Thank you!
Your support is sustaining the future of local news in our communities.

Why didn’t President John Kennedy put women in outer space decades ago?

The first all-female space walk was cancelled last week because NASA didn’t have space suits of the right size for both female astronauts. Most NASA suits are designed for men, who are larger. So the walk was changed to one woman and one man.

Predictably, this raised a cry about female victimhood in a male-dominated world. So a little background is in order.

In April, 1961, Russian cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin became the first man in space, but only after dogs, monkeys and other non-humans (including turtles, mice, fruit flies and plants) had gone up first “to test the survivability of spaceflight, before human spaceflights were attempted.”

Six weeks after Gagarin put the Soviets ahead in the space race, President John F. Kennedy told Congress that the United States “should commit itself to achieving the goal, before this decade is out, of landing a man on the moon and returning him safely to the Earth.”

JFK did not mention putting a woman on the moon too, or even into Earth’s orbit. Yet there was no outcry about discrimination. That’s because Kennedy was not discriminating against women. He was protecting them.

The early years of the space race was a time when rockets, both Soviet and American, frequently blew up on the launch pad. In 1967 three American astronauts, Gus Grissom, Edward White and Roger Chaffee, were killed in a fire when they were trapped inside their capsule during a launchpad test.

Early spaceflight included the risk of not even knowing what effect just being in space would have on humans. Astronauts returning from flights were quarantined until doctors made sure they hadn’t picked up any space viruses that might be transmitted to the rest of us. That’s why the order of risk-taking in space exploration was non-humans first, then men, then women.

Undoubtedly there were qualified women who could have gone into space in the Kennedy era. Female pilots had ferried fighter planes during World War II and performed other traditional male roles.

But sending women outside the atmosphere at that time was as unthinkable as putting children in harm’s way. When Grissom’s Mercury capsule splashed down in July, 1961, it and his suit filled with water. The capsule sank. He nearly drowned. John Glenn’s 1962 re-entry had a glitch which it was feared would incinerate him. Had JFK called for women in space he would have been pilloried for it and called a madman by everybody, including women.

 

When the Space Shuttle “Challenger” blew up in 1986, killing all on board, the only member of the crew the public remembered was Christa McAuliffe. That’s partly because the death of a woman was then and still is considered a greater tragedy than that of a man.

This is worth remembering in the NASA dustup. Feminist victim claims are often wrong. One example is Marisa Porges writing in The New York Times. Ms. Porges, ironically enough, is the head of an all-girl school (another vestige of female protection), although she sees no problem with that. She finds female discrimination against males useful and necessary.

Along with her rage at NASA for not having enough female accommodation, Ms. Porges notes that when she was a Navy pilot she had to sign a waiver because the ejection seat of her jet was designed for a man, not a smaller woman.

But again, there was a reason for that, and it wasn’t discrimination against women. If anything, it was discrimination against men. Only men flew in combat, only men were drafted to fight (an inequity Ms. Porges and other feminists are still in no hurry to fix), and thus it was only men for whom combat aircraft and other weapons were designed.

Same with space suits. Astronauts were chosen from the ranks of military test pilots, many of whom had seen combat in World War II, Korea or Vietnam.

Ms. Porges also raises the common complaint about women juggling parenting and workplace, while men supposedly skate. She doesn’t mention that at least women have flexibility and choice. Men usually don’t. Nor does she mention that women are compensated with a far larger share of child custody, which is a big reason they do more parenting. If men got a fair share, a lot more women would be free to devote a lot more time to the workplace.

Indeed, if we finally started to draft women for military service, fewer men would have to serve and the casualty rates might be a bit more equitable (it’s currently about 10 males for every female).

It’s time for real equality, not just the selective feminist kind. Not only in space suits but everywhere, even all-girl schools.

Mark Godburn is a bookseller in Norfolk and the author of “Nineteenth-Century Dust-Jackets” (2016).

Latest News

Lelah M. Somers

Lelah M. Somers

DOVER PLAINS — Lelah M. Somers, 97, a longtime Dover Plains, New York, resident, passed away peacefully on Saturday, Oct. 10, 2026, at Ferncliff Nursing Home in Rhinebeck, New York. Lelah was born on July 3, 1929, in Pawling, New York, to the late Byron and Lelah (Watts) Brill. Lelah grew up in Pawling and on Nov. 22, 1946, in Pleasant Valley, New York, she married James F. Somers, Sr. Mr. Somers passed away on Sept. 3, 1970. Lelah worked for New York State as a therapy aide for thirty-years and as a senior companion for New York State for thirty-two-years, with specific care provided to the mentally disabled.

