September not kind to investors

Historically, this is the month that the three main averages of the stock market usually perform the poorest. It doesn’t have to happen, but my advice would be to tread carefully in September.

The “September Effect” is a market anomaly worldwide. It is unrelated to any event or news. The Dow Jones Industrial Average as well as the S&P 500 Index have averaged a decline of 0.8% and 0.5% respectively since 1950 during this month. In the period from 1928 through 2021, the benchmark S&P had an even worse record, down 1% on average.

The only reasonable explanation might be that investors tend to cash in on gains made throughout the sleepy summer, but that’s just a guess. As for the historical track record, I pay attention, although I need more reasons than seasonality to make me wary.

In any event, stocks regained quite a bit of the August 5.5% sell-off by the end of the month. I was expecting a bounce and I got it. Quarterly corporate earnings helped somewhat. On average, earnings came in better than expected.

Volume has been extremely light throughout the month since most of the financial community was on vacation. Only skeleton staff manned the trading desks and that allowed traders to push the averages higher on fewer and fewer stocks.

The economic data this week also helped support the markets. Remember that bad economic news is good for the stock market right now. The weaker the data the higher the chance that the Fed will pause or even cease raising interest rates.

The second quarter Gross Domestic Product was revised downward by 0.3% to 2.1%.

The Fed’s key inflation indicator, the Personal Consumer Expenditure Index (PCE) came in as expected with a gain of 0.2%, which was no change versus last month.

On the jobs front, both the Jobs Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) and ADP National Employment Report data indicated that new job creation slowed substantially last month. Both data points are considered a leading indicator of the labor market. A recent non-farm payroll revealed that the economy only added 187,000 new jobs and the unemployment rate rose to 3.8%. Bad news for labor but good news for the Fed which wanted to see employment gains slow.

On another subject, the marijuana industry had a good week. Many pot stocks saw gains of between 30-50%. Several marijuana exchange-traded funds also spiked higher. Why?

The Health and Human Services, after reviewing the present status of marijuana in the U.S. at the behest of the Biden Administration, recommended to the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) that the classification of marijuana be changed from a Schedule 1 controlled substance to a Schedule III drug. What’s the difference?

A Schedule I drug is considered one “with no currently accepted use and a high potential for abuse.” A Schedule III substance has “moderate to low potential for physical and psychological dependence.” If the DEA were to re-classify marijuana, it would then be considered a drug like ketamine, anabolic steroids, and testosterone, which are all Schedule III drugs. The difference in schedules could provide a large boost in sales, cash flow, and profits for American-based pot purveyors. My advice is to hold back if you have an itch to play this sector.

All the stocks are up a huge amount and will likely be subject to profit-taking shortly.

The week before Labor Day weekend is usually up. Check that one off the list. The risk going forward during the next few weeks is that we pull back to re-test the lows made on the S&P 500 Index in mid-August. From a technical point of view, that would be perfectly normal. But, if we break that level (roughly 4,432 or -5.5% from here), then we could go even lower,

How much lower? A rough guess would be down to the 4,200 level give or take. 

 

Bill Schmick is a founding partner of Onota Partners Inc. in the Berkshires. None of his commentary is or should be considered investment advice.  Email him at bill@-schmicksretiredinvestor.com.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Lakeville Journal and The Journal does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Rhys V. Bowen

LAKEVILLE — Rhys V. Bowen, 65, of Foxboro, Massachusetts, died unexpectedly in his sleep on Sept. 15, 2025. Rhys was born in Sharon, Connecticut, on April 9, 1960 to Anne H. Bowen and the late John G. Bowen. His brother, David, died in 1979.

Rhys grew up at The Hotchkiss School in Lakeville, where his father taught English. Attending Hotchkiss, Rhys excelled in academics and played soccer, basketball, and baseball. During these years, he also learned the challenges and joys of running, and continued to run at least 50 miles a week, until the day he died.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kelsey K. Horton

LAKEVILLE — Kelsey K. Horton, 43, a lifelong area resident, died peacefully on Saturday, Sept. 27, 2025, at Norwalk Hospital in Norwalk, Connecticut, following a courageous battle with cancer. Kelsey worked as a certified nursing assistant and administrative assistant at Noble Horizons in Salisbury, from 1999 until 2024, where she was a very respected and loved member of their nursing and administrative staff.

Born Oct. 4, 1981, in Sharon, she was the daughter of W. Craig Kellogg of Southern Pines, North Carolina, and JoAnne (Lukens) Tuncy and her husband Donald of Millerton, New York. Kelsey graduated with the class of 1999 from Webutuck High School in Amenia and from BOCES in 1999 with a certificate from the CNA program as well. She was a longtime member of the Lakeville United Methodist Church in Lakeville. On Oct. 11, 2003, in Poughkeepsie, New York, she married James Horton. Jimmy survives at home in Lakeville. Kelsey loved camping every summer at Waubeeka Family Campground in Copake, and she volunteered as a cheer coach for A.R.C. Cheerleading for many years. Kelsey also enjoyed hiking and gardening in her spare time and spending time with her loving family and many dear friends.

Keep ReadingShow less
Eliot Warren Brown

SHARON — On Sept. 27, Eliot Warren Brown was shot and killed at age 47 at his home in New Orleans, Louisiana, in a random act of violence by a young man in need of mental health services. Eliot was born and raised in Sharon, Connecticut, and attended Indian Mountain School and Concord Academy in Massachusetts. He graduated from the School of the Art Institute of Chicago. He and his wife Brooke moved to New Orleans to answer the call for help in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina and fell in love with the city.

In addition to his wife Brooke, Eliot leaves behind his parents Malcolm and Louise Brown, his sisters Lucia (Thaddeus) and Carla (Ruairi), three nephews, and extended family and friends spread far and wide.

Keep ReadingShow less
Randall Osolin

SHARON — Randall “Randy” Osolin passed away on Sept. 25, 2025, at the age of 74. He was born on Feb. 6, 1951, in Sharon, Connecticut to the late Ramon (Sonny) and Barbara (Sandmeyer) Osolin.

He was a dedicated social worker, a natural athlete, a gentle friend of animals, an abiding parish verger, an inveterate reader, and an estimable friend and neighbor. He was a kind-hearted person whose greatest joy was in helping someone in need and sharing his time with his family and good friends.

Keep ReadingShow less