Without the proof, the rig is up

Every presidential election tends to follow a somewhat predictable pattern. As the candidates battle it out we, the voting public, take stock of what’s on offer and decide who to support based on a mix of policy, party and personality. The closer we get to Election Day the more we worry about everything from an unwanted “October Surprise” to what undecided voters will ultimately decide to which polls we should believe. The one thing we’ve never had to worry about—until now—is that the loser might refuse to accept the results of a fair and free election.

This new ‘normal’ would have been unthinkable a decade ago. How did we get here? There are plenty of theories (and culprits) to go around but that’s a topic for another day. The more pressing issue, as Nov. 5 fast approaches, is to debunk the myth that election fraud is widespread because failing to do so threatens the very foundation of our democracy.

Our election system is extremely decentralized, a feature that can be maddening at times (who, in Connecticut, doesn’t remember trying to understand what a hanging chad was 2000?). But this fragmentation does have its benefits, primary among them is that it makes conspiring to rig an election impossible. Other than enacting laws to protect the right to vote, the federal government has little to do with administering elections. Rather, the vast majority of election law is written (and enforced) at the state level. The states, in turn, rely on over 10,000 local jurisdictions across the country to administer elections, using a mix of paid staff and volunteers to maintain accurate voter rolls, mail out ballots, monitor the polls, count votes and certify the results. While election laws vary from state to state, they all include protective measures designed to ensure the process is secure, including strictly limiting access to ballots and keeping all election-related machines offline.

Has this combination of decentralization and protective measures worked? According to every organization that monitors election fraud, the answer is an unequivocal “yes”. Even the uber conservative Heritage Foundation, which maintains a database to track voter fraud, found that of 3 billion votes cast in federal elections since 2016, the percentage of fraudulent votes amounted to a miniscule .0000367.

The presidential election of 2020 was no different and, despite constant cries of a ‘rigged election’, no proof of widespread fraud has ever been found.

Trump’s legal team lost 60 of 61 court cases, with 50 of the cases being summarily dismissed due to lack of evidence. Even judges appointed by Trump were unimpressed with the arguments being presented and ruled accordingly. The lawsuits were so egregiously frivolous a number of his attorneys faced professional consequences, most notably Rudy Guilianni, who was disbarred.

Christopher Krebs, the Trump-appointed Director of CISA (Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency), was fired in November 2020 after repeatedly telling Trump there was no evidence of widespread fraud. When Krebs went before the Senate he testified, under oath, that the 2020 election was “the most secure in American history”.

Following the 2020 election, Dominion Voting Systems and Smartmatic — repeated targets of the Trump team’s claim of election fraud — sued various news outlets for defamation. Fox News had to pay Dominion $787.5 million in damages and Newsmax, eager to avoid an embarrassing trial, settled with Smartmatic for an undisclosed sum.

Recounts were conducted at the behest of Trump’s campaign in a number of swing states. Georgia’s three recounts confirmed Trump’s loss. Arizona allowed an outside firm with deep ties to the Republican party, Cyber Ninjas, to do a statewide recount, resulting in a net increase of 360 votes for Biden. Wisconsin did partial recounts in two counties and this, too, resulted in a net gain for Biden, adding 87 votes to his total.

It seems these days everyone feels entitled to their own facts, particularly with the fragmentation of media and the deluge of ‘information’ on social media platforms like X. But hard evidence, especially when it’s based on testimony given under oath, still matters. As do numbers. And all of the hard evidence and numbers that were litigated after the 2020 election prove there was no widespread voter fraud. Period.

Unfortunately, it doesn’t seem the story will end there. Trump and his allies are already laying the groundwork for the same unfounded lies about a rigged election if he loses again. This dishonesty should worry us all, even those who voted for Trump in 2020 and plan to do so again. Democracy depends on fair and free elections but it also depends on a shared reality and Trump’s “Big Lie” is inflicting lasting damage on both. If we value what makes America great, we need to hold sacred the ritual of casting a vote and, equally important, accepting the results if our candidate doesn’t win.

Susu Langlands lives in Lakeville.

The views expressed here are not necessarily those of The Lakeville Journal and The Journal does not support or oppose candidates for public office.

Latest News

Swinging into spring sports at HVRHS

HVRHS sophomore Wyatt Bayer will suit up for the Mountaineers' varsity baseball team.

Photo by Riley Klein

FALLS VILLAGE — With the arrival of warm weather, so too comes a new season of athletics at Housatonic Valley Regional High School.

The Mountaineers will field teams in five different sports for the spring season: baseball, softball, lacrosse, tennis and track and field.

Keep ReadingShow less
Northlight art show opens at Historical Society Gallery
One of a dozen artists participating in the Northlight Art Center’s 14th annual student exhibit is Cathleen Halloran, above, who paused for a photo by one of her several works on display. The opening reception at the Sharon Historical Society’s Gallery on Saturday, March 15, brought out a robust group of local art fans.
Leila Hawken

Fans of fine art filed into the Sharon Historical Society’s gallery on Saturday, March 15, for the opening reception of student works from the Northlight Art Center in Amenia, New York.

Northlight was founded in Sharon by Pieter Lefferts in 2010 and later moved to Amenia. This is the 14th year of the annual student exhibit.

Keep ReadingShow less
‘Urinetown’ makes use of brand new HVRHS auditorium

Tess Marks as Little Sally and Jackson Olson as Officer Lockstock in the Housatonic Musical Theatre Society production of "Urinetown."

Tom Brown

Last week’s Housatonic Musical Theatre Society production of “Urinetown” featured strong performances and superb choreography.

The remodeled auditorium at Housatonic Valley Regional High School made a big difference as well. New seats were a welcome addition, and the increased technical capability meant that the show was flawless from a production point of view.

Keep ReadingShow less
Race Brook Lodge: A timeless haven for music, art, and community

Race Brook Lodge

Lety Marcos

Tucked away on Under Mountain Road in Sheffield, Massachusetts, The Stagecoach Tavern dates back to the mid-18th century and offers fine dining in an enchanted setting. It also serves as the portal into the Race Brook Lodge, which harbors unique spaces for entertainment, lodging and wellness.

Intimate outdoor gathering areas are illuminated by strings of lights. A cluster of mid-century bungalows can be rented by guests who come to spend the weekend and attend concerts and retreats, which typically take place in the barns farther back in the woods.

Keep ReadingShow less