The case for and against nullification

At a political event in Connecticut, participants were confronted by a demonstrator bearing a sign admonishing us all to “Read the Constitution!” One could hardly disagree. So I asked her whether she, herself, had actually read the document. She replied, “No, I haven’t, but people should.” Right on. Another demonstrator carried a sign calling for “Tort Reform Now!” No doubt we could use some reform, but what, I asked, is a “tort”? He didn’t know, but like he said, “Whatever it is, it needs reform.” Right again.When the man or woman in the street has not read the Constitution or thought much about abstruse subjects such as “torts,” the “general welfare,” rights and obligations of “persons,” the right “peaceably to assemble,” the nature of protected “free speech,” the requirement of “due process of law” or the meaning of “cruel and unusual punishment,” that’s one thing, and possibly forgivable. However, what are we to say when prominent, presumably educated politicians, financiers, special self-interest groups, self-styled patriots and even a couple of Supreme Court justices meet together to define our national “values,” while decrying promotion of the “general welfare,” the ills of “intrusive government,” “Obamacare” and labor unions all in the name of “freedom” under the Constitution?What are we to say when such prominent, privileged personalities, under the banner of American “exceptionalism,” deny the legal relevance and application of international treaties (against torture, for example) in these United (or Disunited) States?What are we to say when such “leaders” attempt to use the concept of “states’ rights” to nullify the application of federal laws, relying on Amendment Article X: “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” How are we to interpret this?Not since the Civil War have we seen in this country such revivalism of the concept of “nullification,” the right of individual states to nullify federal law. And, according to some, if nullification doesn’t work, individual states have the “right of secession” from the Union. Didn’t we conclude a long war over this very issue nearly 150 years ago? Has there been some secessionist amendment to the Constitution since then?So, what’s the meaning of Article X, and what’s the legality of “nullification”? Where should we look for an answer? As that placard-carrying demonstrator put it, “Read the Constitution!” So let’s read Amendment Article VI, section 2, as follows:“This Constitution, and the laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof, and all treaties made or which shall be made, under the authority of the United States, shall be the supreme law of the land, and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, anything in the Constitution or laws of any State to the contrary notwithstanding.”That seems clear enough. Sharon resident Anthony Piel is a former director and general legal counsel of the World Health Organization.

Latest News

Jacob assumes leadership role at William Pitt Sotheby’s Litchfield Hills offices

Eddie Jacob was recently promoted to Assistant Brokerage Manager for four Litchfield Hills offices of William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty.

Photo provided

William Pitt Sotheby’s International Realty has appointed Eddie Jacob as Assistant Brokerage Manager for its four Litchfield Hills offices, the company announced on Nov. 19.

In his new role, Jacob will support agents and help oversee operations in the firm’s Kent, Litchfield, Salisbury and Washington Depot brokerages.

Keep ReadingShow less
Winter sports season approaches at HVRHS

Mohawk Mountain was making snow the first week of December. The slopes host practices and meets for the HVRHS ski team.

By Riley Klein

FALLS VILLAGE — After concluding a successful autumn of athletics, Housatonic Valley Regional High School is set to field teams in five sports this winter.

Basketball

Keep ReadingShow less
Bears headline DEEP forum in Sharon; attendees call for coexistence, not hunting

A mother bear and her cubs move through a backyard in northwest Connecticut, where residents told DEEP that bear litters are now appearing more frequently.

By James H. Clark

SHARON — About 40 people filled the Sharon Audubon Center on Wednesday, Dec. 3, to discuss black bears — and most attendees made clear that they welcome the animals’ presence. Even as they traded practical advice on how to keep bears out of garages, porches and trash cans, residents repeatedly emphasized that they want the bears to stay and that the real problem lies with people, not wildlife.

The Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP) convened the meeting as the first in a series of regional Bear Management Listening Sessions, held at a time when Connecticut is increasingly divided over whether the state should authorize a limited bear hunt. Anticipating the potential for heated exchanges, DEEP opened the evening with strict ground rules designed to prevent confrontations: speakers were limited to three minutes, directed to address only the panel of DEEP officials, and warned that interruptions or personal attacks would not be tolerated.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kent unveils two new 'smart bins' to boost composting efforts

Rick Osborne, manager of the Kent Transfer Station, deposits the first bag of food scraps into a new organics “smart bin.” HRRA Executive Director Jennifer Heaton-Jones stands at right, with Transfer Station staff member Rob Hayes at left.

By Ruth Epstein

KENT — Residents now have access to around-the-clock food-scrap composting thanks to two newly installed organics “smart bins,” unveiled during a ribbon-cutting ceremony Monday morning, Dec. 1.

Rick Osborne, manager of the Kent Transfer Station, placed the first bag of food scraps into the smart bin located at 3 Railroad St. A second bin has been installed outside the Transfer Station gate, allowing 24/7 public access even when the facility is closed.

Keep ReadingShow less