Democracy in decline, prey to numbness and inaction

This infrequent column always strives to take the long view. Here is a very long one: Governance by representative democracy is but a hiccup in the history of the world. From time immemorial, human societies have been ruled by autocracies that oppress the vast majority of people who are not in the tiny ruling class.

Autocracy was our collective past, and may well be our collective future.

Montesquieu (1689-1755) wrote that the basic principle of democracy is “the love of the laws and of [the] country,” and that it requires “a constant preference of public to private interest” on the part of individuals who aspire to hold public office, and “self-renunciation” in favor of service to the greater good. Democracy can be fatally corrupted, he wrote, by “the spirit of inequality,” which he defined as some citizens seeking to advance their own agendas and private interests at the expense of the others, including the acquisition of political power over those others. Montesquieu believed that democracy would only work for modestly sized states.

In the 22nd century — should human beings survive that long on Earth — it feels to me at the moment that the era of representative democratic governance will be gone.  Looking back from then, historians will judge that the era notable for such attributes as fair-mindedness, attempts to better the lives of the poor, and capitalism that “works” for the benefit of the majority of people lasted less than 300 years total, from the latter part of the 18th century until the middle of the 21st.

Democracy’s initial blossoming coincided with the onset of capitalism. Adam Smith’s major work on capitalism and the Declaration of Independence were both issued in 1776.  Future historians will take as a given that large-scale democracy could not have prevailed if not in tandem with capitalism.

However, today we are in the throes of what has been termed “end-stage capitalism,” with the vast majority of added wealth increasingly going to a very privileged few, and the remainder of us dividing a smaller pie. The decline of democracy and the updraft of wealth to the very top tier are inextricably tied, and one of the characteristics of today’s vote-denial movement is that the very wealthy are using the undereducated and the severely impoverished to accomplish their ends, while allowing that underclass to take the brunt of the criticism for what the privileged want and from which the very rich will benefit the most.

To maintain our democracy requires that citizens are able to vote in a free and fair manner for our leaders, and to do so while taking for granted that the decision of the majority will then be accepted by those who backed the candidates who did not win. In this regard we should remember that other countries such as Russia regularly hold what they label as votes of the populace, and then tout the results to show that their leaders have been “democratically” chosen and their decisions validated, even though that is far from the truth. The recent votes in the eastern provinces of Ukraine, to become part of Russia — votes held at actual gunpoint, by armed men going house to house — are a case in point.   We should also remember that Hitler was elected more-or-less democratically.

Today’s American election deniers, and those pledged to overturn the votes of the people if those votes don’t agree with the pledgers’ picks, and the racially and politically motivated gerrymanderers, and the judges bent on destroying the Constitution in the guise of defending it, are gaining ground rapidly.  I am not sanguine that their rising tide can be stopped, because the vast majority of us are so content with our lot that we cannot believe we will lose anything of value to us should the deniers take over.

So please vote in the upcoming election. It will likely be your last chance to do so in a free and fair way, and in a representative democracy, and for candidates pledged to the continuance of our democratic institutions and way of life. If you don’t vote in 2022, by 2024 the issue may be moot.

Democracy will likely not die in fire but in the ice of numbness and inaction.

Salisbury resident Tom Shachtman has written more than two dozen books and many television documentaries.

 

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Lakeville Journal and The Journal does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

One dead, two hurt in Sharon car crash

Emergency responders block Amenia Union Road in Sharon Saturday, Oct. 11, while responding to the vehicle crash.

Photo by Patrick L. Sullivan

SHARON — Emergency crews were called Saturday, Oct. 11, to Amenia Union Road in Sharon for a report of a vehicle into a building with entrapment.

The call went out shortly after 3 p.m. with an update at 3:20 p.m. reporting one dead on arrival, two conscious. Emergency helicopter transport was requested.

Keep ReadingShow less
Rhys V. Bowen

LAKEVILLE — Rhys V. Bowen, 65, of Foxboro, Massachusetts, died unexpectedly in his sleep on Sept. 15, 2025. Rhys was born in Sharon, Connecticut, on April 9, 1960 to Anne H. Bowen and the late John G. Bowen. His brother, David, died in 1979.

Rhys grew up at The Hotchkiss School in Lakeville, where his father taught English. Attending Hotchkiss, Rhys excelled in academics and played soccer, basketball, and baseball. During these years, he also learned the challenges and joys of running, and continued to run at least 50 miles a week, until the day he died.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kelsey K. Horton

LAKEVILLE — Kelsey K. Horton, 43, a lifelong area resident, died peacefully on Saturday, Sept. 27, 2025, at Norwalk Hospital in Norwalk, Connecticut, following a courageous battle with cancer. Kelsey worked as a certified nursing assistant and administrative assistant at Noble Horizons in Salisbury, from 1999 until 2024, where she was a very respected and loved member of their nursing and administrative staff.

Born Oct. 4, 1981, in Sharon, she was the daughter of W. Craig Kellogg of Southern Pines, North Carolina, and JoAnne (Lukens) Tuncy and her husband Donald of Millerton, New York. Kelsey graduated with the class of 1999 from Webutuck High School in Amenia and from BOCES in 1999 with a certificate from the CNA program as well. She was a longtime member of the Lakeville United Methodist Church in Lakeville. On Oct. 11, 2003, in Poughkeepsie, New York, she married James Horton. Jimmy survives at home in Lakeville. Kelsey loved camping every summer at Waubeeka Family Campground in Copake, and she volunteered as a cheer coach for A.R.C. Cheerleading for many years. Kelsey also enjoyed hiking and gardening in her spare time and spending time with her loving family and many dear friends.

Keep ReadingShow less
Eliot Warren Brown

SHARON — On Sept. 27, Eliot Warren Brown was shot and killed at age 47 at his home in New Orleans, Louisiana, in a random act of violence by a young man in need of mental health services. Eliot was born and raised in Sharon, Connecticut, and attended Indian Mountain School and Concord Academy in Massachusetts. He graduated from the School of the Art Institute of Chicago. He and his wife Brooke moved to New Orleans to answer the call for help in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina and fell in love with the city.

In addition to his wife Brooke, Eliot leaves behind his parents Malcolm and Louise Brown, his sisters Lucia (Thaddeus) and Carla (Ruairi), three nephews, and extended family and friends spread far and wide.

Keep ReadingShow less