Juxtaposing present crises with those of the past

You might find the present in the past on any day of history you choose.

For instance, here’s a quote about another time:

“This is an age of the world where nations are trembling and convulsed. A mighty influence is abroad, surging and heaving the world, as with an earthquake. And is America safe? Every nation that carries in its bosom great and unredressed injustice has in it the elements of this last convulsion.”

Aside from an antique verbiage — one seldom mentions a nation’s bosom anymore — the un-lilted paragraph might be lifted from a column by George Will or even David Brooks, both of whom would surely posit answers as to America’s safety, or lack thereof, in the present moment.

In its time, however, the passage was more a prophecy than an observation. The author glimpsed a future involving a “last convulsion.” Harriet Beecher Stowe wrote it in a weekly serial published by “The National Era,” an antislavery newspaper in Washington, D.C., in 1851. The next year, the paper’s publisher wisely contracted with the author to publish the series as a book. Both were called “Uncle Tom’s Cabin.”

The juxtaposition of past on present inevitably brings to mind the apocryphal aphorism, “History doesn’t repeat itself, but sometimes it rhymes.” (Mark Twain is given credit; surely he’d accept it.) Mrs. Stowe made her prediction based on what she observed of the nation’s fraying cultural, political, and societal foundations in those antebellum years. Almost exactly a decade later, Confederate forces fired on Fort Sumter.

At present, the United States tolerates no slavery. In 1851, the country had no Trump. Yet there are similarities that force comparison:

The toxic effects of a recent unpopular, costly foreign war. Then: The Mexican War of 1846-8. Now: Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, take your pick.

Dubious presidents. Then: Polk, Zachary Taylor, Millard Fillmore, Pierce, Buchanan. Now: Trump.

Long-lasting and damaging economic struggles. Then: the financial Panic of 1837, the South’s monetary dependence on slavery, the North’s industry, its dependence on immigrant labor. Now: the financial crisis of 2008, fiscal inequality, and the creation of the 1% billionaire class...and recently, the revelatory stupidity of Trump’s tariff destruction.

Geographical expansion. Then: “Manifest Destiny,” the U.S. lust for more territory, not only for more than half of Mexico, but Cuba as another slave state. Now: Greenland, Panama, Canada as a 51st state, the Gulf of “America.”

The conflict between states. Then: slave-states v. free-states, leading to shooting wars between them, such as in “Bleeding Kansas.” Now: red states v. blue states, no wars yet, but countless pockets of preparation.

Many more comparisons can be found in the history. Could Mrs. Stowe’s future vision of a “last convulsion” be justified today, looking to 2035, a decade from now?

Could history indeed rhyme?

William Kinsolving is the author of five books. He will read and discuss his book “Dangerous Times” on May 15 at The Scoville Library, along with his wife Susan Kinsolving, who will also read and talk about her novel “The Head’s Tale.”

For more and reservations, go to scovillelibrary.libcal.com/event/14014494.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Lakeville Journal and The Journal does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Joseph Robert Meehan

SALISBURY — Joseph Robert Meehan the 2nd,photographer, college professor and nearly 50 year resident of Salisbury, passed away peacefully at Noble Horizon on June 17, 2025. He was 83.

He was the son of Joseph Meehan the 1st and his mother, Anna Burawa of Levittown, New York, and sister Joanne, of Montgomery, New York.

Keep ReadingShow less
Florence Olive Zutter Murphy

STANFORDVILLE, New York — It is with profound sadness that we announce the passing of Florence Olive Zutter Murphy, who went home to be with the Lord on June 16, 2025, at the age of 99.

She was born in Sharon, Connecticut on Nov. 20, 1925, and was a long time resident of the Dutchess County area.

Keep ReadingShow less
Chore Service hosts annual garden party fundraiser

Chore Service hosted 250 supporters at it’s annual Garden Party fundraiser.

Bob Ellwood

On Saturday, June 21, Mort Klaus, longtime Sharon resident, hosted 250 enthusiastic supporters of Northwest Corner’s beloved nonprofit, Chore Service at his stunning 175-acre property. Chore Service provides essential non-medical support to help older adults and those with disabilities maintain their independence and quality of life in their own homes.

Jane MacLaren, Executive Director, and Dolores Perotti, Board President, personally welcomed arriving attendees. The well-stocked bar and enticing hors d’oeuvres table were popular destinations as the crowd waited for the afternoon’s presentations.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bach and beyond
The Berkshire Bach Society (BBS) of Stockbridge will present a concert by cellist Dane Johansen on June 28 at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church.
Provided

The mission statement of the Berkshire Bach Society (BBS) reads: “Our mission is to preserve the cultural legacy of Baroque music for current and future audiences — local, national, and international — by presenting the music of J.S. Bach, his Baroque predecessors, contemporaries, and followers performed by world-class musicians.”

Its mission will once again be fulfilled by presenting a concert featuring Dane Johansen on June 28 at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church at 29 Main Street, in Stockbridge, Massachusetts.

Keep ReadingShow less