A New Musical Flails at Sharon Playhouse

Sharon Playhouse has produced some delightful new works in the last three years: “Nine Wives,” “Next Thing You Know,” and last year, the wonderful “Georgie.” But this season’s “Judge Jackie: Disorder in the Court” is so confused that even terrific direction and some fine performances cannot save it.

Van Kaplan, a producer of “An American in Paris” on Broadway and executive producer of Pittsburgh Civic Light Opera, the Steel City’s year-round venue for musical theater, noted the popularity of outrageous reality TV shows where society’s least attractive citizens are put on show like damaged specimens. (Think Judge Judy, Jerry Springer, or the ever-loathsome Dr. Phil.)

Kaplan, who also produces CLO’s Cabaret series, took the idea of basing a musical on these TV shows to the team of lyricist and script writer Christopher Dimond, and composer Michael Kooman.  These graduates of Carnegie Mellon’s musical theater school, writers of several musicals and winners of three prizes, including the Fred Ebb Award, produced “Judge Jackie,” which debuted at CLO in early 2014 — a musical mishmash of plot and musical styles. 

Judge Jackie (the estimable Klea Blackhurst, who sings and dances — she does a mean break dance in the second act — but bobbles a few of the banal lines) learns that her TV show is plummeting in the ratings. A network hack (always hardworking David Fanning) tells her she needs more outrageous celebrities (think Lindsay Lohan), more romance, more of society’s dregs. So we get lawsuits about too-hot pizza cheese, disappearance of money to fund a survival bunker, even one seeking parental emancipation for a pop singer from her lascivious father.

The best of the show comes at the beginning, when Judge Jackie’s bailiff, Henry (charming Paul Whitty, who originated the role of Billy in “Once” on Broadway with his lovely high baritone), teaches the audience the Judge Jackie theme song, complete with fist pump, followed by audience participation (if you do not want to be selected, do not sit in the front rows.)

Then the real play begins with its focus on saving the judge’s show with boosted ratings. Underneath is a confusing backstory of Jackie’s love life, which I doubt even she could understand. All delivered in dialog that mistakes limp and clichéd for funny and clever.

Director John Simpkins and his set designer, Josh Smith, have created a realistic judge’s bench with two witness boxes on wheels that serve many purposes. All is done in warm wood tones, with the audience sitting on three sides as an expanded jury. (Yes, dear readers, this jury gets to select from three possible endings for the show. Original, no?) Simpkins has directed with energy and inventiveness, but not enough attention to diction. 

There are some good songs that surprise when they come along. Henry’s “If Only You Knew” about his secret passion is terrific. “Chour Fantasy” — sung by Whitty as Jorge de Amour (how did that “u” get into a Spanish word?) — moves the show along, despite its condescension to Spanish-Americans. “Like Your Mother Does” is a sweet paean to maternal protection.

All of the plaintiffs and defendants are played by young Danielle Gimbal and Tim Shea with hip accents that are rarely understandable. Unfortunately, in Gimbal’s trashy song, “My Daddy Hates Me,” she is.

A  minor show, the kind that plays in small community theaters, maybe off-off-Broadway, could be made out of “Judge Jackie” with a better, more coherent script. But it will have to be a lot better.

 

“Judge Jackie: Disorder in the Court” runs in the Sharon Playhouse Bok Gallery through July 17. Call 860-364-7469 or go to www.info@sharonplayhouse.org for tickets.

Latest News

Sharon parents push back on school budget cuts

Sharon resident Veronica Betts posts flyers around Sharon to raise support for Sharon Center School.

Madi Long

SHARON – In a last-ditch effort to avoid a proposed $70,000 cut to the Sharon Center School’s 2026-27 budget, local parents are mobilizing – packing meetings, posting flyers and warning that reductions could undermine the school’s future. Sharon resident Veronica Betts plastered the town with posters earlier this week, urging residents to attend town meetings to voice support for the Board of Education, which determines the SCS budget.

“We shouldn’t be talking about defunding the school,” said Betts, who has a young daughter en- rolled in Sharon Daycare, part of SCS. “These are kids, this is so short-sighted and ridiculous.” The cuts, if adopted, could affect the staff salary line, supplies and even the cafeteria, which would require premade lunches to be delivered from HVRHS.

Keep ReadingShow less
Remembering George and Anne Phillips’ Edgewood restaurant in Amenia

The Edgewood Restaurant, a beloved Amenia roadside restaurant run by George and Anne Phillips, pictured during its peak years in the 1950s and ’60s.

Provided

With the recent death of George Phillips at 100, locals are remembering the Edgewood Restaurant, the Amenia supper club he and his wife, Anne Phillips, owned and operated together for more than two decades.

At the Edgewood, there were Delmonico steaks George carved in the basement, lobster tails from an infrared cooker, local trout from the stream outside the door, and a folded paper cup of butter, with heaping bowls of family-style potatoes and vegetables, plus a shot glass of crème de menthe to calm the stomach when the modest check arrived after dessert.

Keep ReadingShow less
Artist Alissa DeGregorio brings her work to Roxbury and New Milford

Alissa DeGregorio, a New Milford -based artist and designer, has pieces on display at Mine Hill Distillery.

Agnes Fohn
When I’m designing a book, I’m also the bridge between artist and author, the final step that pulls everything together.
— Alissa DeGregorio

A visit to Alissa DeGregorio Art, the website of the artist and designer, reveals the multiple talents she possesses.

Tabs for design, commissions, print club, and classes still reveal only part of her work.On the design page are examples of graphic and book design, including book covers illustrated by DeGregorio, along with samples of licensed products such as coloring pages and lunch boxes, and examples of prop design she has done for film.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Agnes Martin at Dia:Beacon

Agnes Martin at Dia:Beacon

Minimalist works by Agnes Martin on display at Dia:Beacon.

D.H. Callahan

At Dia:Beacon, simplicity commands attention.

On Saturday, April 4, the venerated modern art museum — located at 3 Beekman St. in Beacon, NY — opened an exhibition of works by the middle- to late-20th-century minimalist artist Agnes Martin.

Keep ReadingShow less
Falls Village exhibit honors life and work of Priscilla Belcher

Hunt Library in Falls Village will present a commemorative show of paintings and etchings by the late Priscilla Belcher of Falls Village.

Lydia Downs

Priscilla Belcher, a Canaan resident who was known for her community involvement and willingness to speak out, will be featured in a posthumous exhibition at the ArtWall at the Hunt Library from April 25 through May 15.

An opening reception will be held from 5 to 7 p.m. on April 25. The show will commemorate her life and work and will include watercolors and etchings. Belcher died in November 2025 at the age of 95.

Keep ReadingShow less
Crescendo’s 'Stepping Into Song' blends Jewish, Argentine traditions

The sounds of Argentine tango and Jewish folk traditions will collide in a rare cross-cultural performance April 25 and 26, when Berkshire’s Crescendo presents the choral program “Stepping Into Song.”

Christine Gevert, Crescendo’s founding artistic director, described the concert as “a world-class, diverse cultural experience” pairing “A Jewish Cantata” with Martin Palmeri’s “Misa a Buenos Aires.”

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.