Two teens die in fatal Pine Plains car crash, two others injured

PINE PLAINS — A one-car automobile accident took the lives of two high school students and badly injured two others — devastating the communities of Pine Plains and Stanfordville and all who knew them. The four teenage boys involved in the Thursday, Aug. 29, crash were all students at Stissing Mountain High School.

Both Zachary Pruner, 16, of Stanfordville, and Gian Paolo Stagnaro, 17, of Pine Plains, died as a result of injuries sustained in the accident. Dustin Hale, 16, of Pine Plains suffered life-threatening injuries and Niall Johnson, 16, also of Pine Plains, suffered non-life-threatening injuries.

There were grief counselors at the high school Friday; they will return Tuesday and Wednesday, the first day of school, to help students cope with the news.

According to the Dutchess County Sheriff’s Office, the accident occurred on Schultz Hill Road, roughly one mile south of State Route 199 in the town of Pine Plains, at approximately 3:45 p.m. 

Dustin was reportedly driving a 2000 Subaru Impreza northbound on Schultz Hill Road when he lost control of the vehicle. According to a press release from the Sheriff’s Office, “The vehicle then left the roadway, struck multiple trees and rolled over. [Zachary] was ejected and all other occupants stayed in the vehicle.”

Other news outlets have reported that Zachary was not wearing a seat belt at the time of the accident.

Dustin was air-lifted to Albany Medical Center while Niall was transported to St. Francis Hospital in Poughkeepsie.

The cause of the accident is still under investigation by members of the Sheriff’s Office Crash Investigation Unit, but initial findings from the Sheriff’s Office stated that “unsafe speed and reckless driving appear to be contributing factors.”

Autopsies are set to take place at the Dutchess County Medical Examiner’s Office on Saturday, Aug. 31.

In the meantime, town Supervisor Brian Coons said the most the community can do is support the victims’ friends and families.

“We are all in pain and pray for the recovery of the two boys currently hospitalized,” Coons said. “Growing up in a small rural community we have all shared these experiences, and we pray that from this tragedy we are reminded how precious and fragile life is.”

Full coverage will be available in the Sept. 5 edition of The Millerton News.

Latest News

Windy weather cancels Kent Invitational

Glastonbury High School crew attempted to battle wind and white caps on Lake Waramaug at the Kent Invitational that was ultimately cancelled, May 10.

Photo by Lans Christensen

KENT — The annual Kent Invitational regatta on Lake Waramaug did not start this year due to strong winds of 30 miles per hour on Saturday, May 10.

The gusts caused white caps on the lake's surface and boats were unable to stay in lane or arrange on the starting line.

Keep ReadingShow less
Masked, armed ICE agents arrest two men in Great Barrington as witnesses taunt, shoot video
Masked, armed ICE agents arrest two men in Great Barrington as witnesses taunt, shoot video
Masked, armed ICE agents arrest two men in Great Barrington as witnesses taunt, shoot video

GREAT BARRINGTON — Attarilm Mcclennon woke up on Tuesday morning to see a man standing on the fire escape and talking on the phone outside his apartment building in Barrington House.

When Mcclennon stepped out into the hallway that connects Main Street with the Triplex parking lot, he saw another man lingering there.

Keep ReadingShow less
Wake Robin developers reapply with P&Z
Wake Robin Inn is located on Sharon Road in Lakeville.
Photo by John Coston

LAKEVILLE — ARADEV LLC, the developer behind the proposed redesign of Wake Robin Inn, returned before Salisbury’s Planning and Zoning Commission at its May 5 regular meeting with a 644-page plan that it says scales back the project.

ARADEV withdrew its previous application last December after a six-round public hearing in which neighbors along Wells Hill Road and Sharon Road rallied against the proposal as detrimental to the neighborhood.

Keep ReadingShow less
Housatonic lax wins 18-6 versus Lakeview
Chloe Hill, left, scored once in the game against Lakeview High School Tuesday, May 7.
Photo by Riley Klein

FALLS VILLAGE — Housatonic Valley Regional High School girls lacrosse kept rolling Tuesday, May 6, with a decisive 18-6 win over Lakeview High School.

Eight different players scored for Housatonic in the Northwest Corner rivalry matchup. Sophomore Georgie Clayton led the team with five goals.

Keep ReadingShow less