Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

Before Roe v. Wade, there was Griswold v. Conn.

In the summer of 1961, I wrote, “For a few days in October, Connecticut women will be able to receive birth control advice and devices in New Haven, where the Planned Parenthood League will open the state’s first birth control center in more than 20 years.” The league planned to test an ancient Connecticut birth control law that prohibited the use of contraception by everyone, including married couples.

It turned out to be a few days in November, 1961, the first to the 10th,  before Planned Parenthood opened and the state closed down the new birth control center and arrested Dr. C. Lee Buxton, a Yale gynecologist who practiced there and Estelle Griswold, executive director of the state Planned Parenthood League.

Griswold would give her name to Griswold v. Connecticut, the U.S. Supreme Court 1965 decision repealing the law by ruling that the Constitution did “protect the right to marital privacy” even though the words never appear in the document.

And Griswold thereby begat, in a way, Roe v. Wade, the 1973, 7-2 Supreme Court decision legalizing abortion.  The Roe decision was grounded on that right to privacy discovered in Griswold eight years earlier when Judge William O. Douglas wrote that privacy was covered in the rights to life, liberty and property grounded in several constitutional amendments.

The two dissenters, Democrat Hugo Black and Republican Lewis Powell, didn’t care much for the law but they couldn’t find the right to privacy the others saw so clearly.

Stewart, in fact, said he found the law “uncommonly silly” but felt the Court had no choice in finding it constitutional.

Connecticut’s birth control law was known as a Comstock law in honor of a Puritanical postal inspector whose main duty was keeping what he considered dirty material out of the mail. He was very good at it.

By the middle of the 20th century, Comstock laws only remained in the old Puritan states of Massachusetts and Connecticut, supported strongly, but not exclusively, by the influential Catholic Church in those states. Members of other religious faiths were also split, but mainly opposed to the totally unenforceable law.

But even though the use of condoms and birth control devices was growing, lawmakers in the two states were not eager to take a position on either side. They became even more reluctant to take a stand as some eminent Catholic laymen and clergy expressed their opposition to the law and called for its repeal.

Doctors, I pointed out in the series, had complained that birth control information was the only existing medical knowledge that Connecticut forbade them to use.

And I quoted Dr. Norman St. John-Stevas, a well-known British Catholic lawyer and writer who argued that Catholics campaigning for the maintenance of the unenforceable law “gain little for public morality. They do, however, increase the fear of Catholicism in the minds of non-Catholics.”

Most of the five-part series was devoted to the plans being made by Buxton and Griswold to test the law by forcing the state to close the lawbreaking birth control center they were about to open in New Haven and testing the closing in the courts, up to, they hoped, the Supreme Court.

Griswold said Connecticut Planned Parenthood had sent 12,000 state women to New York and Rhode Island during the past four years to be fitted with contraceptive devices in circumvention of the 82-year-old state law. She told me that the 12,000 women who had literally smuggled illegal contraceptive devices into the state prove the demand and need for centers.

We know now that things worked out as planned for Griswold and Buxton. The closing of their center made it to the Supreme Court, which found for Griswold and against Connecticut — and by extension, Massachusetts.

And my series of articles? I guess you’d have to say it wasn’t well received. In fact, it wasn’t received at all and the few quotes you read here are the first to be printed anywhere in the 61 years since they were written.

I had proposed the series to the Courant’s state editor, my immediate superior, and he readily approved. But the finished product was killed by the managing editor, the Courant’s top news executive, on the grounds it would offend some readers.

Those running the then-locally owned Courant were every bit as courageous as the state’s lawmakers.

 

Simsbury resident Dick Ahles is a retired journalist. Email him at rahles1@outlook.com.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Lakeville Journal and The Journal does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

A life reshaped by clay in “Matin”

Left to right: Hannah Wheeler, Matin Malikzada and Yonah Sadeh.

