The saga of the pink house continues

CORNWALL — The iconic “pink house” is going to need a new nickname.

New owners Libby Mitchell and Jim Herity have decided to paint the West Cornwall village landmark a pale, honey-toned yellow. A new color was selected not so much because the current pale pink was controversial, but because it was not historically accurate. Pastels were often used, but in the more muted Victorian shades, such as rose.

The couple is planning to move their West Cornwall Publishing Company into the 12-room duplex, and host public events there. Their plan is to make it a vital part of the village center.

They also planned to go to Hartford this week for a hearing on their request for the 1870 house to be added to the National Register of Historic Places.

They are working with a  crew to complete exterior work by a Nov. 1 deadline for a facade grant that will reimburse much of the cost.

That work includes the removal of shutters to reveal intricately milled window moldings that will get a fresh coat of white paint, along with elaborate trim work.

The front porch was rotted and is being replaced. It spans the facade, and the owners envision visitors sitting there. A tangle of shrubbery was removed from the front lawn. New landscaping will be installed, along with a wide pathway of paver bricks.

The couple are bucking opposition and dealing with ongoing calls to the state police by former owner Maura Smithies, who maintains life use of the property through an agreement with Landmark Trust and as the result of a case heard in Litchfield Superior Court. 

But that life estate includes maintaining the property, carrying insurance and paying taxes, which Smithies has not done. She turned down Mitchell and Herity’s offer to give up her use of the main home in exchange for the right to continue to live in a barn apartment there at no cost.

Mitchell said that even though they need Smithies’ permission to be on the property, they decided they needed to forge ahead in order to save the house. It has been deteriorating for more than six years in the wake of a January 2008 fire. Smithies’ water-damaged possessions remain inside. With no repair or cleanup taking place, the building official eventually condemned the structure.

Mitchell last week pointed out a large bundle of power lines that they paid to have replaced. Insulation was worn away and wires were exposed where they ran along the exterior of the house to the meter and breaker box. A small propane tank is also situated there to ensure the barn apartment is serviced with water from the well for the main house.

Mitchell said it was important to them to make sure the water supply to the apartment was not disrupted, and that they uphold their end of the proposed life estate agreement. They will pay for modifications as needed.

As part of the Dec. 30, 2013, sale, they say they paid back taxes of about $60,000 and related legal fees incurred by Smithies of more than $20,000. They continue to pay all expenses there, and at some point intend to petition the court to modify the life estate to remove Smithies’ hold over the main house.

Latest News

Local talent takes the stage in Sharon Playhouse’s production of Agatha Christie’s ‘The Mousetrap’

Top row, left to right, Caroline Kinsolving, Christopher McLinden, Dana Domenick, Reid Sinclair and Director Hunter Foster. Bottom row, left to right, Will Nash Broyles, Dick Terhune, Sandy York and Ricky Oliver in Agatha Christie’s “The Mousetrap.”

Aly Morrissey

Opening on Sept. 26, Agatha Christie’s legendary whodunit “The Mousetrap” brings suspense and intrigue to the Sharon Playhouse stage, as the theater wraps up its 2025 Mainstage Season with a bold new take on the world’s longest-running play.

Running from Sept. 26 to Oct. 5, “The Mousetrap” marks another milestone for the award-winning regional theater, bringing together an ensemble of exceptional local talent under the direction of Broadway’s Hunter Foster, who also directed last season’s production of “Rock of Ages." With a career that spans stage and screen, Foster brings a fresh and suspense-filled staging to Christie’s classic.

Keep ReadingShow less
Plein Air Litchfield returns for a week of art in the open air

Mary Beth Lawlor, publisher/editor-in-chief of Litchfield Magazine, and supporter of Plein Air Litchfield, left,and Michele Murelli, Director of Plein Air Litchfield and Art Tripping, right.

Jennifer Almquist

For six days this autumn, Litchfield will welcome 33 acclaimed painters for the second year of Plein Air Litchfield (PAL), an arts festival produced by Art Tripping, a Litchfield nonprofit.

The public is invited to watch the artists at work while enjoying the beauty of early fall. The new Belden House & Mews hotel at 31 North St. in Litchfield will host PAL this year.

Keep ReadingShow less