Study Suggests Retail Center Could Deliver Surge in Crime


A nationwide survey of the costs of providing local police services to large shopping centers raises some thorny questions about the proposed Widewaters mega-mall in Greenport and casts doubt on the town’s assurances of "minimal" tax and crime impacts from the project.

The 2006 survey cites widespread evidence that Wal-Mart stores, particularly the newer 200,000-square-foot "super-centers" of the kind considered for Greenport, lead to much more crime and place far greater demands on local police than mall developers or town planning officials usually anticipate.

The high costs of supporting a larger police presence is one of the reasons why centers like the 550,000-square-foot Widewaters plan typically lead to higher property taxes for town homeowners, despite the sizable tax receipts contributed by the new mall’s owners.

The survey "Crime and Wal-Mart," compiled data on police calls from 551 Wal-Mart stores around the country in an effort to quantify the financial and social costs to local communities of introducing or expanding the company’s dominating format into a community’s retail mix. (The full study is available at www.littletownviews.com under the "Members Mention" section of the Web site.)


u u u


Since the opening of super-centers in their towns, police chiefs across the country have voiced surprise at the steep increase in calls for assistance to their departments, according to the study, which was authored by WakeUpWalMart.com, a public awareness platform funded by national labor unions.

"If we had known the number of calls (from Wal-Mart), we probably would have considered an increase in officers" before signing off on the development proposal, stated the police chief of North Lebanon, Pennsylvania, a town with a population of 11,000.

The chief of a much smaller 2,500-resident town in Pennsylvania told the study’s authors that Wal-Mart "has completely changed the way we do business. It has overwhelmed us." He added that town tax revenues from the super-center did not come close to covering the higher costs incurred by his department.

The study points out that super-centers have a substantial impact not only on the number of calls to law enforcement, but on the severity of the crimes reported as well.

A large Wal-Mart store in the Albany suburb of Bethlehem has led to an increase in the number of serious criminals drawn to the super-center, including "gang members, drug addicts and thieves," according to a report by the Albany Times-Union, which tallied nearly 12,000 police responses to the store since its opening in 2004.


u u u


The developer of the Bethlehem store "was extremely low on his estimate" of calls from the Wal-Mart, the town’s police chief recently told the Times-Union.

The 4,200-resident town of Greenport, which spends roughly $130,000 annually on its own part-time police department and on patrols by state and county officers, would be faced with substantially higher budgets for law enforcement if the study’s estimate of 250-300 additional calls from a large Wal-Mart store alone prove accurate.

With a super-center accounting for less than half of Widewaters 550,000 square feet of rentable space, the mall would likely require additional police services to meet the demands of its other retail tenants. Moreover, most observers expect the new plaza to draw sales and merchants from the neighboring shopping plazas along Route 9, raising concerns that many current stores would be left vacant and could themselves become magnets for crime.

Despite repeated requests, Greenport officials have refused to provide details on police costs and call volumes in their town, which already hosts four shopping centers on Route 9, including a 75,000-square-foot Wal-Mart store.

If the trends identified in the "Wal-Mart and Crime" report and in similar studies prove relevant, the town will see a dramatic rise in public safety costs and may have to convert its current part-time police effort into a much more costly full-time department.

With ample evidence linking large-scale retail development to steep increases in law enforcement budgets, it would seem sensible for the Greenport Town Planning Board to enlist independent experts to estimate the particular demands that the Widewaters project, if approved, would place on the town’s police resources and on its taxpayers.


James Sheldon, a writer and financial consultant, lives in the Columbia County town of Gallatin. Visit www.littletownviews.com.


 

 

Latest News

Wake Robin public hearing closes

Aradev LLC’s plans to redevelop Wake Robin Inn include four 2,000-square-foot cabins, an event space, a sit-down restaurant and fast-casual counter, a spa, library, lounge, gym and seasonal pool. If approved, guest room numbers would increase from 38 to 57.

Provided

LAKEVILLE — The public hearing for the redevelopment of Wake Robin Inn is over. Salisbury Planning and Zoning Commission now has two months to make a decision.

The hearing closed on Tuesday, Sept. 9, after its seventh session.

Keep ReadingShow less
Judith Marie Drury

COPAKE — Judith Marie “Judy” Drury, 76, a four-year resident of Copake, New York, formerly of Millerton, New York, died peacefully on Tuesday, Sept. 2, 2025, at Vassar Bros. Medical Center in Poughkeepsie, New York, surrounded by her loving family and her Lord and savior Jesus Christ. Judy worked as a therapy aide for Taconic DDSO in Wassaic, New York, prior to her retirement on Feb. 1, 2004. She then went on to work in the Housekeeping Department at Vassar Bros. Medical Center for several years.

Born Jan. 2, 1949, in Richford, Vermont, she was the daughter of the late Leo J. and Marie A. (Bean) Martel. She attended Roeliff Jansen Central School in Columbia County, New York, in her early years. Judy was an avid sports fan and she was particularly fond of the New England Patriots football team and the New York Rangers hockey team. She enjoyed spending time with her family and traveling to Florida, Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, and Pennsylvania for many years. She was a longtime parishioner of Faith Bible Chapel of Shekomeko on Silver Mountain in Millerton as well.

Keep ReadingShow less
Jeremy Dakin

AMESVILLE — Jeremy Dakin, 78, passed away Aug. 31, 2025, at Vassar Brothers Medical Center after a long battle with COPD and other ailments.

Jeremy was a dear friend to many, and a fixture of the Amesville community. There will be a service in his memory at Trinity Lime Rock Episcopal Church on Sept. 27 at 11 a.m.

Keep ReadingShow less