The Story of Sacred Art to Carousel Horses


This is a story of perseverance. And love. And history. And more.

For me, it began with a love of carousel animals, the magical artistry that produced the horses, the lions, the giraffes and the frogs of those fanciful turn-of-the-century merry-go-rounds, mostly now gone.

For artist and teacher Murray Zimiles, it was the love of wooden synagogues that led to his guest curating "Gilded Lions and Jeweled Horses: The Synagogue to the Carousel," on view at the American Folk Art Museum in New York City.

The show includes scores of marvelous religious carvings of animals - Jewish law forbade the human form in sacred art - as well as gravestone art and wonderfully intricate paper cutouts, which hung in Eastern European synagogues and homes. It also includes a dozen delightful carved carousel animals, produced in the late 18th and early 19th century by Jewish woodcarvers who emigrated to New York. How Zimiles traced one to the other is the show's story.

Twenty years ago, Zimiles, a Millerton, NY, resident and a professor at Purchase College, read and was smitten by "Wooden Synagogues," which depicted 16th-18th century synagogues in Europe, most now destroyed. That led to travels in Poland, where he became entranced by the carvings that had decorated them.

Back home, he dug out a catalog from the folk art museum of a show in the mid-80s, "The Jewish Heritage in American Folk Art." That's when he realized the connection between the tradition of Jewish religious carving in Europe and its more secular form in America. He was hooked on exploring it. The folk museum agreed to let him do it.

What he discovered as he set across Europe on his search was a world of exquisite wood carvings and gravestone markers, often in animal - lions, eagles, serpents - and floral form. Elaborate paper cutouts were sometimes used as preliminary "drawings" for carvers but also depicted psalms for synagogue interiors or in homes, served as mizrahs, signs that indicate east, the direction of Jerusalem and of prayer. Paper cutouts were made with small scissors on folded paper, with further details cut with tiny knives; interestingly, these incredibly intricate pieces were made by boys and men. Much of the carving was family based, passed down from father to son. The artists were most often anonymous but the level of their work bespoke years of training.

The religious carvings in the "Gilded Lions" are indeed gorgeous; the surprise is the breathtaking beauty of the paper cutouts. Their elaborate intricacy and detail is astounding, the birds and animals, including wolves, unicorns, snakes and elephants are wildly imaginative. These are amazing works, not the least because of their painstaking painting in brilliant colors.

The fervor and talent that went into these art forms were often translated, when the artists came to the United States, into more secular forms.

"This is a very American story," Zimiles said. "From the sacred to the secular... it's an immigrant's story, too." In Europe, he said, "You had to look to the messianic future; there was nothing else to look toward. But in America, you were judged on who you were and what you could do, not on your religious fervor."

As Eastern European Jews were emigrating to the United States, amusement areas were beginning to flourish in cities around the country. And with them came the carousel, and in turn, "schools" of carousel carving. One such area, and school, was Coney Island, which absorbed a number of master Jewish carvers.

And so it was that the primary creators of carousels in Coney Island - comprising the "Coney Island School"- were Eastern European Jews: Marcus Charles Illions, Solomon Stein, Harry Goldstein, and Charles Carmel (there were doubtless others, but Anglicizing names and the lack of documentation make it difficult to know for sure).

Each carver had his particular style and arguably the most talented was Marcus Charles Illions, the son of a Russian horse-trader, who knew the horse anatomy intimately. His shop eventually employed his extended family. His horses, of which two are on display in this show along with a muscular lion, were "some of the most animated carousel animals ever made," Zimiles said.

But Illions had competition: Two were Solomon Stein and Harry Goldstein, who originally worked for another Jewish immigrant carver of horses, William Mangels. Together, Stein and Goldstein produced 17 carousels, one of which - the carousel in Central Park - is still in operation.

Charles Carmel also worked for Mangels, and then opened his own shop, which produced a carousel for Coney Island's Dreamland Park. The day before it was scheduled to open, the entire park burned to the ground. From then on Carmel sold his animals to other manufacturers of carousels, including Mangels and Stein and Goldstein.

It's clear from viewing the wonderful specimens on display in the show that the Coney Island carvers absorbed the methods employed in "the old country": the visual iconography of lions, birds, serpents; the fully dimensional carving techniques; the pierced scrollwork and vivid coloring of paper cutouts; the intricate vines and flowers from gravestones that later adorned horses' manes and bridles. One look at the snarling lions guarding the Torah's ark makes clear the lineage of the snarling lion at the arcade.

The melding of that tradition with elements from other cultures the new immigrants found here and embraced gave the American carousel its particularly innovative, playful and imaginative aspect that allowed it "to reach a height of artistry not achieved elsewhere," writes Zimiles in the show's accompanying book. And this melding made the Coney Island School "In my opinion, probably the greatest carousel carving school."

The carousel building business collapsed just before the Depression, brought about by dwindling supplies after World War I, the public's desire for more thrilling rides and machines which began to produce animals in aluminum more efficiently - if less beautifully. And by immigrants who raised their sons not to carve, but to go to college. The Depression itself drove the last nail, so to speak, in the coffin. And so another art form began to disappear.

