Weakening police immunity needs review

Sailing against a heavy political wind, Republican candidates for the General Assembly were heartened by the vigorous endorsements they received from police unions, which this year broke away from the government employee union apparatus in the Democratic Party.

The endorsements encouraged Republicans not because police officers are so numerous but because the public fears increasing disorder and crime amid the coronavirus pandemic and political hatefulness and violence, and the police are the public’s main defense.

Since some of the recent disorder and crime arises from protests against both the real and imagined use of excessive force by police against racial minorities, some people suspect that the Republican eagerness for police endorsements was anti-minority. After all, the unions are mad at Democratic legislators and Gov. Lamont for enacting the recent police reform legislation that was advocated by minority legislators. The new law purports to diminish the “qualified immunity” officers enjoy against personal lawsuits for their conduct on the job.

Police unions do have a lot to answer for. Like all government employee unions, they strive for more than due process of law for their members. They strive to defeat accountability altogether, as with the current State Police union contract, which supersedes Connecticut’s freedom-of-information law by forbidding disclosure of misconduct complaints that have been dismissed by police management. Of course without disclosure of all complaints, management itself cannot be evaluated and cover-ups can always prevail.

But critics of the police have a lot to answer for as well, like their silly calls to “defund” police precisely when disorder is worsening, as if any mistake or misconduct in police work eliminates the need for all police work.

Connecticut’s new police law has several excellent provisions, like its requirement for regular recertification of state troopers and its nullification of the State Police contract’s secrecy clause. But the law’s provision on immunity is questionable because its meaning and likely effect are not clear.

It’s no wonder police officers are resentful, and everyone should be concerned that once again the General Assembly didn’t know what it was doing except rushing to oblige the special-interest politics of the moment.

There is misconduct in all occupations. It is most important to expose and stop it in police work. But police officers are far more sinned against than sinning. If it condemns all for the mistakes or misconduct of a few, society will only imperil itself.

While the “qualified immunity” provision is demoralizing officers, it won’t take effect until July next year. It should be reconsidered authoritatively as soon as the Legislature reconvenes.

Chris Powell is a columnist for the Journal Inquirer in Manchester.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Lakeville Journal and The Journal does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Year in review: Community and change in North Canaan
Bunny McGuire stands in the park that now bears her name in North Canaan.
Riley Klein

NORTH CANAAN — The past year was marked by several significant news events.

In January, the town honored Bunny McGuire for her decades of service to the community with the renaming of a park in her honor. The field, pavilion, playground and dog park on Main Street later received new signage to designate the area Bunny McGuire Park.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: Cornwall’s community spirit defined the year

In May, Cornwall residents gathered at the cemetery on Route 4 for a ceremony honoring local Revolutionary War veterans.

Lakeville Journal

CORNWALL — The year 2025 was one of high spirits and strong connections in Cornwall.

January started on a sweet note with the annual New Year’s Day breakfast at the United Church of Christ’s Parish House. Volunteers served up fresh pancakes, sausage, juice, coffee and real maple syrup.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: Quiet change and enduring spirit in Falls Village

Matthew Yanarella shows children and adults how to make cannoli at the Hunt Library on Sept. 12.

By Patrick L. Sullivan

FALLS VILLAGE — The year 2025 saw some new faces in town, starting with Liz and Howie Ives of the Off the Trail Cafe, which took over the town-owned space at 107 Main St., formerly occupied by the Falls Village Cafe.

As the name suggests, the café’s owners have made a point of welcoming Appalachian Trail hikers, including be collaborating with the Center on Main next door on an informal, trail-themed art project.

Keep ReadingShow less
Year in review: Progress and milestones in Salisbury

Affordable housing moved forward in 2025, including two homes on Perry Street in Lakeville. Jennifer Kronholm Clark (with scissors) cuts the ribbon at one of the two affordable homes on Perry Street along with (from left) John Harney, State Representative Maria Horn (D-64) and housing Commissioner Seila Mosquera-Bruno.

By Patrick L. Sullivan

SALISBURY — Salisbury expanded its affordable housing stock in 2025 with the addition of four new three-bedroom homes developed by the Salisbury Housing Trust. Two of the homes were built at 26 and 28 Undermountain Rd, with another two constructed at the top of Perry Street in Lakeville.

Motorists and students from The Hotchkiss School will soon benefit from a new sidewalk along Sharon Road (Route 41) connecting the school to Lakeville village. In November, Salisbury was awarded $800,000 in state funding to construct the sidewalk along the southbound side of the road, linking it to the existing sidewalk between Main Street and Wells Hill Road.

Keep ReadingShow less