Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

Please DON'T ‘Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses ...’

A few years ago, during a project on Russian Jewish immigrants, I came upon Malka Chavanowa, who in 1905 had arrived at Ellis Island with her 10-year-old son. Beside her name were initials, LPC, which turned out to stand for, “likely to become a public charge.” Although Malka was allowed to pass through Ellis Island (she would become matriarch of Arnoff’s Moving and Storage), women who arrived without a husband either at their side or waiting on the pier were labeled LPC, and many were put back on steerage to be returned to Europe.  

At the time, I was outraged at U.S. Immigration’s assumption that a woman was incapable of sustaining herself. It never occurred to me that becoming a “public charge,” was part of the web of obstacles that immigrants still face — that is, until President Trump’s recent executive decision to deny green cards to any immigrant who has applied for one of a range of federal public assistance programs. 

The fact is, U.S. Immigration has long used “public charge” to refer to someone primarily dependent on the government for subsistence, either through income maintenance or institutionalization for long term care. Nor is the 21st century version of the term “inadmissibility on public charge grounds” new with the Trump administration. Though rarely used, government statistics show that, in 2016, 164 visas were denied on the grounds that the applicant could become a “public charge.” What is noteworthy is the enormous increase in the use of the hardhearted term under Trump: in fiscal year 2018, 5,518 immigrants were denied visas “on public charge grounds.” 

Trump’s executive decision, intended as a “clarification” of current policy, denies green cards to those who have applied for any of various public assistance programs, from food stamps, housing vouchers, SSI and Medicaid to purchasing subsidized or unsubsidized healthcare under the Affordable Care Act. Needless to say, most of these programs offer far less than primary dependency on the government. Although there are already several court challenges to the decision, the suggestion that poor immigrants are taking undue advantage of federal benefit programs needs to be critiqued.

First, the 11 million undocumented immigrants in the U.S., including DACA recipients, who contribute an estimated $11.74 billion to state and local economies each year, have never been eligible for the federal benefit programs mentioned in the executive order. Second, legal immigrants — those with lawful permanent resident (LPR) status — are barred from full access to public benefit programs until they have been here for five years and/or have worked here for 40 quarters. Even social security benefits, which all workers pay into, are not available to legal immigrants until they have completed 40 quarters of work, in addition to having maintained LPR status for five years.

The Trump administration claims that it is simply looking to ensure self-sufficiency from immigrants and to prevent them from becoming a drain on U.S. taxpayers. Yet, immigrants pay more in taxes than they receive in government services and benefits, and legal immigrants use federal public benefit programs at lower rates than U.S.-born citizens. According to the Cato Institute, 32.5% of native-born citizen adults received SNAP benefits in 2012, compared to 25.4% of naturalized citizen adults and 29% of noncitizen adults. The Cato Institute also found that immigrants received lower benefit values, costing the program less than native-born citizens. 

While immigrants with serious medical conditions, along with their families, have until recently been allowed to remain in the United States while receiving life-saving medical treatment, without warning the Trump administration has also axed the “medical deferred action program.” Letters are being sent to thousands of immigrants here under this program, notifying them that they will have to leave within 33 days. The media have already reported stories of immigrant children for whom this may prove a death sentence. 

Those of us who want to live in a country that “cares for the stranger” are looking on in horror at the new rulings. More important, they must send a chill throughout our immigrant population, who see their choices being narrowed almost daily.  

 

Carol Ascher, who lives in Sharon, has published seven books of fiction and nonfiction, as well as many essays and stories.

Latest News

The Cornwall Whale resurfaces in West Cornwall

The Cornwall Whale is the brain-child of visual and experiential designer Lindsay Stadig.

D.H. Callahan

There’s something oddly familiar yet intangibly foreign about the Cornwall Whale. It’s not an interiors store, even though there are chairs and furnishings for sale. It’s not an art gallery, though there are paintings and sculptures occupying every corner of the space. It’s not a boutique, even with locally handmade shoes and carefully selected garments. No, The Cornwall Whale is something truly unique in the world of the truly unique.

The enigmatic shop popped up in the early winter of 2025 at the Hughes Memorial Library, right on the bank of the Housatonic River in West Cornwall. It is the brain-child of visual and experiential designer Lindsay Stadig.

Keep ReadingShow less

Social justice songwriting fall retreat

Social justice songwriting fall retreat

Singer, songwriter and activist Taína Asili leads a social justice songwriting retreat Nov. 20-23 at Soul Fire Farm in Petersburgh, N.Y.

Provided

Music has long been a powerful tool for protest, solidarity and social change. From civil rights anthems to contemporary songs of resistance, songwriting has helped give voice to movements and inspire collective action. Singer, composer and activist Taína Asili will explore that tradition during a four-day Social Justice Songwriting Retreat, Nov. 20 to 23, at Soul Fire Farm in Petersburgh, New York.

