Health-care reform: a continuing tragedy

On Tuesday, Jan. 19, Massachusetts voters went to the polls to hand Republican candidate Scott Brown a triumphant victory over Democrat Martha Coakley for the Senate seat long held by Sen. Ted Kennedy.  

The final score was 52 percent to 47 percent of the votes cast, on a turnout of 65 percent of all registered voters.  Massachusetts Democrats normally outnumber Republicans by more than 2 to 1. On that snowy winter day, Republican and unaffiliated voters turned out in unprecedented numbers; Democrats stayed at home.

Admittedly, Coakley waged a lackluster campaign, while Brown waged a disciplined, energetic and populist one.  The Democrats utterly failed to communicate to their base what was really at stake in this election:  a filibuster-proof Senate. As a result, the health-care reform movement in Washington, D.C., now falls in disarray, at least until the November 2010 elections.

This delay continues a long-standing American tragedy, the inability to adopt the clearly superior reforms of the democracies of Europe, so praised by Republican President Dwight D. Eisenhower. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), the United States stands in no more than 37th place in terms of health outcomes and performance in relation to cost, well behind virtually every country in Europe. One independent research organization after another confirms the WHO result.

u      u      u

Some legislators urge that Congress still go for the full health-care reform package, but do so under a budgetary “reconciliationâ€� procedure that requires only a 51 percent, not a 61 percent, vote majority, as Dr. Howard Dean has long advocated. A variant on this approach could be to go ahead under standard rules and force the Republicans to filibuster in fact, spending hours reading text from the encyclopedia, and letting Americans witness what the Republicans really do and don’t stand for.  

Others would scale back the health bill to some “core essentials� — provided consensus can be reached on what those essentials are. Or, by “salami slicing� the package, we could present to Congress certain specific reforms individually, notably laws forbidding denial of coverage for “pre-existing conditions� or dropping insurance coverage when an insured person becomes seriously and expensively ill. As reform after reform is adopted, the insurance industry will eventually say wait a minute, and demand “mandated� (required) coverage, to bring millions more into the insurance pool, for their own large-scale profit reasons.

u      u      u

Finally, there is my own, previously rejected, optimal solution.  What is it?  Here it is:  I believe that the president has the legal and Constitutional right, without going to Congress, to simply request the Department of Health and Human Services, together with Medicare, to establish an initially modest, government-run health insurance plan — a simple health insurance policy like any other, but unlike any other, open to any U.S. citizen as a matter of free choice.

Preferably, this would be modeled on a study undertaken a few years ago by the U.S. National Academy of Sciences, in turn based on the existing WHO health insurance plan, operating in the black in more than 200 countries — including the United States.

Most of the reforms currently being debated in Washington, D.C., would be incorporated in the voluntary public health insurance plan. Based on WHO experience, cost savings would be dramatic. Legislation would not be needed initially, because nothing would be “mandatedâ€� (thrust down the throats of American industry or citizens), and no taxpayer money would be used or budgeted. Eventually, however, as hundreds, thousands and millions of Americans opted for the public, single-payer plan, the health insurance industry would be forced by free market competition to adopt the reforms voluntarily.  

u      u      u

At a subsequent stage, we would go to the Congress for approval to “mandate� health insurance for all Americans, and to appropriate taxpayer money to subsidize the premiums of those citizens who want insurance coverage but cannot afford it — until such time as they can pay for it. At that point, Republicans will not be in a position to criticize health reform or filibuster an existing public option, but they will have to explain why government should not be involved in helping to bring health insurance to all Americans.

Thus, there’s more than one way to skin a cat. I believe my way is best, of course, but we cannot always have everything our way.  I’ll compromise with whatever actually works. There’s one clear lesson from Massachusetts for the Democrats: If they want to pull the chestnuts out of the fire, they had better get to work, starting right now, to re-capture the populist middle ground, using superior communication, organization and purpose.

