Special coverage: The Rhiannon Smith case

Mysteries surround girl’s disappearance

WINSTED — A mysterious note left behind Sept. 1, the day Rhiannon Smith disappeared from her home, raised several red flags, right from the beginning.

The letter, written on a computer and printed on white paper, begins, “Dear Dale and Brian.�

Rhiannon’s grandmother, Dale Smith, explains the salutation is “very unlike Rhiannon. She never called us that — ever — especially Brian. She always called him ‘Papa.’�

The letter continues to explain with emotion and fear that Rhiannon is leaving to run from a male she calls Kasey, who has also been identified as 20-year-old Florida man Joey Schneider, an employee at a gift shop at Disney World in Orlando, with whom Rhiannon had once had an online affair. They remained in contact online and by phone until recently, according to Schneider, who contacted Winsted police at the urging of another friend, Kelley McGuire.

Both Schneider and McGuire have had repeated contact with The Winsted Journal regarding Rhiannon’s case. McGuire, of Torrington, has started a Facebook page devoted to helping find her close friend.

The mysterious letter also states that Rhiannon had “dated� Schneider her entire freshman year in high school — though the relationship apparently only existed online — and he is “the reason I am this way now.�

The letter goes on to claim that “Kasey, or rather Joey, wants to kill me� and everyone she loves, including her grandparents. “I will never forgive myself for the pain my absence will inflict upon you both and nor do I enjoy this parting, but it is for your safety, he doesn’t know I have grandparents,� the letter says.

In e-mails discovered by The Winsted Journal between Schneider and Rhiannon, he writes to her he was bored and had looked up her exact address and the name and age of her sstep-grandfather.

The letter then mentions five other people — all of whom are believed to be real people — using nicknames. Max, Jake, Nick, Sanji and Ashely are mentioned. Max has been positively identified as 20-year-old Jeffrey Woods of Alabama.

The letter Rhiannon left claims “Max� was trying to run from Schneider and that Max ultimately committed suicide in Alabama — a false claim, according to Winchester Police Department Sgt. Kevin Kinahan, who has interviewed Jeffrey Woods.

The letter goes on to say that “Jake, Nick and Sanji are taking me to my girlfriend Ashely in MA then we are all going to PEI or Cannda [sic].�

That part of the letter raises several more red flags. Dale Smith said Rhiannon had mentioned Jake, Nick and Sanji, who are possibly people she met online, and that Jake and Nick were around Rhiannon’s age, but Sanji was known as Nick’s older male partner. They may live in a condo near Westfarms Mall.

However, Smith also knows that Jake, Nick and Sanji are not real names. Most of Rhiannon’s friends and acquaintances used nicknames for each other, with Rhiannon going by the name Wolf-e.

Dale Smith said she still thinks “Jake� may be the key to what happened to Rhiannon. Who exactly Jake is continues to be a mystery. Smith also said there were many spelling and grammatical errors in the letter, suggesting either that it was written under duress or that it wasn’t written by Rhiannon at all.

Whichever the case, it remains a mystery as to why and how Rhiannon vanished between the hours of midnight and 6 a.m. on Sept. 2.

Questions quickly built up following Rhiannon’s disappearance. Initially treating the case as a classic runaway, police noted that threats Rhiannon mentioned in her letter appeared to be false, linking names of her friends to fictional characters in a Japanese cartoon. But when additional information came to light regarding some psychological issues, the case was reclassified as “endangered runaway.�

Still unknown are the identities of Jake, Nick, Sanji and Ashely who are mentioned in Rhiannon’s supposed runaway letter.

Smith explained, “Rhiannon would always tell me about Jake, as she would talk to him online, apparently he dated a friend of hers. She told me Jake lived with his grandparents but then left to move in with Nick and Sanji, in their condominium near Westfarms Mall. She told me Jake just had gotten a job at the Walmart near the mall, but of course I don’t know how much of that is true, or if she just would tell it to me to cover up the truth of who these people are.�

Friends and family still believe identifying these mysterious contacts is crucial to finding Rhiannon. There has been some online chatter suggesting Jeffrey Woods may be “Jake,� but there are numerous profiles opened under code names, making the trail difficult to follow. Friends are hoping that a new online account will turn up, and that it will be Rhiannon’s.

Latest News

Salisbury property assessments up about 30%; Tax rate likely to drop
Salisbury Town Hall
Alec Linden

SALISBURY — Salisbury’s outside contractor, eQuality, has completed the town’s required five-year revaluation of all properties.

Proposed assessments were mailed to property owners in mid-December and show a median increase of approximately 30% to 32% across the grand list.

Keep ReadingShow less
HVA awards spotlight ‘once-in-a-generation’ land conservation effort anchored in Salisbury

Grant Bogle, center, poses with his Louis and Elaine Hecht Follow the Forest Award with Julia Rogers, left, and Tim Abbott, during HVA’s 2025 Annual Meeting and Holiday Party.

Photo by Laura Beckius / HVA

SALISBURY — From the wooded heights of Tom’s Hill, overlooking East Twin Lake, the long view across Salisbury now includes a rare certainty: the nearly 300-acre landscape will remain forever wild — a milestone that reflects years of quiet local organizing, donor support and regional collaboration.

That assurance — and the broader conservation momentum it represents — was at the heart of the Housatonic Valley Association’s (HVA) 2025 environmental awards, presented in mid-December at the organization’s annual meeting and holiday party at The Silo in New Milford.

Keep ReadingShow less
Northwest Corner voters chose continuity in the 2025 municipal election cycle
Lots of lawn signs were seen around North Canaan leading up to the Nov. 4 election.
Christian Murray

Municipal elections across Northwest Connecticut in 2025 largely left the status quo intact, returning longtime local leaders to office and producing few changes at the top of town government.

With the exception of North Canaan, where a two-vote margin decided the first selectman race, incumbents and established officials dominated across the region.

Keep ReadingShow less
The hydrilla menace: 2025 marked a turning point

A boater prepares to launch from O’Hara’s Landing at East Twin Lake this past summer, near the area where hydrilla was first discovered in 2023.

By Debra Aleksinas

SALISBURY — After three years of mounting frustration, costly emergency responses and relentless community effort, 2025 closed with the first sustained signs that hydrilla — the aggressive, non-native aquatic plant that was discovered in East Twin Lake in the summer of 2023 — has been pushed back through a coordinated treatment program.

The Twin Lakes Association (TLA) and its coalition of local, state and federal scientific partners say a shift in strategy — including earlier, whole-bay treatments in 2025 paired with carefully calibrated, sustained herbicide applications — yielded results not seen since hydrilla was first identified in the lake.

Keep ReadingShow less