It's not an 'invasion,' but immigration needs attention

Article IV of the Constitution states that in addition to guaranteeing to every state a republican form of government, it also guarantees to “protect each of them against invasion.â€

By failing to secure our borders since 9/11, has the government failed to protect states like Arizona and therefore the entire nation against invasion? Not an invasion of illegal immigrants, but an invasion of those enemies who can and do cross the open borders along with them.

Of course, the delegates to the Constitutional Convention had neither illegal immigrants nor terrorists in mind when they drafted Article IV. They were thinking of Red Coats streaming over the Canadian border or attacking from ships anchored off the Atlantic coast. And they surely couldn’t envision a time when a handful of men could seize airliners and kill thousands of Americans in minutes.

In 1994, Arizona (yes, Arizona) cited Article IV when it sued the federal government to recover a modest $121 million it said the state was owed to keep illegal immigrants in Arizona prisons. A federal appeals court threw out the suit, ruling Arizona — and California, which had joined the suit — were not being invaded by a hostile, foreign power. Three years later, the Supreme Court refused to consider Arizona’s appeal.

But on Sept. 11, 2001, our ideas about wars and invasions changed for all time when 19 al-Qaeda terrorists hijacked four passenger jet airliners and crashed them into the Twin Towers, the Pentagon and a Pennsylvania field, killing nearly 3,000. Only the size of the invasion force made it different from the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor that killed a similar number of Americans.

Sadly, the fact that unknown numbers of terrorists can be among the millions who illegally breach our borders has made no more of an impression on those elected to uphold the Constitution than it had on the pre-9/11 courts.

The House has passed immigration reform, but the last time the United States Senate, that most deliberative body, made a serious attempt to do anything about the 12 or 20 million undocumented immigrants already here and the millions more en route, was in 2007.

The bill, a thoughtful, bipartisan effort, combined upgraded border protection and a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants. It had the support of President Bush and prominent senators from both parties like Edward Kennedy and Lindsey Graham. Both Hispanic senators, Democrat Ken Salazar and Republican Mel Martinez, favored the bill, as did the two Arizona Republicans, John McCain and Jon Kyl, yet it failed.

It failed because it couldn’t attract the support of the party bases and special interests. It was attacked on the right as being soft on illegals, for granting “amnesty†to those who illegally came here seeking work and rewarding them for violating the law. Civil rights groups on the left attacked a guest worker program that they feared would create a permanent underclass of workers, and unions balked at the specter of nonunion immigrants competing for jobs. It was picked to death, failed four cloture votes and was abandoned, some say prematurely, by the Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, who informed reporters, “the bill’s over with, the bill’s gone.â€

As David Broder recalled last week in The Washington Post, a disappointed Edward Kennedy asked those who killed the bill what they proposed to do next.

“What are they going to do with the 12 million who are undocumented here? Send them back to countries around the world? Develop a type of Gestapo here to seek out these people that are in the shadows?â€

Last month, Arizona adopted the Gestapo alternative and in doing so, got the attention of that great deliberative body once again. Leader Reid, who killed the 2007 bill before its time, now needs Hispanic voters to save his elective neck back home in Nevada, so he’s willing to try again.

But don’t bet on immigration reform succeeding this election year, no matter how dangerous ignoring it may be.

Dick Ahles is a retired journalist from Simsbury. E-mail him at dahles@hotmail.com.

Latest News

‘Vulnerable Earth’ opens at the Tremaine Gallery

Tremaine Gallery exhibit ‘Vulnerable Earth’ explores climate change in the High Arctic.

Photo by Greg Lock

“Vulnerable Earth,” on view through June 14 at the Tremaine Gallery at Hotchkiss, brings together artists who have traveled to one of the most remote regions on Earth and returned with work shaped by first-hand experience of a fragile, rapidly shifting planet, inviting viewers to sit with the tension between awe and loss, beauty and vulnerability.

