Winchester Estate On Sale for Cool $17.5 Million


 

WINCHESTER — About 10 years ago, Jerome Pomerance purchased 438 acres of land on Winchester Lake, known as the Time Equity property. Last week Tom Mettling of Mettling Real Estate in Torrington listed the reconfigured Pomerance estate for $17,500,000.

Mettling has been a Realtor for 38 years and has brokered a majority of the transactions on Winchester Lake. Playing an active role in the subdivision of the 438 acres and recognizing the goals of the landowners through the years, Mettling said he is satisfied that Pomerance’s goals to preserve Winchester Lake were met.


History


For nearly a decade, the Time Equity property remained unsold as an approved 65-acre subdivision. In 1999 the property was finally "sold to the Pomerances with the intent that they would build on the property," said Mettling.

"The plan changed slightly so that his decision was to sell off a couple of big chunks," said Mettling. However, restrictions and covenants written into the deed would restrict future subdivision of the parcels.

Pomerance initially gave nearly 30 acres of land fronting Grantville Road to the neighboring Nature Conservancy. The land conveyed included the Silas Hall Pond.

Pomerance then sold a 143-acre parcel to the Yeary family of Rye, N.Y., according to Mettling.

According to Mettling, the Yearys purchased the 143 acres for $2,750,000 and have since carved a 4,000-foot driveway to their site and may begin building next spring.

A 127-acre parcel with frontage on Winchester Road was sold next, said Mettling, bought by Dartnell for $2,400,000.

"I sold one more parcel for Pomerance before he died in December," said Mettling. This parcel included the south half of the lake’s peninsula. Thirty-five acres in all were sold for $1,500,000. Approximately two-thirds of that land belonged to Pomerance and the remainder to a bordering neighbor.

"That left 120 acres of the remaining property," said Mettling, which became the Pomerance estate.

Of the original 438 acres and 91 additional acres owned by the Ilany family, four owners have direct water frontage on Winchester Lake. Because of the restrictions in place, those will be the only properties to have this luxury, explained Mettling. The state of Connecticut owns the rest of the shoreline.


The House


"The house is on a mini-peninsula. It’s a 7,000-square-foot lodge-style home," said Mettling. "It is probably the finest craftsmanship and workmanship that I have ever seen in 38 years of this business. It is just a work of art."

Included on the property is a tennis court, inground pool and pool house and three-car garage. According to data from the Multiple Listing Service, the house has two fireplaces, four bedrooms and four-and-a-half bathrooms. The master bedroom is 27 feet by 21 feet and the great-room style living room is 36 feet by 28 feet.

The property sits on 1 mile of direct shoreline and includes a small island and a stone-lined canal with a boat basin and dock.

"It is just an absolutely beautiful blend of stone and wood," said Mettling. "Fifty feet away from the waters edge you can paddle a canoe along the shoreline and it just blends into the background."

Pomerance had the opportunity to see about 90 percent of the construction completed on the home when he died in December at the age of 66. The final touches to the landscape are just about complete as of this week.

Mettling said that it was the family’s decision, with Pomerance’s blessing before he died, to sell the estate. "The family did make the decision to sell rather than to keep it and enjoy it for themselves."

It is amazing "the spirit and commitment that he had to a dream to have this piece of property that others could enjoy without fear of it being developed," said Mettling.

Latest News

Year in review: Quiet change and enduring spirit in Falls Village

Matthew Yanarella shows children and adults how to make cannoli at the Hunt Library on Sept. 12.

By Patrick L. Sullivan

FALLS VILLAGE — The year 2025 saw some new faces in town, starting with Liz and Howie Ives of the Off the Trail Cafe, which took over the town-owned space at 107 Main St., formerly occupied by the Falls Village Cafe.

As the name suggests, the café’s owners have made a point of welcoming Appalachian Trail hikers, including be collaborating with the Center on Main next door on an informal, trail-themed art project.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: Progress and milestones in Salisbury

Affordable housing moved forward in 2025, including two homes on Perry Street in Lakeville. Jennifer Kronholm Clark (with scissors) cuts the ribbon at one of the two affordable homes on Perry Street along with (from left) John Harney, State Representative Maria Horn (D-64) and housing Commissioner Seila Mosquera-Bruno.

By Patrick L. Sullivan

SALISBURY — Salisbury expanded its affordable housing stock in 2025 with the addition of four new three-bedroom homes developed by the Salisbury Housing Trust. Two of the homes were built at 26 and 28 Undermountain Rd, with another two constructed at the top of Perry Street in Lakeville.

Motorists and students from The Hotchkiss School will soon benefit from a new sidewalk along Sharon Road (Route 41) connecting the school to Lakeville village. In November, Salisbury was awarded $800,000 in state funding to construct the sidewalk along the southbound side of the road, linking it to the existing sidewalk between Main Street and Wells Hill Road.

Keep ReadingShow less
New CT laws taking effect Jan. 1: Housing, solar panels, driving
The state Capitol.
Mark Pazniokas/CT Mirror

Connecticut will kick off 2026 with nearly two dozen new laws that are slated to wholly or partially take effect on Jan 1.

The laws touch a range of areas in the state, from farming to pharmaceuticals to housing to the justice system.

Keep ReadingShow less
Housatonic falls to Nonnenwaug 52-42 in varsity season opener

HVRHS’s Victoria Brooks navigates traffic on her way to the hoop. She scored a game-high 17 points against Nonnewaug Tuesday, Dec. 16.

Riley Klein

FALLS VILLAGE — Berkshire League basketball returned to Housatonic Valley Regional High School Tuesday, Dec. 16.

Nonnewaug High School’s girls varsity team beat Housatonic 52-42 in the first game of the regular season.

Keep ReadingShow less