Cooling the Middle East rhetoric

In recent weeks the David Horowitz Freedom Center has been placing half- and full-page advertisements in the mainstream U.S. press including the New York Times under such titles as “The Palestinians’ Case Against Israel is Based on a Genocidal Lie.” The ads continue: “The Palestinian Authority on the West Bank and the Hamas Government of Gaza both claim that Israel is ‘Occupied Palestine.’ This is a lie.”Technically, the Horowitz Center is correct in that there has never been an internationally recognized political entity, state or country called Palestine in the Middle East. Furthermore, the lands we refer to as Palestine have been repeatedly overrun and ruled or claimed by outsiders for most of recorded history. There never was a Palestine state in the political sense.Nevertheless, “statehood” is not what the “occupation” issue is all about, in the minds of members of the United Nations, the United States government or Israelis and Palestinians concerned with human rights. The underlying issue is that Israel has occupied real estate property owned by local Palestinian families without consent and without due process of law. Such local land ownership, stretching back a couple of hundred years and more, is increasingly difficult to prove since most municipal land records evidencing this ownership have been systematically destroyed. Furthermore, in the face of calls by the United Nations and others for restraint, the expansion of new settlements has continued unabated. This is the central problem.Considering the historical territorial conquests of Palestinian lands by Neanderthals, Persians, Mongols, Greeks, Romans, Egyptians, Turks, Crusaders, French, Britons and others, it is difficult to conclude that a benevolent deity intended the land for only one preferred group or the other. Furthermore, the argument over “who got there first” is a dead end, especially since genetic studies show that, recent immigrants aside, the bloodlines of long-term resident Jews and Palestinians, who are practically close cousins, go back over 2,500 years in equal measure. Extremists on each side falsely accuse the other side of “genocide,” that is, the systematic eradication of a racial, religious or cultural group. These accusations are simply false, and intended for inflammatory purposes. It is time to cool the rhetoric down on both sides. It’s time to ask what most of the people, Israelis and Palestinians alike, actually want.Formal and informal polling by the United Nations, the World Health Organization and other independent agencies and researchers demonstrates that the vast majority of Israelis and Palestinians, well over 70 percent in each case, seek peace and security for all, preferably under a “two-state solution,” subject to mutual agreement to safeguard free trade, travel, land and water rights and the exercise of democratic self-determination without outside influence. Both sides will have to give up some of their claims relating to national security, boundaries, refugees, settlements and resources. This requires detailed negotiation. Meanwhile, let’s cool down the hyperbolic rhetoric by minority factions on both sides who have an interest in promoting endless conflict and violence. Let’s listen to the majority of Israelis and Palestinians who want reconciliation and cooperation now to avoid future catastrophe and to ensure the betterment of all.Sharon resident Anthony Piel is a former director and general legal counsel of the World Health Organization.

Latest News

From research to recognition: Student project honors pioneering Black landowner

Cornwall Consolidated School seventh graders Skylar Brown, Izabella Coppola, Halley Villa, Willow Berry, Claire Barbosa, Willa Lesch, Vivianne DiRocco and Franco Aburto presented a group research project on the life of Naomi Freeman Wednesday, April 23. In attendance were U.S. Rep. Jahana Hayes, D-Conn., John Mills, president of Alex Breanne Corporation, Cornwall First Selectman Gordon Ridgway, Cornwall Selectman Jennifer Markow and CCS social studies teacher Will Vincent.

Photo by Riley Klein

CORNWALL — “In Cornwall you have made the decision that everyone here matters and everyone’s story is important,” said U.S. Rep. Jahana Hayes, D-Waterbury, to the seventh grade class at Cornwall Consolidated School April 23.

Hayes was in attendance to celebrate history on Wednesday as the CCS students presented their group research project on the life of Naomi Cain Freeman, the first Black female landowner in Cornwall.

Keep ReadingShow less
Legal Notices - April 24, 2025

Town of Salisbury

Board of Finance

Keep ReadingShow less
Classifieds - April 24, 2025

Help Wanted

Experienced horse equestrian: to train three-year-old white Persian Mare for trail riding. 860-67-0499.

Help wanted: Small Angus Farm seeks reliable help for cattle and horses. Duties include feeding, fence repair, machine repair. Will train the right person. 860-671-0499.

Keep ReadingShow less