Colonial Theatre’s 21st century comeback
Stacey and David Fiorillo and Marc and Lenore Mallet (shown left to right), new owners of the Colonial Theatre in Canaan.
Photo by Kathryn Boughton

Colonial Theatre’s 21st century comeback

CANAAN — Back when movies were new, when a Saturday matinee or an evening show was an adventure for a rural town, Seth Moseley, a wealthy New Haven hotelier, built The Casino in Canaan as a fancy trinket for his young wife’s birthday.

The entertainment center, purchased by the Boscardin family in 1929 and renamed the Colonial, soon became the entertainment hub for the community, featuring the brand-new “talkies,” vaudeville shows, high school graduations, roller skating and community balls in the ornate upstairs ballroom.

In a day before cell phones, tablets and large-screen televisions, the theater was packed on Friday nights and Saturdays, and there was even a town meeting to discuss whether the sanctity of the Sabbath could be disturbed by Sunday screenings. But that was long ago, and movie theaters have struggled over the intervening decades. The Colonial, once virtually derelict, has been shuttered since 1997 except for an extensive refurbishment and brief revival in the early 2000s. 

Now the excitement is returning. In April, Lenore and Marc Mallett and David and Stacey Fiorillo, two Salisbury couples, purchased the old theater, rolled up their sleeves, and plotted a future designed to bring life and activity back to downtown Canaan.

The couples, all of whom have other “day jobs,” quickly fell in love with the theater when they first toured it. “They had just reduced the price and we decided to take a look,” said Lenore Mallet. “We just popped in and when we saw how beautiful the interior is, we said, ‘Oh, my God,’ and the wheels started turning. When we walked out the door, we knew we were going to buy it.”

They devised a plan to return the building to its status as a community hub, offering the space for events as varied as corporate meetings, charity events, birthday and anniversary parties, weddings, live performances, educational seminars, movies, and dances. “We’re really excited,” said Mallet. “It was a little slow at the beginning, but now our phones are ringing off the hook.”

Indeed, the neon marquee once again lights up Railroad Street, advertising events as diverse as a “Dragons” game-playing convention and sponsored movies, many of them free for patrons. In the coming weeks, area residents can expect to see classic holiday movies such as “Elf,” sponsored by SHG Event Planning; “National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation,” supported by Rick and Sasha McCue; and the all-time favorite “It’s a Wonderful Life,” underwritten by the Community Health and Wellness Center. 

Sadly, the whimsical “Ratatouille,” the animated tale of a kitchen rat turned Parisian chef, and a corresponding food event by Tory Hill, is fully subscribed. 

Many events are sponsored by local businesses, whose names appear on the marquee in the week before the event. While sponsored movies have been free to date, Mallet said the theater may soon charge a nominal fee. “Because the movies are free, we have had a lot of no-shows,” she said. “We think if we charge something like $2 for kids and $5 for adults, it will encourage people to come.” Half the funds would be used for operational expenses and half would be donated to local charities.

For some children, the experience of going to the movies in a theater resurrects the excitement felt by children in the first decades of the 20th century. A small boy was seen sobbing in a seat when AHA sponsored “Legos II.” Concerned adults moved to console him, but soon learned his tears were tears of joy. “So excited,” he kept saying.

Over the Thanksgiving weekend, two ski films were screened, the first from Teton Gravity Research titled “Legend Has It,” and the second, Warren Miller’s “All Time.” 

But it’s not all flicks — a comedy show is planned for Saturday, Dec. 1, when local comedian Ronnie Reed will host his comedically talented friends. A portion of the proceeds will benefit Canaan’s Fishes and Loaves. It will be followed Sunday,  Dec. 10, by a free book talk on “The Fabulist: The Lying, Hustling, Grifting, Stealing, and Very American Legend of George Santos” with author Mark Chiusano. The author will sign books available for purchase at the event, courtesy of Oblong Books. Attendees are asked to RSVP.

At the front of the venerable building are two retail spaces. One is occupied by a hair salon, while the other space will soon host pop-up store Hither Lane, a housewares store “somewhat like William Sonoma.” “She is testing the market to see where she wants to set up her business,” said Mallet. “We need retail on Main Street, so we are really excited.”

The two couples are also reviving another tradition — first jobs for young people. They recently interviewed high school students who would be tasked with running the concession bar and greeting patrons. “So many people have told us this was their first job,” said Mallet. “We want to offer that experience to a new generation.”

For more information, visit www.canaancolonial.com

Latest News

Frederick Wright Hosterman

KENT — Frederick Wright Hosterman passed away peacefully in his home in Kent on April 16, 2025. Born in 1929 in Auburn, Nebraska, he was the son of farmers. He attended a one-room schoolhouse just outside of Brownville, Nebraska, adjacent to his family’s farm. The little brick schoolhouse is still standing! After graduating from high school, Fred attended the University of Nebraska (Lincoln), eventually earning a master’s degree in agronomy. He took a job with Monsanto in Buffalo, New York, where the company was a pioneer in applying biotechnology to agricultural sciences. In Buffalo, Fred met his future wife, Dorothy. Fred and Dorothy moved to New York City for several years in the early 1960s, before settling down in Norwalk. In Norwalk, Fred and Dorothy had three children. The family later moved to Kent. In 1980, Fred and Dorothy divorced, and Fred bought a large tract of land on Carter Road in Kent. He built a house there, largely by himself, which he maintained until his death at age 95. After taking early retirement, he spent the following decades working on his property, adding various buildings, woodcrafting, landscaping, and spending time with his children and grandchildren.

Keep ReadingShow less
Nancy (Case) Brenner

CANAAN — Nancy (Case) Brenner, 81, of Canaan, passed away peacefully in her sleep at Charlotte Hungerford Hospital in Torrington, following a long illness on Good Friday, April 18, 2025.

Nancy was born on April 10, 1944, to the late Ray Sargeant Case Sr. and Beatrice Southey Case. She was the second youngest of five children, predeceased by her three brothers, Ray S. Case Jr., David E. Case and Douglas C. Case, and her sister Linda (Case) Olson. She grew up in New Hartford and Winsted, where she graduated from Northwestern Regional 7 High School.

Keep ReadingShow less
Adam Rand

SHEFFIELD — Adam Rand, 59, of Sheffield, Massachusetts, passed away peacefully in his home on April 22, 2025, after a long battle with ALS.

Adam was born on April 6, 1966, to Lee and Charles Rand II of Boston, Massachusetts. Adam spent his early childhood in Nantucket, where his love of fishing and water was born before moving to Sharon. It was here where he made many lifelong friends and later graduated from Housatonic Valley Regional High School in 1984. He attended Hiram College in Ohio before settling in Connecticut.

Keep ReadingShow less