The retreat comes amid a renewed interest in collective singing as a form of activism. Organizations such as Singing Resistance are bringing people together across the country to use songs as tools for solidarity, nonviolent resistance and community building. The movement draws on the long history of music in social justice struggles, emphasizing the power of singing together to overcome fear, strengthen connections and inspire collective action.

Keep ReadingShow less
Where Calvin, Hobbes and Rockwell meet

Original “Calvin and Hobbes” comic strips by Bill Watterson are on view alongside works by Norman Rockwell in “Exploring Calvin and Hobbes” at the Norman Rockwell Museum. Stockbridge. The exhibition runs through May 31, 2027.

D.H. Callahan

Two distinctive approaches to American life and storytelling come together in a new exhibition at the Norman Rockwell Museum in Stockbridge, Massachusetts. Opening Saturday, Nov. 14, the exhibition brings the imaginative world of Bill Watterson’s “Calvin and Hobbes” into conversation with the familiar scenes of everyday life captured by Norman Rockwell. Though separated by generations and working in different mediums, both artists found humor, humanity and complexity in the seemingly ordinary.

Norman Rockwell skyrocketed to popularity when he started painting the covers for the Saturday Evening Post, a magazine with a history spanning more than two centuries.Its last print edition ran this past September, transitioning the publication to an online-only format. From 1897 until 1963, it published a new issue every week. Over that time, it published writings by literary legends like F. Scott Fitzgerald, Kurt Vonnegut, Agatha Christie, William Faulkner, Edgar Allan Poe, Louis L’Amour, John Steinbeck and Lenox, Massachusetts resident Edith Wharton, and featured comics by “Peanuts” creator Charles M. Schultz. In 1916, the magazine first featured one of Rockwell’s illustrations. He was just 22 years old.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Chim Chim Cher-ee! A local sweep makes movie magic
Dick Van Dyke, Julie Andrews and the Banks children in Disney’s 1964 classic, “Mary Poppins.”
Dick Van Dyke, Julie Andrews and the Banks children in Disney’s 1964 classic, “Mary Poppins.”

There are few films in the history of Hollywood that have endeared themselves to kids of all ages like “Mary Poppins.” On Sunday, Nov. 22 at 2 p.m., the classic story of a magical nanny, a couple precocious children, some cartoon penguins and a chimney sweep will screen at the Colonial Theatre in North Canaan. For the third year in a row, the event will be free of charge, thanks to Salisbury-based chimney sweep Rob Keller of Sultans of Soot.

Keller has been cleaning, relining and tending to area chimneys for over 30 years while raising a family in the community. He credits the Colonial for making its theater available for sponsored events like this one. Of course, Keller doesn’t need to drum up any more business this time of year. His motivation for the sponsorship is simply to give back to the community and create opportunities for togetherness. Seeing the joy and excitement of the kids and families who are making this a yearly tradition is more than enough for him.

Keep ReadingShow less
Erinys Quartet brings its furious energy to Wethersfield

The Erinys Quartet with Oskar Espina Ruiz and Alfonso Fuentes at Music Mountain in August 2026.

D.H. Callahan

This past summer, the Erinys Quartet, a chamber music ensemble, premiered a new composition by Puerto Rican composer Alfonso Fuentes at Music Mountain in Falls Village, Connecticut, accompanied by clarinetist Oskar Espina Ruiz. On Nov. 21 and 22, the same group will take the mountain’s programming on the road, performing together again at the Carriage House at the Wethersfield Estate & Garden in Amenia, New York.

The Erinys Quartet originated at the Sibelius Academy in Helsinki in 2018, when its members were all students. The musicians are from across the globe, with roots in Finland, Lithuania, Estonia, Rochester, New York, and Greece. The quartet’s name is taken from Greek mythology, in which the Erinyes were chthonic goddesses of vengeance. Homer referred to them in his epic “The Iliad,” writing, “the Erinyes, that under earth take vengeance on men, whosoever hath sworn a false oath.” Their Roman counterparts are the Furies. And indeed, the quartet can harness some rather furious energy..

Keep ReadingShow less

Tangled gift guide 2026

Tangled gift guide 2026

The Tacky Pescador Mag-Pad box fits in a shirt pocket, holds plenty of flies and has a spot for the tiny ones.

Patrick L. Sullivan

Anyone with the misfortune — er, the unbridled joy — of having a fly-fisherperson on the Christmas list knows the problem. In a sport where idiosyncrasy is an art form, how does the gift giver find something the giftee will use?

Also, how can this be accomplished without spending vast sums?

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.