D.H. Callahan

On Monday, Oct. 26, a group of students, teachers and local residents gathered at the Hotchkiss School in Lakeville for a screening of the new short documentary “Matin.” The film tells the story of Matin Malikzada, a seventh-generation Afghani potter making a new life in New Milford, Connecticut. The film was made by local filmmaker Yonah Sadeh, creator of the Video Wall at the David M. Hunt Library, and Berkshires-based potter Hannah Wheeler, who were both present for the screening, along with Malikzada himself.

As a member of the seventh generation of his family to master the art of pottery, Malikzada had done things the way his family had for over a century. Istalif, the village where his family has lived for generations, was known throughout Afghanistan for its pottery, with wares sent across the country for use as everyday cups, bowls, plates and other vessels. The pottery-making families of Istalif gathered clay from the same mountain, about 30 to 45 minutes away by donkey. Every July, they would head north toward the Uzbekistan border to gather ishkar, a plant they processed by hand to make their signature glazes.

Keep ReadingShow less
Meg Sher finds her calling among the stacks

Meg Sher, executive director of the David M. Hunt Library in Falls Village.

L. Tomaino

When Meg Sher came to Falls Village in 2006 from Old Lyme, Connecticut, where she grew up, she never imagined she’d someday be the executive director of the David M. Hunt Library.

Although, in hindsight, perhaps it makes sense.

Keep ReadingShow less
Crescendo’s 23rd season speaks to the heart and mind

Christine Gevert, founding artistic director of Crescendo, conducts the audience at a performance.

Steve Potter

For Christine Gevert, founding artistic director of Crescendo, music from centuries past is anything but a relic. It is a living, breathing art form, full of drama, emotional complexity and, occasionally, surprises. As the regional choral and period-instrument ensemble launches its 23rd season, Gevert is once again bringing forgotten masterpieces into the present.

“Early Music has been my lifelong passion and the focus of my specialization in Europe and South America,” Gevert said. “Bringing this repertoire to our audiences in a nuanced way that does justice to its incredible depth, intensity, and beauty is deeply important to me.”

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Close Encounters with Music celebrates 35 years of musical discovery

Close Encounters with Music’s 35th season opens with “Saluting the Clarinet” featuring clarinetist Alexander Fiterstein.

Provided

For 35 years, cellist Yehuda Hanani has been inviting audiences to experience classical music in unexpected ways. As founder and artistic director of Close Encounters with Music, Hanani has built a concert series that goes beyond the music itself, exploring connections to literature, history, politics and the human experience.

This year, Close Encounters celebrates its 35th season with “Celebration & Discovery,” a seven-concert series that opens Sunday, Nov. 1, at the Mahaiwe Performing Arts Center in Great Barrington.

Keep ReadingShow less
Shinbone Alley brings spooky songs to Spencertown

Seeing isn’t always believing. Sometimes it’s the lack of a defined picture that can be the most compelling. And when Alex Harvey of Shinbone Alley sings his supernaturally charged sea shanties and street ballads, the unseen will be downright scary. On Oct. 30, the historically inclined storyteller and performer will create a spooky evening of forbidden tales and yarns through a carefully chosen series of songs at Spencertown Academy of Arts.

The repertoire for the performance is a bit fraught. Over the years, Shinbone Alley has explored the world of folklore through music. Though the group usually features two musicians, Harvey, a multi-instrumentalist and singer, will be performing solo. That is, of course, unless you include the spirits.

Keep ReadingShow less
Malian blues and Moroccan Gnawa meet in Sheffield
Vieux Farka Touré
Proivded

Desert winds rarely blow into the Berkshires, but on Nov. 5, they will carry the Malian blues and Moroccan Gnawa music to Race Brook Lodge.

That evening, Malian guitarist Vieux Farka Touré, often called “the Hendrix of the Sahara,” and Moroccan musician Samir LanGus will play at the lodge’s Event Barn in Sheffield, Massachusetts, at a benefit for the foundation Touré directs.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.