Judge hears argument for ‘motion to dismiss’ Paley Farm case

SHARON — Attorneys representing the Connecticut Department of Agriculture and the current owners of Paley Farm argued that an ongoing injunction case should be dismissed at a preliminary hearing on Monday, Dec. 9. Judge Walter Menjivar has yet to rule.

The case surrounds DOAG’s decision to approve the landowners’ application to construct a residence on the protected farmland.

Sharon Land Trust and Carol Flaton brought the case to Torrington Superior Court in July when they filed an injunction request to block the construction, arguing that DOAG misapplied the language of the original easement in its approval decision.

The property at the center of the suit, a 187 acre parcel located at 135 Millerton Road, was put under a farmland protection easement in 1984 when retired farmer Morris Paley sold his development rights to the state through DOAG’s Farmland Preservation Program.

The easement bars the development of the land for purposes other than agriculture, but it allows for the construction of residences for “persons directly incidental to farm operation.”

In 2022, current owners David and Liza Bainbridge of Rye, New York, purchased the property and applied to DOAG for building approval. Their proposal included a two-story home, pool and outdoor spa, all of which were later approved in a letter from DOAG Commissioner Bryan Hurlburt.

Flaton and SLT contend that the approval decision ran afoul of the intent of the easement and constituted a misappropriation of public funds; the state paid today’s equivalent of about $900,000 for Paley’s development rights.

These arguments were not the focus of Monday’s hearing, however, which centered instead on the defendants’ motion to dismiss the case. The pivotal question was whether Flaton and SLT had legal standing to bring the suit in the first place.

Representing DOAG, attorney Gail Shane argued that the plaintiffs’ claims are not legally relevant under the doctrine of sovereign immunity, which holds that the state cannot be sued, in all but a few select cases, for conducting its given duties.

A memorandum prepared by the defense emphasized that the 1984 deed granted the state the “right to enforce the restrictions” on development, turning over sole responsibility for the deed’s future interpretation to DOAG staff.

Shane stated at the hearing that, without proof that Commissioner Hurlburt engaged in wrongful conduct to reach his approval decision, the plaintiff’s argument is “factually and legally” incorrect.

Adding to Shane’s argument, attorney Ken Slater emphasized that his clients, the Bainbridges, complied with DOAG’s construction application process and were duly approved by the department. He argued that the Bainbridges met the “incidental to farm operation” stipulation by laying out their plans to oversee continued farming on the land.

“We very much disagree that this isn’t going to be [dedicated] to agricultural use,” said Slater.

Shane and Slater also contended the plaintiffs’ standing, arguing that SLT and Flaton had not demonstrated that they were specifically and injuriously impacted by the construction.

While the plaintiffs’ initial complaint referenced SLT’s position abutting the property and the alteration of ridgeline views for hikers on SLT land, Shane asserted that the personal feelings of speculative hikers are irrelevant to SLT’s standing.

Slater meanwhile argued that Flaton’s position as a taxpayer and resident is insufficient to show standing, as any neighbor might disagree with how the house is built.

“It’s between the owner and the party that has the easement or the covenant over my clients’ land,” said Slater.

In his rebuttal, attorney Wilson Carroll, on behalf of the plaintiffs, contended that not only did Hurlburt’s decision constitute wrongful conduct, thus meeting an exception to the sovereign immunity doctrine, it also ran afoul of the public trust doctrine by misusing taxpayer dollars.

“This is a matter of significant public concern in Sharon and in the rest of the state right now,” said Carroll.

Carroll asserted that the “groundswell of public opposition” to DOAG’s decision legitimizes the plaintiffs’ standing as public representatives, and decried the lack of public oversight in DOAG’s easement interpretation process. To date, 485 people have signed a petition calling for stricter easement enforcement.

“The public has not ratified this [decision] in any way,” Carroll said.

Judge Menjivar has yet to rule on the case.

In a comment following the hearing, Slater said his client was “very happy that the hearing on the motion to dismiss was held” and that he is personally “very hopeful” the yuling will be in their favor.

SLT Board President Jennifer Dillon was less pleased with the hearing.

“We’re still just talking about these technicalities and not the merits of our argument,” she said. “I would love to get to a point where we can talk about the merits of the case.”

Flaton said that should the case be dismissed on standing technicalities, they plan to try again.

“We will simply refile. It will be much more straightforward,” said Flaton.

Latest News

To mow or not to mow?

