Pine Plains man charged with murder

PINE PLAINS — The town is reeling from the news that a resident has been arrested for the murder and attempted murder of a Catskill couple last Wednesday, June 17.

The suspect, Robert N. Wilkinson, 23, whose home is on Route 199 in Pine Plains, has been charged with murder in the second degree, criminal use of a firearm in the first degree, assault in the first degree and reckless endangerment in the first degree.

He was arraigned in the Town of Catskill Court before Town Justice Robert Carl, and remanded without bail to Greene County Jail.

Pine Plains Town Supervisor Gregg Pulver, who said he doesn’t know Wilkinson personally, does know the family.

“They’re really a lovely family in town,� he said. “Obviously this was a tragedy on a lot of levels. Somebody lost their life and another man stands accused of murder. It’s a tough thing, and until we know the facts it’s tough to understand.�

The facts are slowly being pieced together. According to New York State Police Troop F in the Catskills, Wilkinson drove to 59 Pennsylvania Ave., in Palenville, early on Wednesday morning.

According to a press release from the police, “Greene County 911 was contacted by Taryn Haid who reported that Wilkinson confronted her husband Lucian Haid and herself in the driveway of their residence on Pennsylvania Avenue with a rifle after having a dispute earlier in the night.�

The couple was hit with multiple rounds fired by Wilkinson, according to the report. The alleged gunman then fled the scene. That’s when Taryn Haid dialed 911. Lucian Haid was pronounced dead at the scene; Taryn Haid was transported to a local hospital, where she was treated for her injuries.

When officers arrived she was able to give a description of the shooter and a 2008 Nissan he was driving. The chase left Dutchess County and moved across the Hudson River into Ulster County. Deputy Frank Gillespie of the Ulster County Sheriff’s Office witnessed that vehicle traveling southbound on State Route 32 in the town of Ulster and tried to pull it over. Wilkinson did not obey the order and a pursuit ensued southbound on State Route 9W through the city of Kingston and the town of Esopus.

According to the press release, “Wilkinson lost control of his vehicle and struck a rock wall in the vicinity of Black Creek Road in the town of Esopus.

“Wilkinson was ultimately taken into custody and admitted his role in the shooting after being interviewed.�

Although no motive for the crime has been discovered, the state police did confirm that Wilkinson lived in the Catskill area previously, nearby the two victims. Additionally, the Haids have previously lived in Dutchess County; Taryn Haid herself is actually from Pine Plains (her maiden name is Demchuck, according to Pulver).

“Our sympathies go out to everybody involved,� Pulver said. “It’s all a shame. I know both families and I can’t even imagine what they’re all going through.�

While authorities have said that no motive has been determined as of yet, there have been reports published stating drugs were found at the Haid’s home. Investigators reportedly confiscated marijuana plants and grow lights at the residence.

The next step is for the district attorney’s office to present the case to the grand jury; that was expected to happen sometime this week, after this paper went to press.

The New York State Police were assisted by the Ulster County Sheriff’s Office, the City of Kingston Police, the Ulster Police, The Town of Saugerties Police, the Town of Lloyd Police, the Greene County Sheriff’s Office, the Greene County District Attorney’s Office and the Village of Catskill Police.

Anyone with information regarding this case is asked to please contact the  Bureau of Criminal Investigation at Catskill at 518-622-8600.

Latest News

The Hydrilla Menace: Twin Lakes group buoyed by DEEP’s assault on invasive hydrilla in 2025

A detail of a whorl of hydrilla pulled from the shallow waters at O’Hara’s Landing Marina in fall of 2024.

Photo by Debra A. Aleksinas

SALISBURY — The Twin Lakes Association is taking an earlier and more aggressive approach to fighting the spread of invasive hydrilla in East Twin Lake by dosing the whole northeast bay, from May through October, with low-level herbicide treatments instead of spot treatments.

The goal, said Russ Conklin, the TLA’s vice president of lake management, is to sustain herbicide concentration over the 2025 growing season.

Keep ReadingShow less
Frederick Wright Hosterman

KENT — Frederick Wright Hosterman passed away peacefully in his home in Kent on April 16, 2025. Born in 1929 in Auburn, Nebraska, he was the son of farmers. He attended a one-room schoolhouse just outside of Brownville, Nebraska, adjacent to his family’s farm. The little brick schoolhouse is still standing! After graduating from high school, Fred attended the University of Nebraska (Lincoln), eventually earning a master’s degree in agronomy. He took a job with Monsanto in Buffalo, New York, where the company was a pioneer in applying biotechnology to agricultural sciences. In Buffalo, Fred met his future wife, Dorothy. Fred and Dorothy moved to New York City for several years in the early 1960s, before settling down in Norwalk. In Norwalk, Fred and Dorothy had three children. The family later moved to Kent. In 1980, Fred and Dorothy divorced, and Fred bought a large tract of land on Carter Road in Kent. He built a house there, largely by himself, which he maintained until his death at age 95. After taking early retirement, he spent the following decades working on his property, adding various buildings, woodcrafting, landscaping, and spending time with his children and grandchildren.

Keep ReadingShow less
Nancy (Case) Brenner

CANAAN — Nancy (Case) Brenner, 81, of Canaan, passed away peacefully in her sleep at Charlotte Hungerford Hospital in Torrington, following a long illness on Good Friday, April 18, 2025.

Nancy was born on April 10, 1944, to the late Ray Sargeant Case Sr. and Beatrice Southey Case. She was the second youngest of five children, predeceased by her three brothers, Ray S. Case Jr., David E. Case and Douglas C. Case, and her sister Linda (Case) Olson. She grew up in New Hartford and Winsted, where she graduated from Northwestern Regional 7 High School.

Keep ReadingShow less