Extremist fringes damaging both parties

Our two, not-so-great political parties are stumbling and fumbling their way to the the 2022 and 2024 congressional and presidential elections because of the antics — to use a kind word — of their respective extremist wings.

The Republicans are suffering from a tendency to pander to the pro-Donald Trump, populist/right base that seems to have become noisier since his defeat while still not growing large enough to win anything.

At the same time, the Democrats appear reluctant to offend their very own crazies on the left.

“Signs of Progressive Overreach Abound” was The New York Times headline the other day over a story about the Democratic Party’s left wing trying to outdo the Republicans’ right in sowing discord.

Of course, nothing the left has done has come close to the Jan. 6, 2021, Trump-led insurrection aimed at illegally overthrowing the election of a president.

But you’ve got to give the Democratic left credit for trying.

However, the party’s moderates have been fighting back. In normally liberal New York, the very unpopular progressive mayor Bill De Blasio, his gubernatorial and presidential dreams demolished, was succeeded by a Democratic centrist, retired NYPD Captain Eric Adams. In one of the new mayor’s first moves, he proposed cuts in nearly every part of the city budget — except the police at a time when crime was on the rise and the left was campaigning to defund the police.

Minneapolis, home of the murdered George Floyd and the subsequent anti-police demonstrations that sometimes became violent, survived a referendum that would have replaced the city’s police department with an agency that emphasized social work over law enforcement.

That Minneapolis vote seems to have ended the brief run of the aforementioned “defund the police” movement.

But the most interesting reaction to the excesses of the Democratic left came in mid-February in San Francisco, the most liberal locality in all these United States.

While keeping the city’s public schools closed longer than most places during the pandemic and showing little to no interest in the impact of remote learning on students and families, the liberal board of education occupied its time conducting a crusade against 44 figures from America’s past whose names adorn the city’s public schools.

All 44 were considered guilty of what amounted to not living up to the contemporary moral, social and cultural standards of the San Francisco board of education even though they lived mostly in the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries.

The list contained the usual, but also, the most unusual suspects. Slave holders like George Washington and Thomas Jefferson were easy targets, without regard for their other, rather significant contributions. But others on the list attracted more attention and ridicule. Abraham Lincoln was considered unworthy of having his name on a school because he wasn’t sufficiently anti-slavery and Paul Revere, the guy who rode through the Massachusetts countryside notifying the Colonists that “the British are coming,” also had to go.

Other victims included John Muir, one of the fathers of the environmental movement, and the current senior senator from their own state of California, the apparently not liberal enough liberal Democrat Dianne Feinstein.

But the board’s greatest offense — after keeping the schools closed while working diligently on rename them — was the decision to end the merit-based admissions policy that had made San Francisco’s Lowell High School a city and state  treasure.

The school’s merit-based admissions resulted in an overwhelmingly white and Asian-American student body, so the school board’s action especially rankled the city’s large, politically active Chinese-American citizenry.

While this was going on, Chinese-Americans across the nation were being attacked — sometimes violently — following the discovery of COVID-19 in Wuhan, China and  President Trump’s attempt to dub the spreading disease the Chinese Virus and the slightly more pejorative “Kung Flu.”

But it didn’t stop the school board from ending merit-based admissions, leaving San Francisco’s largely Democratic, Chinese/Asian-American population mad as hell and not going to take it anymore, to quote the old movie.

In a city that is 36% Asian-American and 40 percent white, they formed a recall movement that removed the board’s three most progressive members by a whopping 70 percent of the referendum turnout.

So, which party’s extremists can do their party the most harm as we move toward the coming elections? It was interesting on a recent Sunday to hear the respected Republican pollster Frank Luntz offer his analysis.

Without knowing the future of the pandemic and Ukraine, said Luntz, “If you look at polling data and do the focus groups and talk to independents,  I find it difficult to see any other conclusion than Republicans winning control of the House and Senate.”

But, and there was a big but, “only Donald Trump could stand in the way. If he tries to make it [the election] about November of 2020 or January of 2021, if he tries to make it about himself, the Republicans could lose.”

Can you imagine Donald Trump doing anything like that?

 

Simsbury resident Dick Ahles is a retired journalist. Email him at rahles1@outlook.com.

Latest News

Red Sox and Royals clash in AAA little league showdown

Teddy Kneeland braces for impact with the catcher.

Riley Klein

TORRINGTON — The Steve Blass Northwest Connecticut Red Sox dropped a nailbiter 10-9 loss to Torrington Royal at Major Besse Park June 5.

The penultimate game of the AAA regular season came down to the wire with Torrington securing a walk-off victory in the final inning. The Red Sox, composed of players aged 9 to 11 from the six Region One towns, played a disciplined game and shook hands with their heads held high after the loss.

Keep ReadingShow less
Art sale to support new nonprofit

“Galactic Dance,” a 90-by-72-inch work by painter Tom Goldenberg of Sharon, is one of about 20 works featured in a fundraising art sale at The White Hart Inn from June 14 to 16.

Provided

It has been said that living well is an art. For Keavy Bedell and Craig Davis, that art form doesn’t end in the so-called Golden years. The two Lakeville residents have created a new nonprofit organization called East Mountain House that will help make end-of-life kinder and gentler.

Bedell has been active in the community, providing access to all levels of assistance to people who are finding it hard to do the essential tasks and activities that bring meaning and joy to their lives. She is trained in contemplative care and is a certified end of life doula.

Keep ReadingShow less
A Heroine’s tale at Hunt Library
Provided

On Thursday, June 20 at 2 p.m., the David M. Hunt Library in Falls Village, in collaboration with the Falls Village Equity Project, will host “Honoring a Heroine: The MumBet Story.” This event features storyteller and museum educator Tammy Denease, who will bring to life the inspiring true story of Elizabeth “MumBet” Freeman.

Elizabeth Freeman, also known as MumBet, was an enslaved African nurse, midwife, and herbalist. Born around 1744 in Claverack, New York, she spent 30 years enslaved in the household of Colonel John Ashley in Sheffield, Massachusetts. Ashley was one of the creators of the 1773 Sheffield Declaration which stated that “Mankind in a state of nature are equal, free, and independent of each other, and have a right to the undisturbed enjoyment of their lives, their liberty and property.” This same language was used in the United States Declaration of Independence of 1776 and in the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780. Evidence suggests that MumBet overheard these ideas when Colonel Ashley held events in his home and when the documents were read aloud in the public square. Seeking freedom, she turned to Theodore Sedgwick, a prominent attorney who helped draft the Sheffield Declaration with Colonel Ashley. MumBet, along with an enslaved man named Brom, began the process of fighting for their freedom. Historians note that Sedgwick, along with many of the lawyers in the area, decided to use the case as a “test case” to determine if slavery was constitutional under the new Massachusetts Constitution.

Keep ReadingShow less
Knees creak by wee creeks

First brookie of the day in hand.

This spring I have spent more time than usual creeping around the “little blue lines,” those streams that show up on good maps as, yes, little blue lines.

This is where to find wild trout. Often brook trout, occasionally browns or rainbows.

Keep ReadingShow less