She enjoyed taking care of the mentally disabled, was a wonderful mother to her four children, always putting her family first. She is survived by her son, James F. Somers, Jr. and his wife Donna of Dover Plains; two daughters, Doreen Monica of Wingdale, and Frances “Fran” Horton of Dover Plains, who was also her caregiver for many years; seven grandchildren, Debbie, Margie, Leah, Stephanie, Deirdra, Benji and Jimmy and several great grandchildren and great-great grandchildren, and many nieces and nephews, and her step-son, Kenny Elliott. In addition to her parents and husband, Lelah was predeceased by her daughter and son-in-law, Carol “DeeDee” Maile and Gil Maile, her son-in-law, Stephen Monica, and her son-in-law, Benny Horton as well as her companion of over forty-years, Andrew “Mac” McAlravey and her siblings, Ferris Brill, Eleanor Barryann, Richard Brill, William Brill and Barney Brill.

Keep ReadingShow less

The art of getting into art school

The art of getting into art school

Hudson Valley Regional Portfolio Day returns to Poughkeepsie.

Provided

For a young artist considering college, the question isn’t simply whether the work is good enough. It’s which work to show, which school might be the right fit and even whether a creative life can lead to a sustainable career.

On Friday, Oct. 16, hundreds of aspiring artists will have the opportunity to explore those questions at Hudson Valley Regional Portfolio Day, presented by The Art Effect at the MJN Convention Center in Poughkeepsie.

Keep ReadingShow less
A colorful life together at Atelier Valla

Textile designer Justine Valla sits in her father’s chair, which she painted, alongside her husband, illustrator and muralist Victor Valla, in their Atelier Valla studio.

L. Tomaino
I lost the ability to paint after the accident. I struggled to paint again.
— Justine Valla

Husband and wife Victor and Justine Valla share a lavender and pink studio, Atelier Valla, across the driveway from their pink house, nestled into a hillside in Salisbury. The colors, said Justine, “were inspired by Monet’s house at Giverny.”

Creating art has been a lifelong pursuit for both.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

David Ruchman’s “Acquired Taste”

Filmmaker David Ruchman

Bleacher and Everard Photography

In a region known for its vibrant but geographically scattered arts community, discovering something new can require a little effort. The same might be said for finding a new place for an extraordinary meal. While the Northwest Corner, Berkshires and Hudson Valley have no shortage of creative talent, opportunities to experience it — whether on a stage, in a gallery or on a plate — aren’t always just around the corner.

In David Ruchman’s short film “Acquired Taste,” that challenge becomes the premise for an unlikely friendship between Nick, an aspiring young food critic living in an area with limited dining options, and a gruff New York City master chef.

Keep ReadingShow less
Follow the Clay Way for ceramic delights

Jane Herold’s beautifully simple dinnerware.

Provided

As the leaves across Litchfield and Dutchess counties rush to make it to the ground, your last chance to peep autumn is fast approaching. On Oct.17 and 18, the 10th annual Clay Way offers peepers a route to follow lined with unique art that rivals the area’s natural beauty.

The two-day event is a ceramics-focused open studio tour through northwestern Connecticut, with a few studios peppered in just over the border in Dutchess County. Featuring nine open studios and 25 participating artists, the tour promises a wide variety of work, from decorative objects to grand vessels and a whole world in between.

Keep ReadingShow less
A new home for the unexpected at Kent Fine Art

CAMERON (1922-1995) is on view at Kent Fine Art in Pine Plains through Nov. 14.

Provided

Where can one find the work of an artist associated with occult rituals, surrealist visions and the underground California art scene? In a beautifully renovated former carriage house in Pine Plains, of course.

Unexpected discoveries are, after all, part of what Doug Walla has spent his career making possible. The longtime New York City art dealer and founder of Kent Fine Art, has brought the work of Marjorie Cameron Parsons Kimmel, known simply as Cameron, to his new gallery space. The exhibition, on view through Nov. 14, introduces visitors to an artist whose life and work moved between mysticism, poetry, film and the avant-garde.

Keep ReadingShow less
google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.

google preferred source

Want more of our stories on Google? Click here to make us a Preferred Source.