdemeanor charges of fourth-degree criminal facilitation and two counts of endangering the welfare of a child. He pleaded not guilty last Thursday to the felony, which could carry a sentence of up to 15 years in prison.

Judge William Sanchez issued an order of protection mandating Bauer keep away from the two girls for a year. Bauer was released from jail on $50,000 bond.

Millsaps is also out of jail after his parents posted $100,000 bail, and then later, when arrested a second time and charged with predatory sexual assault, a $150,000 bail. He must wear an electronic monitoring device as part of his release, and he is confined to his parents’ house. Law enforcement also removed his computer so he will not have access to the Internet.

It was through the Internet, and a MySpace page, that the girls reportedly met Millsaps.

Latest News

Frederick Wright Hosterman

KENT — Frederick Wright Hosterman passed away peacefully in his home in Kent on April 16, 2025. Born in 1929 in Auburn, Nebraska, he was the son of farmers. He attended a one-room schoolhouse just outside of Brownville, Nebraska, adjacent to his family’s farm. The little brick schoolhouse is still standing! After graduating from high school, Fred attended the University of Nebraska (Lincoln), eventually earning a master’s degree in agronomy. He took a job with Monsanto in Buffalo, New York, where the company was a pioneer in applying biotechnology to agricultural sciences. In Buffalo, Fred met his future wife, Dorothy. Fred and Dorothy moved to New York City for several years in the early 1960s, before settling down in Norwalk. In Norwalk, Fred and Dorothy had three children. The family later moved to Kent. In 1980, Fred and Dorothy divorced, and Fred bought a large tract of land on Carter Road in Kent. He built a house there, largely by himself, which he maintained until his death at age 95. After taking early retirement, he spent the following decades working on his property, adding various buildings, woodcrafting, landscaping, and spending time with his children and grandchildren.

Keep ReadingShow less
Nancy (Case) Brenner

CANAAN — Nancy (Case) Brenner, 81, of Canaan, passed away peacefully in her sleep at Charlotte Hungerford Hospital in Torrington, following a long illness on Good Friday, April 18, 2025.

Nancy was born on April 10, 1944, to the late Ray Sargeant Case Sr. and Beatrice Southey Case. She was the second youngest of five children, predeceased by her three brothers, Ray S. Case Jr., David E. Case and Douglas C. Case, and her sister Linda (Case) Olson. She grew up in New Hartford and Winsted, where she graduated from Northwestern Regional 7 High School.

Keep ReadingShow less
Adam Rand

SHEFFIELD — Adam Rand, 59, of Sheffield, Massachusetts, passed away peacefully in his home on April 22, 2025, after a long battle with ALS.

Adam was born on April 6, 1966, to Lee and Charles Rand II of Boston, Massachusetts. Adam spent his early childhood in Nantucket, where his love of fishing and water was born before moving to Sharon. It was here where he made many lifelong friends and later graduated from Housatonic Valley Regional High School in 1984. He attended Hiram College in Ohio before settling in Connecticut.

Keep ReadingShow less