Political discourse amid broken windows and heads

A discourse is defined as “a serious discussion of a particular subject” or “a formal and orderly expression of thought on a subject.”   

You will note that neither definition mentions the use of guns or knives or axe handles or chemical sprays or baseball bats or riot shields or crowbars to enhance the formal and orderly expression of thoughts and ideas.

So why then did the Republican National Committee describe the Jan. 6 insurrection that vandalized the Capitol of the nation and injured more than 150 police officers as “a legitimate political discourse?”

The novel description of that terrible day came in a resolution the RNC passed to censure two of the party’s House members who are taking part in an investigation of the worst act of violence in Washington since the British set fire to the place in the War of 1812.

The two, Liz Cheney of Wyoming and Adam Kinzinger of Illinois, were censured at the committee’s winter meeting in Utah for participating in what the resolution describes as “the persecution of ordinary citizens engaged in legitimate political discourse.”

If there was any legitimate political discoursing going on as these “ordinary citizens” were smashing their way through locked doors and windows to force members of Congress to overturn the election of a president of the United States, it was rather effectively drowned out.

The censure, which was passed by a voice vote at the direction RNC chairwoman Ronna McDaniel, did not identify any of the persecuted citizens.

Later, however, McDaniel did try to sell the idea that the resolution was not meant to be about the rioters who violently stormed the building after being incited by Donald Trump  to try to overthrow a presidential election.

You will recall that Trump, after prodding the rioters, did not join the march on the Capitol as he promised, but retired to the White House to enjoy the televised coverage of his thugs defiling the seat of our democracy.  At the same time, he ignored the pleas of advisers and family members to call for a halt to the uprising.

The next day, he did discover he had been “outraged” by the “heinous attack” but he quickly returned to claiming, without a bit of evidence, that the election was stolen.

And, only a few days before the RNC’s censure vote, he announced that if he’s elected in 2024, “we will treat those people from January 6 fairly and if it requires pardons, we will give them pardons, because they are being treated so unfairly.”  I don’t believe he was referring to those still unknown citizens who were waiting outside the Capitol for the discourse to begin.

It is somewhat heartening that the condemnation of Cheney and Kinzinger was not quite unanimous.  Ronna McCaniel’s Uncle Mitt, the 2012 presidential candidate and current senator Mitt Romney, condemned the resolution.

“Shame falls on a party that would censure persons of conscience, who seek truth in the face of vitriol,” said Romney of his niece’s effort. “Honor attaches to Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger for seeking the truth when doing so comes at great personal cost.”

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell also expressed disdain for the resolution, saying “we support all members of our party, regardless of their views on some issues.”

Gov. Larry Hogan of Maryland called Feb. 4, the day the resolution passed, “a sad day for my party — and the country.”

The resolution got mixed reviews in Connecticut Republican circles. GOP State Chairman Ben Proto, one of three Connecticut members of the RNC, revealed the controversial resolution was considered in a package with others he favored but he voted against all of them because of the Jan. 6 statement.

The other state members of the RNC, Leora Levy of Greenwich and John Frey of Ridgefield, voted for the resolution. Levy is one of several Republicans running for the Senate against Richard Blumenthal this year but the party’s nomination is expected to go to former legislative leader Themis Klarides.

Bob Stefanowski, the likely Republican candidate for governor again, wasn’t at the meeting but he wanted the state’s voters to know he didn’t support the rioters either.

“I condemned the acts of violence on the day they happened and feel the same way today. The Republican National Committee statement is wrong.”

And finally, let’s not forget that the committee’s resolution wasn’t the craziest thing said about Jan. 6.

That distinction goes to Rep. Andrew Clyde of Georgia who saw the attack on the Capitol as no more than “a normal tourist visit.”  Clyde hasn’t been heard from since reporters found photos of him, looking quite agitated, as he helped colleagues barricade the doors to the House chamber to keep the visiting tourists out.

 

Simsbury resident Dick Ahles is a retired journalist. Email him at rahles1@outlook.com.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Lakeville Journal and The Journal does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Year in review: Housing, healthcare and conservation take center stage in Sharon

Sharon Hospital, shown here, experienced a consequential year marked by a merger agreement with Northwell Health, national recognition for patient care, and renewed concerns about emergency medical and ambulance coverage in the region.

Archive photo

Housing—both its scarcity and the push to diversify options—remained at the center of Sharon’s public discourse throughout the year.

The year began with the Sharon Housing Trust announcing the acquisition of a parcel in the Silver Lake Shores neighborhood to be developed as a new affordable homeownership opportunity. Later in January, in a separate initiative, the trust revealed it had secured a $1 million preliminary funding commitment from the state Department of Housing to advance plans for an affordable housing “campus” on Gay Street.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kent 2025: Zoning Disputes and Civic Debate

An overflow crowd packed Kent Town Hall on June 27 for a scheduled vote on a proposed wakesurfing ban on Lake Waramaug, prompting then–First Selectman Marty Lindenmayer to adjourn the meeting without a vote.

By David Carley

KENT —In 2025, Kent officials and residents spent much of the year navigating zoning disputes, regional policy issues and leadership changes that kept Town Hall at the center of community life.

The year opened with heightened tensions when a local dispute on Stone Fences Lane brought a long-running, home-based pottery studio before the Planning and Zoning Commission.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: Community and change shape North Canaan
Bunny McGuire stands in the park that now bears her name in North Canaan.
Riley Klein

NORTH CANAAN — The past year was marked by several significant news events.

In January, the town honored Bunny McGuire for her decades of service to the community with the renaming of a park in her honor. The field, pavilion, playground and dog park on Main Street later received new signage to designate the area Bunny McGuire Park.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: Cornwall’s community spirit defined the year

In May, Cornwall residents gathered at the cemetery on Route 4 for a ceremony honoring local Revolutionary War veterans.

Lakeville Journal

CORNWALL — The year 2025 was one of high spirits and strong connections in Cornwall.

January started on a sweet note with the annual New Year’s Day breakfast at the United Church of Christ’s Parish House. Volunteers served up fresh pancakes, sausage, juice, coffee and real maple syrup.

Keep ReadingShow less