Sharon resident Anthony Piel is a former director and legal counsel of the World Health Organization.

Latest News

Sharon parents push back on school budget cuts

Sharon resident Veronica Betts posts flyers around Sharon to raise support for Sharon Center School.

Madi Long

SHARON – In a last-ditch effort to avoid a proposed $70,000 cut to the Sharon Center School’s 2026-27 budget, local parents are mobilizing – packing meetings, posting flyers and warning that reductions could undermine the school’s future. Sharon resident Veronica Betts plastered the town with posters earlier this week, urging residents to attend town meetings to voice support for the Board of Education, which determines the SCS budget.

“We shouldn’t be talking about defunding the school,” said Betts, who has a young daughter en- rolled in Sharon Daycare, part of SCS. “These are kids, this is so short-sighted and ridiculous.” The cuts, if adopted, could affect the staff salary line, supplies and even the cafeteria, which would require premade lunches to be delivered from HVRHS.

Keep ReadingShow less
Remembering George and Anne Phillips’ Edgewood restaurant in Amenia

The Edgewood Restaurant, a beloved Amenia roadside restaurant run by George and Anne Phillips, pictured during its peak years in the 1950s and ’60s.

Provided

With the recent death of George Phillips at 100, locals are remembering the Edgewood Restaurant, the Amenia supper club he and his wife, Anne Phillips, owned and operated together for more than two decades.

At the Edgewood, there were Delmonico steaks George carved in the basement, lobster tails from an infrared cooker, local trout from the stream outside the door, and a folded paper cup of butter, with heaping bowls of family-style potatoes and vegetables, plus a shot glass of crème de menthe to calm the stomach when the modest check arrived after dessert.

Keep ReadingShow less
Artist Alissa DeGregorio brings her work to Roxbury and New Milford

Alissa DeGregorio, a New Milford -based artist and designer, has pieces on display at Mine Hill Distillery.

Agnes Fohn
When I’m designing a book, I’m also the bridge between artist and author, the final step that pulls everything together.
— Alissa DeGregorio

A visit to Alissa DeGregorio Art, the website of the artist and designer, reveals the multiple talents she possesses.

Tabs for design, commissions, print club, and classes still reveal only part of her work.On the design page are examples of graphic and book design, including book covers illustrated by DeGregorio, along with samples of licensed products such as coloring pages and lunch boxes, and examples of prop design she has done for film.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Agnes Martin at Dia:Beacon

Agnes Martin at Dia:Beacon

Minimalist works by Agnes Martin on display at Dia:Beacon.

D.H. Callahan

At Dia:Beacon, simplicity commands attention.

On Saturday, April 4, the venerated modern art museum — located at 3 Beekman St. in Beacon, NY — opened an exhibition of works by the middle- to late-20th-century minimalist artist Agnes Martin.

Keep ReadingShow less
Falls Village exhibit honors life and work of Priscilla Belcher

Hunt Library in Falls Village will present a commemorative show of paintings and etchings by the late Priscilla Belcher of Falls Village.

Lydia Downs

Priscilla Belcher, a Canaan resident who was known for her community involvement and willingness to speak out, will be featured in a posthumous exhibition at the ArtWall at the Hunt Library from April 25 through May 15.

An opening reception will be held from 5 to 7 p.m. on April 25. The show will commemorate her life and work and will include watercolors and etchings. Belcher died in November 2025 at the age of 95.

Keep ReadingShow less
Crescendo’s 'Stepping Into Song' blends Jewish, Argentine traditions

The sounds of Argentine tango and Jewish folk traditions will collide in a rare cross-cultural performance April 25 and 26, when Berkshire’s Crescendo presents the choral program “Stepping Into Song.”

Christine Gevert, Crescendo’s founding artistic director, described the concert as “a world-class, diverse cultural experience” pairing “A Jewish Cantata” with Martin Palmeri’s “Misa a Buenos Aires.”

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.