Consolidation would weaken agencies

Gov. Dannel P. Malloy has proposed a merger of five independent government “watchdog” agencies into a single super-sized agency to be called the Office of Government Accountability. Every governor since William A. O’Neill has suggested similar, superficially appealing legislation. But when those bills were examined in public, they were defeated because they would create a more expensive bureaucracy, result in less rather than more transparency and accountability and effectively gut some of the best and most well-regarded government agencies.The five agencies to be merged are the Freedom of Information Commission, the Office of State Ethics, the Elections Enforcement Commission, the Judicial Review Council and the State Contracting Standards Board. They have no common areas of responsibility; each keeps an eye on a distinct element of government activity.The merger of these agencies will not eliminate any front-line or supervisory staff positions because each operating division within the new agency will still require a high degree of specific technical expertise and leadership. On the other hand, the new government accountability agency would create an unnecessary, yet expensive, additional top level of bureaucracy to lord over each of the former agencies. This includes an executive director as department head and undoubtedly one or more deputies and administrative support staff members. All this will easily cost hundreds of thousands of dollars extra for salaries, space and office furniture.In addition, the merger will necessitate an expensive, integrated computer system. It will have to be programmed with internal “firewalls” to guarantee the confidentiality of the highly sensitive information kept by the accountability agency’s separate divisions, while ensuring that their public records are readily available under the state’s Freedom of Information Act. This could add perhaps a million or more dollars to the proposed agency’s cost.Substantively, the Freedom of Information Commission is the only body that enforces the state’s open government laws. The laws governing all the other agencies to be included in the accountability agency mandate a significant degree of secrecy and confidentiality. So, if a citizen brings a freedom of information case against the other divisions of the new agency, the freedom of information division must adjudicate the claim.Similarly, the ethics division of the accountability office would be responsible for detecting and investigating ethical lapses by the officials and employees of the other divisions of that agency. It will look highly suspicious to state residents when one division of the consolidated agency adjudicates the actions of the other divisions. Their credibility would be lost.Finally, and perhaps most crucially, the proposed bill would make the executive director of the accountability agency a political appointee — that is, one who serves solely at the pleasure of the governor and who can be fired summarily without cause, simply because the governor does not like a decision of the agency. Currently, with the exception of the contracting standards board, the executive directors of the other agencies are appointed by their boards based on established professional qualifications. Their performance is evaluated by their boards and they cannot be fired for political or other improper reasons. They can be fired only for good cause.Without such protections, anyone who becomes executive director of the accountability agency would be at risk of losing the job if any agency decision embarrasses the governor, or if it blows the whistle on any government employee who decides a matter based on political or other inappropriate considerations. I suspect that few people are in a position to accept such a risk.Sometimes bigger is better and cost-effective. Sometimes it isn’t. This is one instance where bigger is neither better nor cost-effective.Although each administration must set its own course once it assumes power, inevitably adjustments to that course must be made as mistakes are made and lessons are learned.Gov. Malloy has pledged to set a course for greater transparency and accountability in his administration. Unless that pledge is a hollow one — and I sincerely believe that it is not — a thoughtful and objective evaluation of these arguments should convince him and the General Assembly that the proposed merger of the principal government watchdog agencies would be costly and a public policy disaster of the first magnitude. Mitchell Pearlman was executive director and general counsel of the Connecticut Freedom of Information Commission for more than 30 years, teaches law and journalism at the University of Connecticut and is the author of “Piercing the Veil of Secrecy: Lessons in the Fight for Freedom of Information.”

Latest News

Winter sports season approaches at HVRHS

Mohawk Mountain was making snow the first week of December. The slopes host practices and meets for the HVRHS ski team.

By Riley Klein

FALLS VILLAGE — After concluding a successful autumn of athletics, Housatonic Valley Regional High School is set to field teams in five sports this winter.

Basketball

Keep ReadingShow less
Bears headline DEEP forum in Sharon; attendees call for coexistence, not hunting

A mother bear and her cubs move through a backyard in northwest Connecticut, where residents told DEEP that bear litters are now appearing more frequently.

By James H. Clark

SHARON — About 40 people filled the Sharon Audubon Center on Wednesday, Dec. 3, to discuss black bears — and most attendees made clear that they welcome the animals’ presence. Even as they traded practical advice on how to keep bears out of garages, porches and trash cans, residents repeatedly emphasized that they want the bears to stay and that the real problem lies with people, not wildlife.

The Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP) convened the meeting as the first in a series of regional Bear Management Listening Sessions, held at a time when Connecticut is increasingly divided over whether the state should authorize a limited bear hunt. Anticipating the potential for heated exchanges, DEEP opened the evening with strict ground rules designed to prevent confrontations: speakers were limited to three minutes, directed to address only the panel of DEEP officials, and warned that interruptions or personal attacks would not be tolerated.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kent unveils two new 'smart bins' to boost composting efforts

Rick Osborne, manager of the Kent Transfer Station, deposits the first bag of food scraps into a new organics “smart bin.” HRRA Executive Director Jennifer Heaton-Jones stands at right, with Transfer Station staff member Rob Hayes at left.

By Ruth Epstein

KENT — Residents now have access to around-the-clock food-scrap composting thanks to two newly installed organics “smart bins,” unveiled during a ribbon-cutting ceremony Monday morning, Dec. 1.

Rick Osborne, manager of the Kent Transfer Station, placed the first bag of food scraps into the smart bin located at 3 Railroad St. A second bin has been installed outside the Transfer Station gate, allowing 24/7 public access even when the facility is closed.

Keep ReadingShow less
Cornwall selectmen prioritize housing, healthcare in new two-year goals

Cornwall First Selectman Gordon Ridgway

File photo

CORNWALL — Housing and healthcare topped the list of 15 goals the Board of Selectmen set for the next two years, reflecting the board’s view that both areas warrant continued attention.

First Selectman Gordon Ridgway and Selectmen Rocco Botto and John Brown outlined their priorities during the board’s regular meeting on Tuesday, Dec. 2. On housing, the board discussed supporting organizations working to create affordable options in town, and Botto said the town should also pursue additional land acquisitions for future housing.

Keep ReadingShow less