Despite outcry, BOE replaces basketball coach

PINE PLAINS — Despite the hundreds of parents, students and district taxpayers who have criticized the move, the Pine Plains Central School District’s Board of Education (BOE) upheld its decision not to reappoint Jedd Sims as coach of the boys varsity basketball program at its Nov. 3 meeting.
 
The crux of the matter

The meeting, held in the Cold Spring Early Learning Center’s gymnasium, was attended by dozens of parents, students and district residents, the overwhelming majority of whom were upset and even outraged that the board had voted at its Oct. 20 meeting not to reappoint Sims. Sims is also a fifth-grade elementary school teacher in the district.

The reasons for not reappointing Sims were not confirmed by the board, school administration or Sims himself, but judging by comments at the beginning of the Nov. 3 meeting, the public impression is that Sims is being punished for his tendency to play select players on his team while benching others.

Community support

The majority of parents and students who spoke during public comment said Sims was a hard-working coach who spent countless hours outside of the season and outside of his required responsibilities as coach with athletes.

Several people pointed out the multiple summer camps and summer teams he has volunteered to coach over the years, and pointed to his team’s winning the league sportsmanship award last year as an indication of the values that the coach has instilled in his players.

Several Pine Plains coaches spoke on Sims’ behalf, including Jim Jackson and Tom Povall.

Jackson, who is most well known for coaching the Pine Plains varsity football program but also led the junior varsity boys basketball last year, said that Sims has been like a mentor to him, despite being half his age.

“He knows basketball,� he said. “I support him 100 percent.�

A matter of timing

Jackson, and then Povall, also criticized the board’s decision to remove Sims from the position only a few weeks before the season began. If the issues with Sims were not new, Jackson said, then they should have been dealt with at the time.

“The season starts in a couple days,� Povall said. “It’s going to be a new coach and a whole different program. We have a championship-level team and we owe it to these kids.�

“I don’t think that the timing was right and I don’t think the reasons were valid,� he said.

Support for the move

The only person who spoke out in favor of the board’s decision was John Gomm, who said that his son had been on the varsity team under Sims. He said that Sims had previously told other players and parents that Gomm’s son would never make the varsity team. When he did, he was barely played despite being a good athlete in Gomm’s eyes.

“This is not the type of coaching that Pine Plains needs,� he said. “I agree with your decision and I hope you stay with it.�

The petition

A large number of students and basketball players attended and, led by Captain Marquis VanDewater, all turned in letters of protest to the board as well as a petition to reinstate Sims. The petition had the signatures of approximately 150 students, parents and coaches.

“I’ve been coached by Coach Sims for the past three years,� VanDewater said. “The team has done nothing but improve, and I don’t think the reasons [to not reappoint Sims] are good at all.�

Players, even water boy, support coach “Coach Sims is fair,� said Joey Kotzur, another member of the team. “In order to be a successful team, you play the better players.�

Kotzur acknowledged that he has not been one of the better athletes on the team, and while he has yet to see much playing time, he is motivated to work harder to earn the right to play.

“It can be frustrating but I know this is life,� he said.

Christa Proper, whose son, Dylan Proper, was captain last year, said that Sims has done a remarkable job with the team.

“We expected a lot from our son and from the team,� she said, adding that she had seen her son grow tremendously under Sims’ leadership. She said that the dynamics that led to some players being played more often than others were to be expected, even though there were many parents who had criticized Sims repeatedly at games for not playing their children.

Proper’s younger son, elementary school student Evan, has been the water boy for the team for the past few years. Even he stood up at the meeting and said that Sims had taught him good values and should deserve to stay, even as he acknowledged that, being young, he did not understand the reasons behind the coach not being reappointed.

“I love Coach Sims and I will not continue to be water boy if he loses his job,� he said.

Executive session leads to a decision

BOE Trustee Todd Bowen said that in light of public comments, he wanted to go into executive session before voting on the agenda, which had listed appointing Brendan LoBrutto, who coached modified last year, as the new varsity basketball coach.

The board agreed and continued with its regular meeting, taking care of all its regular business before adjourning to executive session. It deliberated for nearly an hour before returning and voting unanimously to appoint LoBrutto, with Bowen abstaining.

The board would not discuss the particulars of its decision. President Bruce Kimball, in an opening statement when the meeting began, explained that district policy was to respect the confidentiality rights of individual employees of the district.

When the board returned from executive session and voted, the audience became angry, with many yelling at the board members, saying they had made the wrong decision. When asked, Kimball said that the board had taken the petition, letters and public opinion into consideration when making its decision. A crowd formed around the exit door and the criticism continued as the board members left the building, with several threatening to vote down next year’s budget as repercussion.

Boys basketball practice began this past Monday.

Latest News

Love is in the atmosphere

Author Anne Lamott

Sam Lamott

On Tuesday, April 9, The Bardavon 1869 Opera House in Poughkeepsie was the setting for a talk between Elizabeth Lesser and Anne Lamott, with the focus on Lamott’s newest book, “Somehow: Thoughts on Love.”

A best-selling novelist, Lamott shared her thoughts about the book, about life’s learning experiences, as well as laughs with the audience. Lesser, an author and co-founder of the Omega Institute in Rhinebeck, interviewed Lamott in a conversation-like setting that allowed watchers to feel as if they were chatting with her over a coffee table.

Keep ReadingShow less
Hotchkiss students team with Sharon Land Trust on conifer grove restoration

Oscar Lock, a Hotchkiss senior, got pointers and encouragement from Tim Hunter, stewardship director of The Sharon Land Trust, while sawing buckthorn.

John Coston

It was a ramble through bramble on Wednesday, April 17 as a handful of Hotchkiss students armed with loppers attacked a thicket of buckthorn and bittersweet at the Sharon Land Trust’s Hamlin Preserve.

The students learned about the destructive impact of invasives as they trudged — often bent over — across wet ground on the semblance of a trail, led by Tom Zetterstrom, a North Canaan tree preservationist and member of the Sharon Land Trust.

Keep ReadingShow less