Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

Why the general had to go

Here are the reasons why President Barack Obama had to fire Gen. Stanley McChrystal:

1) Respect.

The general’s remarks to a Rolling Stone reporter showed lack of respect for the president, the vice president, the national security adviser, and the president’s diplomatic team in Afghanistan.

Even worse, it showed a lack of respect for the troops — soldiers and service personnel on the ground in Afghanistan. Did the general ever think about them and their respect for the chain of command before he indulged himself in contempt? Did he ever think about their morale and his responsibility to them?

If he did, he did not think long and hard enough.

For lack of respect the general had to be fired.

2) Discipline.

To succeed, any organization needs a certain degree of discipline. That must come from the top. We need to succeed in Afghanistan. That is, we need to catch some anti-U.S. terrorists and disrupt their organization, stabilize Afghanistan, and Pakistan, and then leave it to our allies in both places, withdrawing our troops and leaving money and humanitarian aid behind.

Success cannot be achieved without discipline.

The military cannot function without discipline.

For lack of discipline and the lack of discipline among his staff, who also spouted off, the general had to be fired.

3) Judgment.

Getting drunk with your staff on a bus and trashing your colleagues and superiors to a kid with a tape recorder in his hand is as clear a case of bad judgment as you could ask for.

The general’s frat-boy behavior with his staff is also, by itself, shocking.

You  need good judgment to lead, especially to lead soldiers. We need Eisenhower and Marshall, not Rush Limbaugh and Don Rickles.

A person is entitled to his private thoughts, but what in the world makes a commanding general give an interview to anyone, let alone a chest-thumping rant of an interview?

And what makes him feel he is entitled to scrutinize his commander-in-chief?

For his poor judgment, the general had to be fired.

4) Civilian control.

In our system, the military answers to an elected, civilian head of state.

The military is not a nation unto itself. It is not a law unto itself.

No general is bigger than the presidency — not a president, but the presidency.

That goes to the heart of our Constitution and our democratic republic.

Political generals are dangerous in democracy.

Arrogant generals are a danger to our Constitution and our troops.

Harry Truman affirmed  this principle when he fired Douglas MacArthur, whom Truman and most of America thought to be brilliant.

And McChrystal is no Mac-Arthur.

In the final analysis, civilian control matters more than brilliance.

No man is indispensable. No general can be.

A good rule for presidents is to ask what Harry Truman would do.

Another is to ask what Abe Lincoln would do.

We have an objective and historical answer in both cases.

When a general places himself above the presidency, his troops, and the law, he must be dispatched.

Keith C. Burris is editorial page editor of the Journal Inquirer in Manchester.

Latest News

HVRHS Announces Senior Awards

HVRHS Announces Senior Awards

Senior awards for the HVRHS Class of 2026 have been announced.

Nathan Miller

The Housatonic Valley Regional High School senior awards were announced for the Class of 2026. The graduation ceremony was held Friday, June 19. Student speakers acknowledged the importance of community, as several reflected on overcoming significant adversity in their young lives.

Norma Lake Award - Shanaya Duprey

Keep ReadingShow less

The nature of Upstate Art Weekend

The nature of Upstate Art Weekend
Opening of Upstate Art Weekend at Olana with Helen Toomer, Ellen Harvey, Jean Shin and Gabriela Salazar
D.H. Callahan

On Thursday, June 25, a collection of eager art enthusiasts gathered at Olana State Historic Estate in Hudson to kick off the seventh annual Upstate Art Weekend (UAW).

Helen Toomer, founder, was joined by sculptors Ellen Harvey, Jean Shin and Gabriela Salazar to discuss their work and the legacy of painter Frederic Church. Church, whose 200th birthday is being celebrated this year, is widely credited as one of the founding members of the Hudson River School of painting. The discussion took place at Olana, Church’s grand estate, where the three artists’ installations are on view.

Keep ReadingShow less
Benjamin Reynaert and the art of layered living

Benjamin Reynaert

Jennifer Almquist
Creating a home is, at its core, an act of love.
— Benjamin Reynaert

Benjamin Reynaert is focused on creative direction and interior styling. He is market director at Elle Décor, a design consultant, and author of “The Layered Home: Inspiration for Crafting Cozy, Collected Rooms,” published this year by Clarkson Potter. He co-founded Ticking Tent, a market featuring antiques, luxury items and vintage treasures. The biannual event is held in New Preston, Connecticut, and Bedford, New York.

Adopted from South Korea at 3 months old, Reynaert grew up in Bloomfield Hills, Michigan. He always knew he wanted to be an artist. “I just loved drawing. I loved making things with clay,” he said. “Remembering what it felt like to be creative as kids and applying that to our creativity as adults is essential.” A graduate of the Rhode Island School of Design (RISD), where he earned a BFA and a degree in architecture, Reynaert also studied bookbinding in Rome. His attention to detail and aesthetic sense reflect years of training and a finely tuned eye for objects. “Attending RISD nurtured my creativity and taught me how to problem-solve,” he said.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Beneath the surface: Delano Dunn and Mickalene Thomas explore history, memory and art

Mickalene Thomas and Delano Dunn at Wassaic Project.

Lucia Landolo

Before “Echoes in the Margin,” Delano Dunn’s new solo exhibition at Troutbeck in Amenia opened, the artist sat down with curator and artist Mickalene Thomas for a conversation at the Wassaic Project on Wednesday, June 24. Their wide-ranging discussion offered an intimate look into Dunn’s practice while situating the work within broader questions of history, memory and representation.

Presented by the Wassaic Project, the exhibition brings Dunn’s richly layered paintings into conversation with Troutbeck itself, the historic estate long associated with artists, writers and civil rights leaders, including W.E.B. Du Bois, Langston Hughes and many more.

Keep ReadingShow less
Local performer Vemilo transforms the Moviehouse

Vemilo performs at the Moviehouse in Millerton.

D.H. Callahan

On Friday, June 26, patrons at the Moviehouse in Millerton were treated to a performance by local artist and musician Vemilo, who returned to the theater’s biggest room for a second full-length show.

Regular patrons will know Theatre Three as the setting for post-screening interviews, Q&As, discussions and the theater’s monthly movie trivia night. Vemilo’s performance entirely reimagined the space. With just a few props and pieces of furniture, the stage was transformed into Vemilo’s sanctuary.

Keep ReadingShow less
After a Hollywood career, Scott Siegler turns failure into fiction

Scott Siegler at his home in Sharon.

D.H. Callahan

Scott Siegler is bored of success stories. But Scott Siegler has had the kind of successful Hollywood career that people write books about.

Before he was 30, he’d earned three degrees. Before he moved to Hollywood, he’d already won an Emmy for one of the nine documentaries he directed and produced. Before he helped launch Netscape, bringing the Internet to the public, he’d already started his own Hollywood studio.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.