Forum dissects today’s national security landscape

Andrew Hoehn and Thom Shanker led the March 8 Salisbury Forum. The two reviewed the modern climate surrounding national security and global threats.

Patrick L. Sullivan

Forum dissects today’s national security landscape

FALLS VILLAGE — Andrew Hoehn and Thom Shanker said the U.S. needs more robust and responsive intelligence and action “machines” to respond effectively to global threats.

The two spoke at the Salisbury Forum Friday, March 8, at Housatonic Valley Regional High School. Alex Ward moderated.

Hoehn is a former deputy assistant secretary at the Defense Department, a member of the Council on Foreign Relations, and currently senior vice president for research and analysis at the RAND Corporation. Shanker is a veteran reporter for the New York Times and Chicago Tribune. Ward is a retired New York Times book editor.

Hoehn and Shanker just published a book: “Age of Danger: Keeping America Safe in an Era of New Superpowers, New Weapons, and New Threats.”

There was some initial fiddling around with microphones and positioning of armchairs, with audience participation. (“Speak up!”)

Logistics settled, Ward asked how the authors got together.

Hoehn said he met Shanker when he was at the Pentagon and Shanker was working for the Times.

He said he grew to respect Shanker’s reporting and found him trustworthy.

“He wasn’t about ‘gotchas.’ He was fair and accurate.”

When Hoehn moved to RAND, the two stayed in touch.

Asked about Russian strongman Vladimir Putin, Shanker called him, and post-Soviet Russia, “the threat hiding in plain sight.”

“Russia became a country the West ignored” after the collapse of the Soviet Union — “a gas station with rockets.”

He said a 2007 speech by Putin at the Munich Security Conference told the world “exactly what he was going to do.”

Acknowledging the peril of making comparisons to Adolf Hitler and the Nazis, he said Putin’s speech was like Hitler’s “Mein Kampf” in spelling out each man’s plans.

“Everybody wrote it off as bluster” aimed at a domestic audience. “And a year later, he invaded Georgia.”

Shanker said that after the Al Qaeda terrorist attacks on 9/11, the U.S. became focused on terrorism to the detriment of other threats.

He compared Putin to a Russian czar rather than a general secretary of the Communist Party. And he said the West “ignored Putin getting angrier and angrier.”

Hoehn explained the concept of “warning machines” and “action machines.”

The warning machine looks at all the “little pieces of information” that come in from numerous sources. The action machine, acting on the intelligence, comes up with a response.

Problems arise when the two machines aren’t working properly together.

Hoehn said that in the two years prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, he and Shanker spoke with intelligence and public health officials and asked what worried them the most.

The answer was a pandemic, which nobody thought the U.S. was prepared for.

At the time, Hoehn concluded, “We don’t have a warning machine or an action machine.”

Shanker added, “We never defined health as a national security problem before.”

And: “We need to define national security away from problems we solve by blowing them up.”

Ward asked if the country is now ready for another pandemic.

Hoehn replied. “Ready? No. A work in progress? Yes.”

He said strategic planners should use the war game model for identifying possible responses and problems in the event of another pandemic.

Asked about the current situation with Ukraine, the “fraying” of support for aid to Ukraine in the American political world, and Putin’s recent rattling of the nuclear saber, Shanker said “I’d never bet against anything he says.”

But he said he found it hard to see the tactical advantage Putin would gain by deploying nuclear weapons.

Shanker pointed out that support for Ukraine comprises about 5% of the defense budget, and expressed concern about shifting American attitudes.

“You don’t have to be partisan to say that this country used to support freedom and independence. There’s a dysfunctional situation in Washington, and both sides are guilty.”

The entire discussion can be seen at www.salisburyforum.org

Latest News

Lime Rock Park seeks detour permit for NASCAR event

Lime Rock Park is slated to host the NASCAR Craftsman Truck Series Friday and Saturday, June 27 to 28 in Lime Rock, Connecticut.

Photo by Nathan Miller

SALISBURY — At a special meeting Thursday, May 15, the Board of Selectmen tabled the issue of approving a permit for traffic rerouting on Route 112 Friday and Saturday, June 27 to 28.

Lime Rock Park is hosting a weekend of NASCAR events. In anticipation of a large crowd, estimated between 12,000 at 15,000 in attendance, LRP has asked to have one-way traffic on Route 112 (Lime Rock Road) from Route 7 to White Hollow Road and the main track entrance between 10 a.m. and 1 p.m. and again between 1 p.m. and 4 p.m. on both days.

Keep ReadingShow less
Falls Village budget hearing May 21
Photo by Patrick L. Sullivan

FALLS VILLAGE — The Board of Finance will hold a public hearing on the proposed spending plans for 2025-26 Wednesday May 21, 6:30 p.m. at the Emergency Services Center and on Zoom.

First Selectman Dave Barger will present the municipal plan and Board of Education Chair Pat Mechare will handle the plan for the Lee H. Kellogg School.

Salisbury approves town and elementary school budgets

SALISBURY — The spending plans for the town and Salisbury Central School were approved unanimously at a town meeting Wednesday, May 14. The vote was 26-0 on both budget items.

The Board of Finance will set the 2025-26 mill rate after a special meeting Wednesday, May 21, at noon.

Keep ReadingShow less
North Canaan vote on budgets, resident trooper set for May 21
North Canaan vote on budgets, resident trooper set for May 21
Photo by Riley Klein

NORTH CANAAN — The Board of Finance accepted spending proposals for the town and school at its regular meeting May 14.

The meeting was held immediately after a three-minute public hearing on the budgets. One resident spoke to ask about the selectmen’s salary line. This matter was also discussed by the finance board members in their meeting.

Keep ReadingShow less