Enemy of the people; or, war is hell

If the press doesn’t like being called the enemy of the people, perhaps it shouldn’t be waging war against the president of the people — or at least the president of the 63 million Americans who voted for Donald Trump.

Make no mistake — this is war. After the press decided that someone as crude and ignorant as Trump shouldn’t be the leader of the free world, it began an openly declared campaign of nuclear Armageddon against him, complete with mushroom clouds of invective every day. This assault began before Trump got to the Oval Office and has continued ever since.

To Trump’s supporters, the issue is not whether he interfered before the election, but that the press has interfered ever since by trying to overturn its result. Such a profoundly undemocratic effort makes the press a clear adversary to tens of millions of people.

New York Times columnist Bret Stephens says Trump will have blood on his hands if any of his followers get so worked up against the press at his rallies that a journalist gets killed. Stephens worries that Trump’s more rabid supporters might take his sloganeering against the press literally.

But it isn’t Trump’s followers that get hysterical over every chant or tweet. They know that much of Trump’s talk is just role playing, politicking, a thin skin, a brawling instinct and lack of finesse.

It is the press, rather, that takes every Trump utterance to extremes in order to make him look unhinged. That’s their strategy for taking him down. In wartime, propagandists depict the enemy as fanatical and evil. So it is with the press and Trump, the deranged Donald Strangelove.

Will the news organizations who constantly portray Trump as treacherous, treasonous and traitorous, a danger to the world who must be removed, have blood on their hands if he is assassinated by a zealot, or if one of his staff gets killed by an angry mob outside a restaurant?

Trump, of course, is not the first Republican president to be attacked by the press. He’s just the latest in a long line of GOP leaders to be caricatured and demonized. George W. Bush was attacked in strikingly similar fashion. He too was portrayed as ignorant, dangerous and divisive, ruining America’s reputation abroad and causing constitutional crises at home. The anger of the right against such coverage has been building for decades.

Like an army at war, the press is filled with rumor and speculation. It speculates constantly about the next shoe that might drop, the next witness that might turn. Armies also use spies, as does the press with its endless anonymous sources. The unsigned op-ed in the New York Times was just the latest.

One rule of military and political war is that the enemy of my enemy is my friend. The press demonizes everyone who works for Trump, yet if a former staffer turns on him, the turncoat temporarily becomes the gold standard for the press, no matter how reviled he or she was previously.

Most press alarms are not only incendiary but ridiculous. Trump isn’t going to destroy NATO. He doesn’t hate immigrants. He didn’t endorse Nazis at Charlottesville; he just declined to be bullied by the press into sweeping denunciations of everyone there. And even if he wanted to, Trump couldn’t have jailed Hillary Clinton after the election like some banana republic dictator. “Lock her up” was just a campaign jingle. Everyone got that except the press, which used it as just another weapon in its war against Trump.

Trump isn’t even more chummy with the Russians than Hillary was when she pushed the “reset button” as Secretary of State. When Trump compliments Vladimir Putin, he’s just gaming him, angling for leverage. Maybe it’s not diplomacy, but it sure isn’t treason.

As for the institutions that Trump habitually rips, most of them need shaking up, which is another thing Trump’s supporters grasp better than the press.

Everyone is aware that a free press is essential to democracy. So are the three branches of government, for that matter. Criticizing the former does no more harm than criticizing the latter. The institutions are healthier for it.

The poor maligned press isn’t used to constant counterfire from the bully pulpit. Maybe it should be. War is hell.

Mark Godburn is a bookseller in Norfolk and the author of “Nineteenth-Century Dust-Jackets.”

Latest News

Kent sets spring deadline for Swift House strategy

Kent Historical Society Curator Marge Smith initiated the tour of the historic Swift House in a vacant room that has been proposed as a new location for the town food pantry.

Alec Linden

KENT — Town officials are moving to decide the future of the long-vacant, town-owned Swift House, with the Board of Selectmen setting an April 30 deadline to identify a path forward for the historic building.

During a special meeting held by the BOS after a tour of the building early Saturday afternoon, Feb. 7, both of which were open to the public, First Selectman Eric Epstein proposed that the town establish an “investigation committee” that would review options for the structure, which has been on the tax roll for years without a clear plan.

Keep ReadingShow less
Taha Clayton’s ‘Historic Presence’ opens at Tremaine Gallery
‘Stoned Soul Picnic’ by Taha Clayton.
Provided

For Brooklyn-based artist Taha Clayton, history isn’t something sealed behind glass. It breathes, moves and stands before us in the bodies of everyday people. His upcoming solo exhibition, “Historic Presence” at the Tremaine Gallery at Hotchkiss, takes its philosophical cue from James Baldwin’s declaration that “History is not the past. It is the present.”

Clayton’s luminous portraits center on elders, friends and acquaintances whose quiet dignity embodies what he calls “the common everyday story” often missing from official narratives. “The historical is talking about something from the past,” Clayton said, “but these are men and women that are living in this day, walking with the ancestors, creating the stories.”

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

Bobby Graham and Matthew Marden: The story behind Dugazon
Bobby Grahamand Matthew Marden
Jennifer Almquist
"This truly is a dream come true...to create something containing all the things I’ve loved."
Bobby Graham


Bobby Graham and his husband, Matthew Marden, opened their home and lifestyle shop, Dugazon, in a clapboard house in Sharon six months ago. Word spread quickly that their shop is filled with objects of beauty, utility and elegance. Graham and Marden tell a story of family, tradition, joy, food, community and welcome.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bold flavors with a side of punk attitude at No Comply Foods

Steve and Julie Browning, co-owners of No Comply Foods in Great Barrington, have built a restaurant that reflects their skate-punk spirit and love of globally inspired comfort food.

Sara S. Wallach

At No Comply Foods in Great Barrington, skate culture, punk music and globally inspired comfort food collide in a pink frame house on Stockbridge Road where community matters as much as what’s on the plate. Opened in 2024 and named for a skateboarding trick, the restaurant hums with eclectic music while its walls double as a gallery of patron-gifted art — brightly colored skateboard cartoons, portraits of the owners’ pug, Honeybun, and offbeat collages.

High school sweethearts Julie and chef Steve Browning both loved skateboarding and punk music, especially the 90s California ska-punk band, Skankin’ Pickle. They also share a love for good food and a strong sense of community and fairness. After stints at Lutèce and the 21 Club in New York City, Steve helped open Prairie Whale in Great Barrington as the inaugural chef and worked there for 10 years. His partner, Julie, is a full-time special education teacher at Housatonic Valley Regional High School in Falls Village.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.