To mow or not to mow?

A partially mowed meadow in early spring provides habitat for wildlife while helping to keep invasive plants in check.

Dee Salomon

Love it or hate it, there is no denying the several blankets of snow this winter were beautiful, especially as they visually muffled some of the damage they caused in the first place.There appears to be tree damage — some minor and some major — in many places, and now that we can move around, the pre-spring cleanup begins. Here, a heavy snow buildup on our sun porch roof crashed onto the shrubs below, snapping off branches and cleaving a boxwood in half, flattening it.

The other area that has been flattened by the snow is the meadow, now heading into its fourth year of post-lawn alterations. A short recap on its genesis: I simply stopped mowing a half-acre of lawn, planted some flowering plants, spread little bluestem seeds and, far less simply, obsessively pluck out invasive plants such as sheep sorrel and stilt grass. And while it’s not exactly enchanting, it is flourishing, so much so that I cannot bring myself to mow.

Keep ReadingShow less

Where the mat meets the market

Where the mat meets the market

Kathy Reisfeld

Elena Spellman

In a barn on Maple Avenue in Great Barrington, Kathy Reisfeld merges two unlikely worlds: wealth management and yoga, teaching clients and students alike how stability — financial and emotional — comes from practice.

Her life sits at an intersection many assume can’t exist: high finance and yoga. One world is often reduced to greed, the other to “woo-woo” stretching. Yet in conversation, she makes both feel grounded, less like opposites and more like two languages describing the same human need for stability.

Keep ReadingShow less
Capitol hosts first-ever staging of Civil War love story

Playwright Cinzi Lavin, left, poses with Kathleen Kelly, director of ‘A Goodnight Kiss.’

Jack Sheedy

Litchfield County playwright Cinzi Lavin’s “A Goodnight Kiss,” based on letters exchanged between a Civil War soldier and the woman who became his wife, premiered in 2025 to sold-out audiences in Goshen, where the couple once lived. Now the original cast, directed by Goshen resident Kathleen Kelly, will present the play beneath the gold dome of Connecticut’s Capitol in Hartford as part of the state’s America250 commemoration — marking what organizers believe may be the first such performance at the Capitol.

“I don’t believe any live performances of an actual play (at the Capitol) have happened,” said Elizabeth Conroy, administrative assistant at the Office of Legislative Management, who coordinates Capitol events.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Hunt Library launches VideoWall for filmmakers

Yonah Sadeh, Falls Village filmmaker and curator of David M. Hunt Library’s new VideoWall.

Robin Roraback

The David M. Hunt Library in Falls Village, known for promoting local artists with its ArtWall, is debuting a new feature showcasing filmmakers. The VideoWall will premiere Saturday, March 28, at 6 p.m. with a screening of two short films by Brooklyn-based documentary filmmaker and animator Imogen Pranger.

The VideoWall is the idea of Falls Village filmmaker Yonah Sadeh, who also serves as curator. “I would love the VideoWall to become a place that showcases the work of local filmmakers, and I hope that other creatives in the area will submit their work to be shown,” he said.

Keep ReadingShow less

A bowl full of stars

A bowl full of stars

A bowl full of stones.

Cheryl Heller

There’s a bowl in my studio where pieces of the planet reside. I bring them home from travels, picking them up not for their beauty or distinction but for their provenance. I choose the ones that speak to me — the ones next to pyramids, along hiking trails, on city sidewalks or volcanic slopes.

I like how stones feel in my hand: weighty, grounding. I don’t mind them making my pockets and suitcase heavier. The bowl is about the size of an average carry-on. It has been years since it was light enough for me to lift.

Keep ReadingShow less
One-woman show brings Mumbet’s fight for freedom to Scoville Library
One-woman show brings Mumbet’s fight for freedom to Scoville Library
One-woman show brings Mumbet’s fight for freedom to Scoville Library

On March 29, writer, producer and director Tammy Denease will embody the life and story of Elizabeth Freeman, widely known as Mumbet, in two performances at the Scoville Library in Salisbury. Presented by Scoville Library and the Salisbury Association Historical Society, the performance is part of Salisbury READS, a community-wide engagement with literature and civic dialogue.

Mumbet was the first enslaved woman in Massachusetts to sue successfully for her freedom in 1781. Her victory helped lay the legal groundwork for the abolition of slavery in the state just two years later. In bringing Mumbet’s story to life, Denease does more than reenact history.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.