Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

The confused and dangerous ‘Zero Dark Thirty’

 

Director Kathryn Bigelow and writer Mark Boal lost their way in “Zero Dark Thirty” the moment they staked a claim to journalistic authenticity. “Based on Accounts of Actual Events” lingers across the entire screen for several seconds before the action starts. After that, they had nowhere to hide when challenges to the film’s factual accuracy justifiably poured in. Once filmmakers purport to give viewers history, they can’t take refuge under the mantle of creative license, as Bigelow and Boal have sought to do. 

The central factual claim of ZD30 is that torture (the CIA liked to call it “enhanced interrogation techniques” [EIT]) extracted information from a fictional al-Qaeda-affiliated captive named Ammar. This was the “war name” of Osama bin Laden’s courier, Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti, who later was tracked to Abbottabad and bin Laden’s compound. After we are treated in the movie to the grisly details of his torment at a CIA black site, Ammar gives up the key fact that finally led us to bin Laden. But the filmmakers’ claim is wrong.

•    •    •

In an April 27, 2012, Joint Statement, senators Dianne Feinstein (chair, Senate Intelligence Committee) and Carl Levin (chair, Senate Armed Services Committee) expressed disappointment that Jose Rodriguez, the CIA’s former deputy director of operations, “and others ... continue to insist that [the EITs] used many years ago were a central component” in locating bin Laden. “This view is misguided and misinformed....”

 

Compounding that distortion, the filmmakers keep insisting on torture’s total effectiveness. “In the end, everybody breaks, bro, it’s biology,” Dan, the CIA interrogator, says to his victim. He intones over and over, “If you lie to me, I hurt you.” And so he does, in a festival of torture porn. And in the film, at least, Dan is proved right — the fictitious Ammar spills the beans. Later on, when pressed for details on who lived in the compound, the senior CIA official laments the demise of the EITs: “Who the hell am I supposed to ask, some guy at Gitmo who’s all lawyered up?” He’s suggesting they could have wrung the vital information out of detainees if they still had those techniques.

•      •      •

How could such reputable filmmakers, in telling the thrilling story of America’s clearest victory in the War on Terrorism, put out such damaging distortions? Were they seduced by rarified access offered by the CIA element that still seeks to justify the EITs, so they never got to the truth? So they never talked to others at the Company sickened by what it had done? And never spoke to Ali Soufan, the former FBI supervisory special agent who investigated highly sensitive and complex international terrorism cases, including the 9/11 attacks, or the heroes who worked with him? Or did Hollywood’s tawdry blandishments — high ticket sales, potential awards and fame — carry away their better judgment? We probably will never know, but I side with Jane Mayer, the recognized authority on post-9/11 torture, who said at a Fordham Law event I attended on Jan. 24: “This would have been a tough movie for Hollywood to fund, if the filmmakers had done it right.” In other words, no torture porn sold as the infallible way to the truth, no movie.

•      •      •

The damage done by Bigelow’s and Boal’s distortions looms as real and substantial, for our nation has never worked through whether to reject torture forever, no matter what the circumstances. America did abandon the EITs almost a decade ago. Both John McCain and Barack Obama during the 2008 presidential campaign vowed never to torture, and Obama made good on his promise the second day in office, when he signed an executive order banning it. But executive orders can be rescinded by a future president, and Mitt Romney campaigned on bringing back the EITs. The same Jose Rodriguez, who also was responsible for destroying video tapes of abu Zubaydah’s (see my Sept. 14, 2012, column) and Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri’s coercive interrogations, continues to tout the EITs’ effectiveness. The popular TV show “24” used to teach us weekly that torture helps to keep us safe. In the Feb. 7 New York Review of Books, Steve Coll tells us that public support for torture has risen significantly in opinion polls during the last several years. Will we return to Dick Cheney’s “dark side?” Will no one remember that Ibn al-Sheik al-Libi, who ran an al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan, confessed under torture to the existence of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq? 

Any chance that the reckoning on our torturing will happen in criminal prosecutions of those who practiced the EITs appears remote; President Obama has rejected such prosecutions. But the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence recently finished its 6,000-plus page study on CIA torture and detention. Based on a review of more than 6 million pages of CIA and other records and buttressed by more than 35,000 footnotes, the report exhaustively describes what was done in our name. Sen. Feinstein believes “it to be one of the most significant oversight efforts in the history” of the Senate.

•      •      •

The SSCI must release the report to the public with as few redactions as possible. Sharing the study with the people would provide the best hope for the reckoning this country so desperately needs, for only when people know all the facts can our nation at long last be done with torture forever.

 

Charles R. Church is an attorney practicing in Salisbury who focuses primarily on Guantanamo Bay, detention, torture, habeas corpus and related issues.