Curated by Greg Lock, director of the Photography, Film and Related Media program at The Hotchkiss School, the exhibition centers on participants in The Arctic Circle, an expeditionary residency that sends artists and scientists into the High Arctic aboard a research vessel twice a year. The result is a show documenting their lived experience and what it means to stand in a place where climate change is not theoretical but visible, immediate and accelerating.

Keep ReadingShow less
Beyond Hammertown: Joan Osofsky designs what comes next

Joan Osofsky and Sharon Marston

Provided

Joan Osofsky is closing the doors on Hammertown, one of the region’s most beloved home furnishings and lifestyle destinations, after 40 years, but she is not calling it an ending.

“I put my baby to bed,” she said, describing the decision with clarity and calm. “It felt like the right time.”

Keep ReadingShow less
A celebratory season of American classics and new works at Barrington Stage Company
Playwright Keelay Gipson’s “Estate Sale” will have its world premier this summer at Barrington Stage Company.
Provided

Amid the many cultural attractions in the region, the Barrington Stage Company in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, stands out for its award-winning productions and comprehensive educational and community-based programming. The theater’s 2026 season is one of its most ambitious; it includes two Pulitzer Prize-winning modern classics, one of the greatest theatrical farces ever written, and new works that speak directly to who we are right now as a society.

“Our 2026 season is a celebration of extraordinary storytelling in all its forms — timeless, uproarious and boldly new,” said Artistic Director Alan Paul. “This season features works that have shaped the American theater, as well as world premieres that reflect the company’s deep commitment to developing new voices and new stories. Together, these productions embody what BSC does best: entertain, challenge and connect our audiences through theater that feels both essential and alive.”

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Hotchkiss Film Festival celebrates 15th year of emerging filmmakers

Student festival directors Trey Ramirez (at the mic) and Leon Li introducing the Hotchkiss Film Festival.

Brian Gersten

The 15th annual Hotchkiss Film Festival took place Saturday, April 25, marking a milestone year for a student-driven event that continues to grow in ambition, reach and artistic scope. The festival was founded in 2012 by Hotchkiss alumnus and Emmy-nominated filmmaker Brian Ryu. Ryu served as a festival juror for this year’s installment, which showcased a selection of emerging filmmakers from around the region. The audience was treated to 17 films spanning drama, horror, comedy, documentary and experimental forms — each reflecting a distinct voice and perspective.

This year’s program was curated by student festival directors Trey Ramirez and Leon Li, working alongside faculty adviser Ann Villano. With more than 52 submissions received, the selection process was both rigorous and rewarding. The final lineup included six films from Hotchkiss students.

Keep ReadingShow less
Artist Maira Kalman curates ‘Shaker Outpost’ in Chatham

The Laundry Room, a painting by Maira Kalman from the exhibition “Shaker Outpost: Design, Commerce, and Culture” at the Shaker Museum’s pop-up space in Chatham.

Photo by Maira Kalman; Courtesy of the artist and Mary Ryan Gallery, New York

With “Shaker Outpost: Design, Commerce, and Culture,” opening May 2, the Shaker Museum in Chatham invites artist and writer Maira Kalman to pair her own new paintings with objects from the museum’s vast holdings, and, in the process, reintroduce the Shakers not as relic, but as a living argument for clarity, usefulness and grace.

Born in Tel Aviv, Maira Kalman is a New York–based artist and writer known for her illustrated books, wide-ranging collaborations and distinctive work spanning publishing, design and fine art.

Keep ReadingShow less

Ticking Tent spring market returns

Ticking Tent spring market returns

The Ticking Tent Spring Market returns to Spring Hill Vineyards in New Preston on May 2.

Jennifer Almquist

The Ticking Tent Spring Market returns to New Preston Saturday, May 2, bringing more than 60 antiques dealers, artisans and design brands to Spring Hill Vineyards for a one-day, brocante-style shopping event from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Co-founders Christina Juarez and Benjamin Reynaert invite visitors to the outdoor market at 292 Bee Brook Road, where curated vendors will offer home goods, fashion, tabletop and collectible design. Guests can browse while enjoying Spring Hill Vineyards’ wines and seasonal fare.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.