This Critic Gives It a Thumbs Up

As a comic book fan, I became quite nervous when the reviews for “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice” were released. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film has a dismal 29 percent rating — 190 of the 268 critics collected on the site gave it a thumbs down.  

And yet, on that very same site, audience members shared their own reviews. Guess what? Out of more than 167,000 moviegoers, 73 percent liked it.

As both a critic and a fan, I cautiously walked into an IMAX theater on opening weekend, wondering which side of the coin I’d land on. I guess I need to hand in my Jaded Critics Association membership card, because I really enjoyed it.

First, some background: “Batman v Superman” is a sequel to 2013’s “Man of Steel,” which was a Superman reboot that retold the hero’s origin story and featured a destructive battle across Metropolis. These two films are the start of DC Comics’s extended movie universe, which will continue with “Suicide Squad” in August, followed by “Wonder Woman” and “The Justice League Part One” in 2017. Plans for other films stretch into 2020.

As you can see, a lot is riding on “Batman v Superman” — an entire series of movies balances on the shoulders of these two superheroes.

If you’ve seen any of the too-revealing trailers for “Batman v Superman,” you already know the basic plot. Batman (Ben Affleck) thinks Superman (Henry Cavill) is dangerous following that horrible battle in Metropolis. Superman thinks Batman is dangerous because he’s a vigilante who brands criminals with a bat symbol. Criminal mastermind Lex Luthor (Jesse Eisenberg) acts as a puppetmaster to get the two heroes to fight, since that’s what being a criminal mastermind is all about. Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot) shows up because the whole point of the film is to act as the dawn of the Justice League — hence the movie’s long title.

“Batman v Superman” clocks in at two-and-a-half hours, which for some may be a deal-breaker.  However, I was entertained the entire time. Superman — who’s basically a god to us mere mortals — is a controversial figure following “Man of Steel,” and it’s interesting to watch the world wrestle with whether he’s a hero or a threat. 

While Superman is new to this universe, Batman has been fighting criminals in Gotham City for 20 years with the help of Alfred (Jeremy Irons). Affleck is impressive in this role. As the vigilante, he’s massive and intimidating — there is one fight scene in particular that perfectly captures the speed and power of this character.

The biggest complaint from critics seems to be the film’s grim setting, but I thought it fit this universe. And watching Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman on-screen together, with an epic score by Hans Zimmer and Junkie XL, was — dare I say — fun.

Of course, it’s not a perfect film. Eisenberg’s version of Lex Luthor was a bit too over-the-top for my taste. He seemed more like a tamer version of the Joker than the shrewd businessman I was hoping for. Some of the cuts between scenes were a little abrupt. And while there are plenty of Easter eggs for comic fans that I personally enjoyed, I can see how they’d be confusing to the general audience. (Two dream sequences in particular had me scratching my head for a minute.)

“Batman v Superman” is a very divisive film. You may like it. You may hate it. But if the thought of watching Batman and Superman duke it out on the big screen sounds even remotely interesting to you, give it a shot.

“Batman vs. Superman” is rated PG-13 for violence, action and some sensuality. It is playing widely.

Latest News

Meet the Candidates: Salisbury

Get to know your candidates ahead of the 2025 municipal election. In Salisbury, Curtis Rand (D) is running unopposed for his 11th term as first selectman. There are three candidates for selectman. Below, each candidate offered information about themselves and their goals for the town.


Keep ReadingShow less
Fire claims old factory in Torrington
Stephanie Januszewski

Crews battled raging flames in the early hours of Sunday, Sept. 28, when an abandoned factory on High Street in Torrington caught fire. At 1 a.m. ladder trucks were deployed around the brick building to contain the fire, an effort which persisted well into daybreak. By 8 a.m., crews had still not entered the building due to unsafe conditions. No injuries were reported. The cause of the fire was unknown. Multiple departments responded from as far as Plainville and residents reported the smell of smoke from miles away. High Street remained closed on Monday with rubble in the road. The building once housed the Hendey Machine Company, which was among the largest employers in Torrington prior to the firm’s closure in the 1950s.

Horses heal: Time Out Foundation partners with Healing Hoofbeats in Lakeville

Corinne Kalser, MD, left, talks about the benefits of animals as therapy partners, as Renee Bouffard, LCSW, of Healing Hoofbeats of CT, on right, watches Harry Potter, a young horse at Time Out.In the background, Finnegan, lead horse at Time Out comes to see what’s going on.

L. Tomaino
“Horses and other livestock maintain their wild instincts. They sense what we are feeling and that makes them amazing therapy partners.”
— Renee Bouffard, LCSW

In 2008, Time Out Foundation became an official rescue and therapeutic riding facility, fulfilling a lifelong dream of founder, Corinne Kalser, M.D.With her husband, David McArthur, LCSW, and the rest of their staff, they offer a haven for children and adults through gentle, relaxed therapies centered around animals — rescued horses, dogs, cats, and goats — on their 35-acre farm in Lakeville.

To ensure the foundation continues, Kalser is partnering with Healing Hoofbeats of CT, an organization with a similar philosophy of care.

Keep ReadingShow less
A peaceful end at East Mountain House

The living room is light, airy, and quiet, with works from local artists on the walls...and no television.

Patrick L. Sullivan

Craig Davis and Keavy Bedell have opened East Mountain House in Lakeville. It is an end-of-life facility — a home, really — that can accomodate up to two guests at a time. The first guest arrived in mid-September.

The house, at 14 Bostwick St., is the one Davis shared with his wife Sandy Dennis, who died in 2020. Davis said her spirit lives on in the house itself and in the approach taken for the guests.

Keep ReadingShow less