Latest News

Van strikes utility pole, closes Route 112 for hours

Traffic was diverted near Wells Hill Road after a crash closed part of Route 112 Friday afternoon.

By James H. Clark

A van crashed into a utility pole on Route 112 near Wells Hill Road Friday afternoon, leaving the driver hospitalized in serious condition and forcing the highway to close for several hours.

The crash was reported at approximately 3:20 p.m., according to Connecticut State Police Troop B.

Keep ReadingShow less
Voices from our Salisbury community about the housing we need for a healthy, economically vibrant future

Renee Wilcox

If you’ve ever wandered through Paley’s Farm Market, you probably know Renee Wilcox. For thirty years, she has been greeting you with unmistakable warmth—always ready with a smile. Renee grew up in Millerton, but it was in Salisbury that her family found something they’d never had before: a true sense of home. In 2003, she and her husband Bill were living in Millerton, but Bill—a volunteer with the Lakeville Hose Company—was already part of Salisbury life. When the Salisbury Housing Trust finished eight new homes on East Main Street (Dunham Drive), Renee and Bill were the first to sign on.

The story of those houses is really a story about the best parts of our community. Richard Dunham and his wife, Inge, along with the Housing Trust board, poured years of energy and hope into the project. Renee can’t help but light up when she talks about the people who helped her family settle in. Digby Brown came by to install appliances and bathroom cabinets; Barbara Niles spent hours painting; Carl Williams assembled bunk beds for the kids. Rick Cantele, at Salisbury Bank, helped them with their finances so they could qualify for a mortgage, while neighbors arrived at their door with fruit baskets and welcoming words.

Keep ReadingShow less
Trade Secrets: a glamorous garden event with a deeper mission

Heavy stone garden ornaments, a specialty of Judy Milne Antiques from Kingston, at Trade Secrets 2025.

Christine Bates

Tucked away on Porter Street in downtown Lakeville, Project SAGE is an unassuming building from a street view. But cross the threshold a week before Trade Secrets — one of the region’s biggest gardening events, long associated with Martha Stewart and glamorous plants of all varieties — and you’ll find a bustling world of employees and volunteers getting ready for the organization’s most important event of the year.

“It’s not usually like this,’ laughed Project SAGE director Kristen van Ginhoven. “But with Trade Secrets just around the corner, it’s definitely like this.”

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Two artists, two Hartford stages, one shared life

Caroline Kinsolving and Gary Capozzielo at home in Salisbury with their dogs, Petruchio and Beatrice

Provided
"He played his violin, I worked on my lines, we walked the dog, and suddenly we were circling each other perfectly."
Caroline Kinsolving

Actor Caroline Kinsolving and violinist Gary Capozziello enjoy their quiet life with their two dogs in Salisbury, yet are often pulled apart to perform on distant stages in far-flung cities. Currently, the planets have aligned, and both are working in Hartford, across Bushnell Park from one another. Bridgewater native Kinsolving is starring in “Circus Fire,” the current production of TheaterWorks Hartford, while Capozziello is a violinist and assistant concertmaster of the Hartford Symphony Orchestra. While Kinsolving hates being away from home, she feels the distance nourishes their relationship.

“We are guardians of each other’s confidence and self-esteem,” she said.

Keep ReadingShow less
Local filmmaker turns spotlight back on Hollywood’s Mermaid

Esther Williams in “Million Dollar Mermaid” (1952).

Provided

For decades, Esther Williams was one of Hollywood’s brightest stars, but the swimming sensation of the silver screen has largely faded from public memory — a disappearance that intrigued Millerton filmmaker Brian Gersten and inspired him to revisit her legacy.

As a millennial, Gersten grew up largely unaware of Williams’ influential career. His teen years in Chicago were spent with friends who obsessed over movies, spending hours at their local independent video store,and watching anything that caught their eye. Somehow, though, they never ventured into the glossy world of synchronized-swimming musicals of the 1940s and ‘50s.

Keep ReadingShow less
Summer exhibition opens at Wassaic Project

Nate King, “When I Was Younger And Now That I’m Older,” 2026, Digital projection, digital animation, photography.

photo courtesy Nate King

The Wassaic Project, the 8,000-square-foot, seven-story former grain elevator transformed into a vibrant arts space, opens its 2026 Summer Exhibition, “Because, now is the time of monsters,” on Saturday, May 16, from 3-6 p.m. at Maxon Mills, launching a season-long presentation featuring 39 artists working across installation, performance, video and sculpture.

The opening celebration will include an afternoon of exhibitions and live programming throughout the historic mill building and its surrounding spaces. Gallery and Art Nest hours run from 12-6 p.m., with special presentations scheduled throughout the day.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.