At one point in his research, Zimiles said, "I thought, 'If I get hit by a truck, I'm the only person who knows about this stuff.' "

Luckily, no longer.

 

 

 


"Gilded Lions and Jeweled Horses:The Synagogue to the Carousel," is on view at the American Folk Art Museum, 45 West 53rd St., through March 23. For information, go to www.info@folkartmuseum.org.

 

The accompanying hard-back book of the same name, with abundant color and black-and-white illustrations, is available at the museum and at Oblong Books in Millerton, NY .

Latest News

Crescendo’s upcoming tribute to Wanda Landowska

Kenneth Weiss (above) will play a solo recital performance in honor of Wanda Landowska, a harpischord virtuoso, who lived in Lakeville for many years.

Provided

On Sept. 14, Crescendo, the award-winning music program based in Lakeville, will present a harpsichord solo recital by Kenneth Weiss in honor of world-renowned harpsichordist Wanda Landowska. Landowska lived in Lakeville from 1941 to 1959. Weiss is a professor at the Paris Conservatoire and has taught at Julliard. Born in New York, he now resides in Europe.

Weiss will play selections from “A Treasury of Harpsichord Music.” It includes works by Baroque composers such as Bach, Mozart, and Handel. It was recorded by Landowska at her Lakeville home, at 63 Millerton Road, which overlooks Lakeville Lake. Weiss said, “I am honored and excited to play in Lakeville, where Wanda Landowska lived.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Silent cinema, live magic

The live audience at Music Mountain takes in a silent film Sept. 7.

Natalia Zukerman

On Saturday, Sept. 7, Gordon Hall at Music Mountain was transformed into a time machine, transporting the audience for a 1920’s spectacular of silent films and live music. Featuring internationally acclaimed silent film musicians Donald Sosin and Joanna Seaton, the evening began with a singalong of songs by Gershwin, Irving Berlin and more. Lyrics for favorites like “Ain’t We Got Fun,” “Yes Sir That’s My Baby,” and “Ain’t Misbehavin’” were projected on the screen and Sosin and Seaton lead the crowd with an easeful joy. The couple then retreated to the side of the stage where they provided the live and improvised score for Buster Keaton’s 1922 short, “Cops,” and his 1924 comedy, “Sherlock Jr.”

Joanna Seaton and Donald Sosin, a husband-and-wife duo, have crafted a singular career, captivating audiences at some of the world’s most prestigious film festivals—New York, TriBeCa, San Francisco, Seattle, Denver, Telluride, and Yorkshire among them. Their performances have graced venerable institutions like MoMA, Film at Lincoln Center, the AFI Silver Theatre, and Moscow’s celebrated Lumière Gallery. Their melodic journey has taken them to far-flung locales such as the Thailand Silent Film Festival and the Jecheon International Music and Film Festival in South Korea. Notably, Seaton and Sosin have become a fixture at Italy’s renowned silent film festivals in Bologna and Pordenone, where they perform annually.

Keep ReadingShow less
Desperately seeking Susan Seidelman

The cover art for Seidelman's memoir "Desperately Seeking Something."

Provided

On Thursday, Sept. 19 at 6 p.m., Haystack Book Talks will present a special evening with director Susan Seidelman, author of “Desperately Seeking Something: A Memoir About Movies, Mothers, and Material Girls.” Part of the Haystack Book Festival run by Michael Selleck, the event will take place at the Norfolk Library, featuring a conversation with Mark Erder after a screening of the 1984 classic, “Desperately Seeking Susan.”

Susan Seidelman’s fearless debut film, “Smithereens,” premiered in 1982 and was the first American indie film to ever compete at Cannes. Then came “Desperately Seeking Susan,” a smash hit that not only solidified her place in Hollywood but helped launch Madonna’s career. Her films, blending classic Hollywood storytelling with New York’s downtown energy, feature unconventional women navigating unique lives. Seidelman continued to shape pop culture into the ’90s, directing the pilot for “Sex and the City.” Four decades later, Seidelman’s stories are still as sharp, funny, and insightful as ever.

Keep ReadingShow less
Annual Tritle organ concert at Smithfield

Kent Tritle at the organ of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine in NYC.

Joshua Smitth

An anticipated fall favorite event at The Smithfield Church is the now-annual virtuoso organ performance by Kent Tritle, organist for the New York Philharmonic, this year to be joined by Arthur Fiacco, Jr. on Cello. The concert will be held on Saturday, Sept. 14, at 3:30 p.m. Proceeds will benefit the Oratorio Society of New York where Tritle serves as Music Director.

For the past ten years, Tritle has performed an annual concert on the Smithfield Church’s historic tracker organ, a favorite of his. The program will include a variety of selections, from classical to modern, along with Tritle’s incomparable commentary on each. Selections will include organ solos and duets with cello, interpreting the works of Bach, Vivaldi and Mendelssohn, with two works by modern composers.

Keep ReadingShow less